Articles

What does 2N redundancy cost a data centre per MW compared with N+1, and what does it buy?

N+1 and 2N differ by one shared distribution chain. The capex premium is a fraction of the build cost and the benefit is the downtime that chain causes.

For a 10 MW hall, 2N power costs $1.8m a MW more than N+1, 18% of the build cost, and needs $21.97 a kW a month of extra rent at 10%. In return modelled downtime falls from 284 to 38 minutes a year, which pays a customer whose hall loses more than $10,717 a minute.

Learn the whole method: Data Center Development & Finance

A course built on one 60 MW campus, from grid tranches and cost per MW to leases, the power recharge, the construction loan, the refinancing and the stress tests, with Excel exercises, a 162-question quiz and the Data Center Development Model, Pro Edition included ($199).

Try module 3 and ten quiz questions, free →

The assumptions

Illustrative 10 MW data hall, invented figures
ItemValue
Critical load10 MW, served by UPS modules of 2.5 MW, so 4 modules carry the load
Module availability99.8% for each UPS module
Distribution availability99.95% for each switchgear and distribution chain
N+1 design5 modules in parallel on one distribution chain; the hall runs if at least 4 modules are up
2N designTwo independent paths, each with 4 modules and its own chain; the hall runs if either path is up
Capex per critical MWElectrical $3.0m with N+1, scaled by 2 ÷ 1.25 for 2N; mechanical $2.0m and shell and other $5.0m unchanged
Financing of the premium10.0% over 15 years, a capital recovery factor of 0.1315, plus 1.5% a year of extra maintenance

The model treats failures as independent. It has no common-cause failures, no maintenance windows and no human error, all of which narrow the gap in practice.

Step 1: availability of each design

N+1 modules: 0.9985 + 5 × 0.9984 × 0.002 = 99.9960%; with the chain at 99.95%, N+1 = 99.9460%

One 2N path: 0.9984 × 0.9995 = 99.153%; two paths: 1 − (1 − 0.99153)2 = 99.9928%

Downtime a year = (1 − availability) × 525,600 minutes: N+1 284 minutes, 2N 38 minutes

N+1 spends almost all its downtime on the single distribution chain: the 5-module block alone is 99.9960% available, which is 21 minutes a year. 2N removes the single chain.

Step 2: the capex and the rent the premium needs

Electrical capex with 2N = 3.0 × 2 ÷ 1.25 = $4.8m a critical MW; total 10.0 with N+1 and 11.8 with 2N, a premium of $1.8m a MW (18%)

Annual cost of the premium for 10 MW = 18.0 × (0.1315 + 0.015) = $2.637m

Extra rent = 2.637m ÷ (10,000 kW × 12) = $21.97 a kW a month

Excel, premium in $m a MW in B6, rate in B7: =B6*10*(-PMT(B7,15,1)+0.015)

Step 3: what a customer buys with the premium

Downtime avoided = 284 − 38 = 246 minutes a year

Break-even outage cost = $2.637m ÷ 246 minutes = $10,717 a minute for the hall

A customer whose 10 MW hall costs more than $10,717 for each minute it is down gains from 2N at $21.97 a kW a month; one that loses less pays for protection it does not value.

What if: the equipment is more or less reliable

Downtime a year by UPS module availability, minutes
Module availabilityN+12NMinutes avoidedBreak-even cost a minute
99.7%31081228$11,541
99.8%28438246$10,717
99.9%26811257$10,241

Module reliability changes the answer little: the minutes avoided range from 228 to 257 and the break-even from $11,541 to $10,241 a minute. The shared distribution chain, which 2N removes, is the same 99.95% in all three cases.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Free Excel template: data center financial model.

Questions readers ask

How much more does 2N cost than N+1?

In this model $1.8m a critical MW, from $10.0m to $11.8m, because only the electrical part doubles. That is 18% of the build cost.

How many minutes of downtime does 2N avoid?

246 minutes a year here: 284 for N+1 against 38 for 2N, with 99.8% UPS modules and 99.95% distribution chains.

When is 2N worth paying for?

When the customer’s loss exceeds about $10,717 a minute for the hall, the point where the $2.64m a year premium equals the downtime avoided.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Data Center Operations Handbook rebuild a 36 MW colocation campus month by month for three years after handover, with the operating checklists in editable form. The figures in this article use invented inputs and are not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on energy, infrastructure and land, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: infrastructure, data centre and energy investing → · All 1908 articles →