Articles

How much of its underwriting fee does a bank lose when a leveraged loan clears beyond its flex?

Flex lets the banks reprice the debt when investors demand more, but only up to a cap. Past the cap, the cost of selling the debt falls on the banks, and it can exceed the fee.

Three banks underwrite a $540 million term loan and $120 million of notes for a $16.5 million fee (2.5 per cent). At the final terms nothing is given up and the arranger’s 60 per cent share is $9.90 million. If the loan clears 25 basis points beyond the spread cap at 98.0, the banks give up $7.95 million and the arranger keeps $5.13 million. If it clears at 94.0 and the notes at 9.50 per cent, the banks lose $10.20 million net and the arranger $6.12 million.

Before a leveraged buyout is syndicated, the banks commit to fund it on terms that include flex: a right to raise the spread, lower the price or raise the coupon if the market demands it. Flex has limits. This article follows the Kestrel financing in the book through three outcomes and asks how much of the fee each one leaves.

The assumptions

ItemValue
Term loan B$540.0 million
Senior unsecured notes$120.0 million
Underwriting fee on loan and notes, three banks2.5%
Term loan spread at commitment / spread flex3.50% / 0.50%
Price flex floor98.5
Notes coupon cap9.00%
Price points per basis point beyond the spread cap0.03
Notes duration (years)4
Arranger’s share of the commitment60%
The 0.03 points per basis point is the case’s three-year-life assumption (0.75 point per 25 basis points). The cost on the notes is yield above the cap times duration times size.

Step 1: the fee and the flex cap

The banks earn the fee only if they can sell the debt on terms within flex:

Fee = 2.5% × (term loan + notes). Spread cap = commitment spread + spread flex. In Excel: =B3*(B1+B2) and =B4+B5.

2.5% × (540 + 120) = 0.025 × 660 = $16.5 million. The spread cap is 3.50% + 0.50% = 4.00%. The arranger’s share of the fee is 60% × 16.5 = $9.9 million.

Step 2: the final terms: nothing given up

At the final terms the loan clears at a spread of 3.75%, inside the 4.00% cap, at a price of 99.0, above the 98.5 floor. The notes clear at 8.00%, below the 9.00% cap. Nothing is given up: the banks keep the whole $16.5 million and the arranger keeps $9.90 million.

Step 3: a loan that clears beyond the cap

Now suppose the loan clears at a spread of 4.25% and a price of 98.0, and the notes at 9.25%. The spread is 25 basis points beyond the cap, and the banks must make up that gap with price:

Sale price = clearing price − basis points beyond the cap × points per basis point. Banks give up = (floor − sale price) × loan, if positive. In Excel: =B6-B7*0.03/100 and =MAX(0,0.985-B8)*540.

25 × 0.03 = 0.75 points, so the sale price is 98.00 − 0.75 = 97.25. That is 1.25 points below the 98.5 floor, and 1.25% of 540 = $6.75 million. The notes are 25 basis points over the cap: 0.0025 × 4 years × 120 = $1.20 million. The fee left is 16.50 − 6.75 − 1.20 = $8.55 million, and the arranger’s 60 per cent is $5.13 million.

Step 4: a loan that needs a deep discount

In the second case the spread is exactly at the 4.00% cap, so there is no repricing beyond it, but the loan clears at 94.0 and the notes at 9.50%. The loan gives up (98.5 − 94.0) = 4.50 points on 540, or $24.30 million. The notes are 50 basis points over the cap: 0.005 × 4 × 120 = $2.40 million. Together the banks give up $26.70 million against a fee of $16.5 million, so they lose $10.20 million net and the arranger bears 60% × 10.20 = $6.12 million.

Final termsWhat-if 1What-if 2
Loan clearing spread3.75%4.25%4.00%
Loan clearing price99.0098.0094.00
Basis points beyond the cap0250
Sale price after the cap adjustment99.0097.2594.00
Banks give up on the loan ($m)0.006.7524.30
Banks give up on the notes ($m)0.001.202.40
Fee left, three banks ($m)16.508.55−10.20
Arranger share, 60% ($m)9.905.13−6.12
The fee is 16.5 million in every case. Only the second what-if turns the fee into a loss.

Step 5: the price at which the fee runs out

The fee covers a price shortfall of 16.5 ÷ 540 = 3.06 points on the loan alone, so with no cost on the notes the loan must be sold above 98.5 − 3.06 = 95.44 for the fee to last. If the notes also clear at 9.50%, the $2.40 million used there leaves 14.1 for the loan, and the break-even price is 98.5 − 14.1 ÷ 540 = 95.89. In Excel: =0.985-(fee-notes_cost)/TL.

What if the banks held the loan instead of selling it?

The common mistakes

Takeaway

The fee is $16.5 million only on paper. Compute the spread beyond the cap, turn it into price, add the cost on the notes and subtract the total from the fee. In this case a loan clearing at 98.0 leaves $8.55 million of the fee, and one clearing at 94.0 produces a loss of $10.20 million. The loan must sell above 95.44 for the fee to cover the price concession. For the financing itself, see The Leveraged Finance Banker.

Reproducing it in the workbook

The inputs are in Leveraged_Finance_Model.xlsx: rows 13 to 24 and 37 to 44 of the Inputs sheet hold the debt, fee, flex, caps and what-if clearing terms. The Flex sheet computes the basis points beyond the cap, the sale price, what the banks give up on the loan and the notes, the fee left and the arranger’s share, for the final terms and the two what-ifs. The break-even price above is not in the workbook; it uses the same inputs.

Questions readers ask

How much of the underwriting fee does a bank lose when a loan clears beyond flex?

Whatever the price shortfall below the floor and the coupon excess over the cap cost. In this case a loan clearing at 98.0 and notes at 9.25% cost $7.95 million of the $16.5 million fee.

How is spread beyond the cap turned into price?

At 0.03 points per basis point here, a three-year life assumption. A spread 25 basis points over the cap is worth 0.75 point, so a loan clearing at 98.0 must be sold at 97.25.

At what price does the underwriting fee run out?

About 95.44 for the loan with no cost on the notes, because the fee equals 3.06 points of the term loan below the 98.5 floor.

Run the numbers yourself: the free LBO model template works a complete buyout in Excel, from entry and debt to exit and sponsor IRR. For a seven-year model with four debt tranches, covenants and a management ratchet, see the LBO Model, Pro Edition ($99). Watch the five-minute demo.

The workbooks behind this article

Every figure above is built from the inputs in the free companion files for The Leveraged Finance Banker, which also hold the Kestrel sources and uses, a five-year projection with sweep, a recovery waterfall and a refinancing and liability management case. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 36 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on how to read the documents, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: credit, private credit and distressed debt → · All 1908 articles →