Articles

How long can a bank hold a hung leveraged loan before the markdown is earned back?

A loan the syndicate cannot place sits on the bank balance sheet and earns carry while it waits. The carry sets how long, and how much price decline, the bank can afford to wait.

A bank holding $600 million of an unplaced leveraged loan at SOFR plus 4.25%, funded at SOFR plus 0.60%, earns a net spread of 3.65%, or $1.825 million a month. A 2-point markdown, $12 million, takes 6.6 months to earn back, and 10.3 months once capital is charged at $0.660 million a month. Holding six months buys a cushion of 1.17 points of price on the net carry.

When a syndicate cannot place a leveraged loan at the price it committed to, the underwriting banks keep the unsold part. They did not choose to hold it, but while they do it earns, and the earnings set a time budget. The question for the desk is how long it can wait for a better price before the carry is no longer enough to offset the loss on the position.

The assumptions

One illustrative hung loan
ItemValue
Unplaced loan held$600 million
SOFR4.30%
Loan margin4.25%
Internal funding cost, SOFR plus0.60%
Risk weight100%
Capital ratio held11%
Cost of equity12%
Markdown if sold now2.0 points

Step 1: carry per month

Net carry rate = (SOFR + margin) − (SOFR + funding spread) = margin − funding spread

Monthly carry = loan × net carry rate / 12

Excel: =Loan*(Margin-FundingSpread)/12

Margin 4.25% less funding spread 0.60% = 3.65%. On $600 million that is 600 × 3.65% = $21.90 million a year, or $1.825 million a month. SOFR drops out because both sides float.

Step 2: the capital charge

The loan uses capital. The charge is the loan, times the risk weight, times the capital ratio, times the cost of equity.

Capital charge per year = loan × risk weight × capital ratio × cost of equity

600 × 100% × 11% × 12% = $7.920 million a year, which is $0.660 million a month. Net carry is 1.825 − 0.660 = $1.165 million a month.

Step 3: months to earn back the markdown

A 2-point markdown on $600 million is 600 × 2.0% = $12 million. Divide by the carry.

Gross: 12 / 1.825 = 6.6 months. After capital: 12 / 1.165 = 10.3 months.

Step 4: the price cushion over time

Turn the question around: if the bank holds for m months, how far can the price fall before it would have been better to sell today? The answer is the net carry earned, in points of par.

Carry earned and price cushion by holding period ($ million)
Months heldGross carryCapital chargeNet carryCushion (points of par)
11.830.661.170.19
35.481.983.500.58
610.953.966.991.17
916.435.9410.491.75
1221.907.9213.982.33

At six months, 6.99 / 600 = 1.17 points. The bank is indifferent between selling now at 98 and holding six months to sell at 96.84.

What if: the loan clears at 99

A 1-point markdown is $6 million. It takes 3.3 months to earn back gross and 5.2 months after capital. Halving the markdown halves the wait, so a small improvement in the clearing price is worth more than a large improvement in the carry rate.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What does a bank earn while it holds a hung loan?

The loan coupon less its funding cost. At SOFR plus 4.25% against SOFR plus 0.60% that is 3.65% a year, $1.825 million a month on $600 million.

Why include a capital charge?

Holding the loan uses regulatory capital that could be used elsewhere. At a 100% risk weight, an 11% capital ratio and a 12% cost of equity, the charge is 1.32% of par a year, $0.660 million a month.

Does a falling SOFR change the carry?

No. Both the coupon and the funding cost float, so the net carry stays at 3.65% whatever SOFR does. It would change only if the loan carried a SOFR floor that binds while the bank's funding cost keeps falling.

Run the numbers yourself: the free LBO model template works a complete buyout in Excel, from entry and debt to exit and sponsor IRR. For a seven-year model with four debt tranches, covenants and a management ratchet, see the LBO Model, Pro Edition ($99). Watch the five-minute demo.

The workbooks behind this article

The workbooks for this book follow a leveraged financing from commitment to syndication, with the fee, flex and pricing arithmetic in live formulas. The hold-period table in this article is a separate illustration and is not in them.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 11 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on banking, credit and payments, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: credit, private credit and distressed debt → · All 1908 articles →