Articles

How much do transaction costs shrink the headline discount on a continuation vehicle?

The price of a continuation vehicle is quoted as a discount to net asset value. The buyer pays the costs on top, and the discount that matters is the one left after them.

A continuation vehicle that buys a $1,000 million portfolio at an 8.0% headline discount pays $920.0 million, but with 2.5% of transaction costs the buyer’s cost is $943.0 million and the effective discount is 5.70%. If the portfolio grows 1.35x over four years, the multiple falls from 1.467x to 1.432x and the IRR from 10.06% to 9.38%. To keep an effective 8.0% after costs, the headline discount must be 10.24%.

The assumptions

Illustrative continuation vehicle, US$ millions
ItemValue
Net asset value of the portfolio1,000.0
Headline discount to NAV8.0%
Transaction costs, on the purchase price2.5%
Growth of the portfolio over four years1.35x NAV
Holding period4 years

Costs here are advisory, legal and structuring fees borne by the new vehicle. Carry, management fees and the roll of the existing manager’s stake are left out so that only the cost of the deal moves the answer.

Step 1: the cost basis

Price = NAV × (1 − headline discount). Cost basis = price × (1 + cost rate)

Effective discount = 1 − cost basis ÷ NAV

Excel: =B2*(1-B3)*(1+B4) and =1-C2/B2

Price: 1,000.0 × 0.92 = $920.0 million. Costs: 2.5% × 920.0 = $23.0 million. Cost basis: $943.0 million. Effective discount: 1 − 943.0 ÷ 1,000.0 = 5.70%, 2.30 points less than the headline.

Step 2: what it does to the return

Multiple = growth × NAV ÷ cost basis. IRR = multiple1/4 − 1

Excel: =1.35*B2/C2 and =D2^(1/4)-1

Cost of 2.5% against the headline discount, four years at 1.35x
Headline discountPriceCostsEffective discountMultipleIRR
5%950.023.82.62%1.386x8.51%
8%920.023.05.70%1.432x9.38%
10%900.022.57.75%1.463x9.99%
12%880.022.09.80%1.497x10.61%
15%850.021.312.88%1.549x11.57%

At 8.0%, the multiple is 1,350.0 ÷ 943.0 = 1.432x and the IRR 9.38%, against 1.467x and 10.06% before costs. Costs take 0.68 points of IRR here. Across the table, costs remove between 2.12 and 2.38 points of discount, because they are charged on the price, not on NAV.

Step 3: the headline discount you need

Headline discount needed = 1 − (1 − target effective discount) ÷ (1 + cost rate)

Excel: =1-(1-B5)/(1+B4)

For an effective 8.0%: 1 − 0.92 ÷ 1.025 = 10.24%. A headline discount of 10.24% is needed to deliver 8.0% after 2.5% of costs, 2.24 points more.

What if: costs are 4.0%

With 4.0% of costs, the cost basis is 956.8 and the effective discount of an 8.0% headline falls to 4.32%. The multiple is 1.411x and the IRR 8.99%. To still deliver 8.0% effective, the headline must be 11.54%.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How do transaction costs change the discount on a continuation vehicle?

They raise the cost basis. At an 8.0% headline discount and 2.5% costs on the price, the effective discount is 5.70%.

What headline discount delivers an effective 8.0% after 2.5% of costs?

10.24%. The formula is 1 − (1 − 8.0%) ÷ 1.025.

How much IRR do transaction costs take from a continuation vehicle buyer?

At 1.35x over four years, 0.68 points: 9.38% against 10.06%. At 4.0% costs the IRR is 8.99%.

The workbooks behind this article

The Thalia workbooks price a continuation fund on the book’s own figures, from first discussion to closing. The grid in this article is a separate illustration and is not in them.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 36 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on how to read the documents, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: private equity and private markets → · All 1908 articles →