Articles

eProcurement savings: what a project saves, worked case

The business case says one number, the accounts show another. Three sources of saving, each counted twice.

eProcurement savings come from three places: more spend bought at contract prices, cheaper purchase-to-pay processing, and supplier discounts that faster approval makes it possible to take. On an illustrative company with $80 million of indirect spend, the business case adds up to $3.81m a year. What reaches EBITDA at full adoption is $2.25m, 59% of that, and after the software subscription the project pays back its $1.50m set-up in 1.9 years.

Related reading: The Private Equity Operating Partner by Julian R. Sterling works its subject on one fully specified case, with free companion workbooks. The figures below are an illustrative case built for this article.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or see it on Amazon

Where eProcurement savings come from

Each of the three is real, but each has a version that a vendor's business case reports and a version that shows up in the accounts. The case below calculates both.

The assumptions

Illustrative mid-sized company, annual figures
ItemValue
Indirect spend addressable through the catalog$80,000,000
Share bought on contract, before and at full adoption50% and 85%
Contract price below off-contract price7%
Leakage after signature15%
Purchase orders a year; cost per order before and after30,000; $95 and $40
Roles actually removed from purchasing and accounts payable6 at $70,000
Supplier spend with 2/10 net 30 terms now captured$10,000,000
Set-up, subscription, change management in year 1$1,500,000, $350,000 a year, $250,000

The calculation

Price saving = spend × (on-contract share after − before) × price gap × (1 − leakage)

= $80,000,000 × (85% − 50%) × 7% = $1,960,000 before leakage, $1,666,000 after

Process saving claimed = 30,000 × ($95 − $40) = $1,650,000; in EBITDA = 6 roles × $70,000 = $420,000

Discount = $10,000,000 × 2% = $200,000, less the cost of paying 20 days early at 6%: $32,219, net $167,781

Run-rate EBITDA saving = $1,666,000 + $420,000 + $167,781 = $2,253,781, 2.8% of addressable spend

The business case total of $3,810,000 differs in two places. It counts the $1,650,000 of freed time as a saving, when only the 6 roles that are not refilled reduce cost; the rest is capacity the team uses for something else. And it counts the price and discount gains gross, before leakage and the cost of cash. How a buyer tests a procurement saving against last year's price, rather than budget, is set out in how to calculate procurement savings and their EBITDA impact; the same discipline applies here.

Payback over five years

Benefits ramp with adoption; set-up of $1,500,000 paid in year 0
YearAdoptionBenefitRunning costNetCumulative
Year 140%$901,512$600,000$301,512$-1,198,488
Year 275%$1,690,336$350,000$1,340,336$141,848
Year 3100%$2,253,781$350,000$1,903,781$2,045,629
Year 4100%$2,253,781$350,000$1,903,781$3,949,410
Year 5100%$2,253,781$350,000$1,903,781$5,853,190

Payback = 1.9 years; five-year NPV at 10% = $3,794,562; net benefit over five years = 4.9 times the set-up cost

Year 1 nets only $301,512, because adoption is partial and change management is paid on top of the subscription. That is normal, and it is why a one-year payback claim should be read with care. The payback mechanics are the same as for any one-off cost against a recurring saving, as in how to calculate restructuring payback.

What decides the result: adoption

Steady-state net saving after the $350,000 subscription, by on-contract share reached
On-contract sharePrice saving after leakageNet annual saving
65%$714,000$951,781
75%$1,190,000$1,427,781
85%$1,666,000$1,903,781
95%$2,142,000$2,379,781

Every ten points of spend moved on contract is worth $476,000 a year here. A system that users route around delivers the subscription cost and little else, so the project plan should track on-contract share monthly, by category, from the first go-live.

Takeaway

Count eProcurement savings as price compliance after leakage, roles removed, and discounts net of the cost of paying early. Here that is $2,253,781 a year against a $3,810,000 business case, a 1.9-year payback and a five-year NPV of $3,794,562.

Questions readers ask

How do you calculate eProcurement savings?

Add the price saving on spend moved on contract after leakage ($1,666,000 here), the cost of roles actually removed ($420,000) and early payment discounts net of the cost of paying early ($167,781). The total, $2,253,781, is the run-rate EBITDA saving.

Are process savings from eProcurement real?

Only to the extent that cost leaves the business. 30,000 purchase orders at $55 less each is $1,650,000 of time; if 6 roles are not refilled, $420,000 reaches EBITDA.

What is a typical eProcurement payback period?

It depends mainly on adoption. In this case, with 40% adoption in year 1 and full adoption from year 3, the $1,500,000 set-up is repaid in 1.9 years.

Run the numbers yourself: the free LBO model template works a complete buyout in Excel, from entry and debt to exit and sponsor IRR. For a seven-year model with four debt tranches, covenants and a management ratchet, see the LBO Model, Pro Edition ($99). Watch the five-minute demo.

Go further

This article applies the method to an illustrative case built for it. The Private Equity Operating Partner works its own fully specified case chapter by chapter, and every figure it prints is a live formula in the free companion workbooks.

Get the book on Amazon →Free companion files

Also on Amazon UK · Amazon Germany · Amazon France · Amazon Canada

Prefer a PDF? The same book is sold as a DRM-free PDF edition, searchable and printable. Get the PDF edition, $19.99

Not on Amazon: 24 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on insurance and retirement, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: private equity and private markets → · All 1908 articles →

If this book helped, or didn’t, a few lines on Amazon are worth more than they look: they are what the next reader goes on. Write a review. The workbook stays free either way.