Articles

When is re-bidding a janitorial contract worth the cost and risk of switching vendors?

The saving on a re-bid is not the difference between two prices. Switching cost and the chance of a bad vendor take part of it, and the incumbent may match.

A $1.45-a-sq-ft bid against a $1.60 incumbent saves $60,000 a year on a 400,000 sq ft office. After $70,000 of switching cost and a 25% chance that the new vendor fails, the bid is worth $43,655 over 3 years at 8%, not the $154,626 of the headline saving. An incumbent that matches at $1.50 is worth $103,084.

The assumptions

Illustrative office building, invented figures
ItemValue
Building400,000 sq ft office
Incumbent janitorial contract$1.60 a sq ft a year, $640,000, with a 3-year term to re-bid
New vendor bid$1.45 a sq ft a year, $580,000, a saving of $60,000 a year
One-off cost of switchingMobilisation, badges, supplies and a parallel run $45,000; service credits and complaints in the first quarter $25,000; total $70,000
If the new vendor failsReplaced after year 1 by a vendor priced at the incumbent’s $1.60, with another $70,000 of switching cost
Probability of failure25%
Discount rate8.0% a year, savings at year end

The sum of the three discount factors is 0.9259 + 0.8573 + 0.7938 = 2.5771, and of years 2 and 3 alone 1.6512.

Step 1: the saving if the new vendor performs

Saving = (1.60 − 1.45) × 400,000 = $60,000 a year

PV of three years = 60,000 × 2.5771 = $154,626; net of the $70,000 switching cost = $84,626

Excel: =(1.60-1.45)*400000*PV(0.08,3,-1)-70000

Step 2: the cost if the new vendor fails

Savings lost in years 2 and 3 = 60,000 × 1.6512 = $99,070

Second switching cost at year 1 = 70,000 × 0.9259 = $64,815

Net result if the vendor fails = 84,626 − 99,070 − 64,815 = −$79,259

Step 3: the expected value

Expected net = 75% × 84,626 + 25% × (−79,259) = $43,655

The bid is worth 28% of the headline saving of $154,626

A new vendor at $1.45 is worth $43,655, not $154,626. With a 25% failure risk the bid must be below $1.500 a sq ft for switching to beat staying, and below $1.532 with no failure risk.

What if: the incumbent matches the bid

Expected value of each choice over 3 years, present value at 8%
ChoiceAnnual costSaving per yearExpected value
Stay at $1.60$640,000$0$0
Switch to the $1.45 bidder$580,000$60,000$43,655
Incumbent matches at $1.55$620,000$20,000$51,542
Incumbent matches at $1.50$600,000$40,000$103,084

An incumbent price match to $1.50 is worth $103,084 with no switching cost or risk, more than the $43,655 from moving to the $1.45 bidder. The re-bid is worth running even if the owner does not switch, because it prices the incumbent.

Expected value of switching, $
Bid per sq ftNo failure risk25% failure risk50% failure risk
$1.40136,16886,94137,714
$1.4584,62643,6552,683
$1.5033,084368−32,347
$1.55−18,458−42,918−67,377

The model ignores CAM recovery, under which tenants pay most of a janitorial contract, so the owner keeps only part of the saving and may recover part of the one-off cost.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How do you decide whether to switch janitorial vendors?

Compare the present value of the saving, less switching cost and the expected cost of a failed vendor, with staying. Here $60,000 a year becomes $43,655 of expected value over 3 years.

What is the break-even bid for switching vendors?

About $1.50 a sq ft with a 25% failure risk and $70,000 of switching cost, against the $1.60 incumbent; with no failure risk it is $1.53.

Should you ask the incumbent to match a lower bid?

Yes. A match at $1.50 saves $40,000 a year with no switching cost and is worth $103,084, more than the $43,655 from switching to the $1.45 bidder.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Commercial Property Manager rebuild a fictional office CAM reconciliation, an apartment operating budget, the cost of a move-out and an HVAC replacement, with live formulas. The figures in this article use invented inputs and are not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 24 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on insurance and retirement, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: real estate investing, finance and fund management → · All 1908 articles →