Articles

How much does one turn of exit multiple move the price a continuation vehicle can pay?

A continuation vehicle price is a bet on the exit multiple. The bet can be sized in points of NAV before the price range is accepted.

On an asset earning 40 of EBITDA today, valued at 10 times with 150 of debt (NAV 250), a buyer who needs 18% a year for four years can pay at most 203.3, which is 81.3% of NAV. Each turn of exit multiple moves that ceiling by 28.1, or 11.2 points of NAV: at a 9 times exit the ceiling falls to 175.3 (70.1% of NAV), and each point of required return moves it by 6.7.

Whoever sets the price of a continuation vehicle is making a forecast, and the forecast that matters most is the multiple at which the asset will be sold. A fairness opinion, a bid range or a reserve price all rest on it. For an investor choosing between cash and a roll, the useful question is not whether the discount to NAV looks wide, but how many turns of exit multiple it is worth.

The assumptions

One illustrative single-asset vehicle
ItemValue
EBITDA today40.0
EBITDA growth a year8.0%
Holding period4 years
Valuation multiple today10.0x
Net debt, held constant150.0
NAV (40 × 10 − 150)250.0
Buyer’s target gross return18.0% a year

Step 1: EBITDA at exit

Exit EBITDA = EBITDA today × (1 + growth)t

Excel: =E0*(1+g)^t

40 × 1.084 = 40 × 1.3605 = 54.42.

Step 2: the most a buyer can pay

The buyer receives the exit equity: exit EBITDA times the exit multiple, less the debt. Discounting it at the target return gives the ceiling price.

Ceiling price = (exit EBITDA × exit multiple − debt) / (1 + r)t

Excel: =(E4*Mult-Debt)/(1+r)^t

At a 10 times exit: 54.42 × 10 = 544.20; less 150 = 394.20. Divide by 1.184 = 1.9388: 203.3, or 81.3% of the NAV of 250 (a discount of 18.7%).

Step 3: the grid

Ceiling price for the equity (NAV 250)
Exit multipleAt 15%At 18%At 20%At 22%At 18% as % of NAV
8.0x163.2147.2137.6128.858.9%
9.0x194.3175.3163.9153.470.1%
10.0x225.4203.3190.1177.981.3%
11.0x256.5231.4216.3202.592.6%
12.0x287.6259.5242.6227.1103.8%

Down a column, every turn adds the same amount: at 18%, 54.42 / 1.9388 = 28.07. Across a row the steps are unequal because the discount factor compounds: at 10 times, moving from 18% to 19% costs 6.7 of price (2.7 points of NAV).

Step 4: how many turns the discount is worth

The marked NAV assumes 10 times. A buyer at 18% pays 203.3, so the 46.7 gap to NAV is worth 46.7 / 28.07 = 1.66 turns of multiple. Put the other way, a bid at full NAV of 250 only earns 18% if the exit multiple is 11.66 times: 250 × 1.184 = 484.7, plus 150 of debt = 634.7, over 54.42 of EBITDA.

What if: the debt is 250, not 150

Keep the enterprise value at 400 and raise the debt to 250. NAV falls to 150. The ceiling at a 10 times exit is (544.20 − 250) / 1.9388 = 151.7, 101.2% of NAV, and at a 9 times exit it is 123.7, 82.4% of NAV. A turn is still worth 28.07 in money, but now 18.7% of NAV instead of 11.2%. The same exit-multiple view moves the discount much further when the vehicle carries more debt.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How much is one turn of multiple worth to a buyer?

Exit EBITDA divided by one plus the target return, to the power of the years held. With 54.42 of EBITDA at exit, an 18% target and four years, one turn is worth 28.07 of price today.

Does the debt change what a turn is worth?

Not in money: a turn is worth the same 28.07 at 150 or 250 of debt. It changes the share of NAV, from 11.2% at 150 of debt to 18.7% at 250, because the equity is smaller.

Is a bigger discount to NAV always safer for the buyer?

No. It is safer only against the exit multiple that produced it. In this example a price at NAV needs a 11.66 times exit to earn 18%, and a 18.7% discount needs exactly 10 times.

Run the numbers yourself: the free LBO model template works a complete buyout in Excel, from entry and debt to exit and sponsor IRR. For a seven-year model with four debt tranches, covenants and a management ratchet, see the LBO Model, Pro Edition ($99). Watch the five-minute demo.

The workbooks behind this article

The Thalia workbooks price a continuation fund on the book’s own figures, from first discussion to closing. The grid in this article is a separate illustration and is not in them.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on markets, funds and compliance, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: private equity and private markets → · All 1908 articles →