The saving on a re-bid is not the difference between two prices. Switching cost and the chance of a bad vendor take part of it, and the incumbent may match.
A $1.45-a-sq-ft bid against a $1.60 incumbent saves $60,000 a year on a 400,000 sq ft office. After $70,000 of switching cost and a 25% chance that the new vendor fails, the bid is worth $43,655 over 3 years at 8%, not the $154,626 of the headline saving. An incumbent that matches at $1.50 is worth $103,084.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Building | 400,000 sq ft office |
| Incumbent janitorial contract | $1.60 a sq ft a year, $640,000, with a 3-year term to re-bid |
| New vendor bid | $1.45 a sq ft a year, $580,000, a saving of $60,000 a year |
| One-off cost of switching | Mobilisation, badges, supplies and a parallel run $45,000; service credits and complaints in the first quarter $25,000; total $70,000 |
| If the new vendor fails | Replaced after year 1 by a vendor priced at the incumbent’s $1.60, with another $70,000 of switching cost |
| Probability of failure | 25% |
| Discount rate | 8.0% a year, savings at year end |
The sum of the three discount factors is 0.9259 + 0.8573 + 0.7938 = 2.5771, and of years 2 and 3 alone 1.6512.
Saving = (1.60 − 1.45) × 400,000 = $60,000 a year
PV of three years = 60,000 × 2.5771 = $154,626; net of the $70,000 switching cost = $84,626
Excel: =(1.60-1.45)*400000*PV(0.08,3,-1)-70000
Savings lost in years 2 and 3 = 60,000 × 1.6512 = $99,070
Second switching cost at year 1 = 70,000 × 0.9259 = $64,815
Net result if the vendor fails = 84,626 − 99,070 − 64,815 = −$79,259
Expected net = 75% × 84,626 + 25% × (−79,259) = $43,655
The bid is worth 28% of the headline saving of $154,626
A new vendor at $1.45 is worth $43,655, not $154,626. With a 25% failure risk the bid must be below $1.500 a sq ft for switching to beat staying, and below $1.532 with no failure risk.
| Choice | Annual cost | Saving per year | Expected value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stay at $1.60 | $640,000 | $0 | $0 |
| Switch to the $1.45 bidder | $580,000 | $60,000 | $43,655 |
| Incumbent matches at $1.55 | $620,000 | $20,000 | $51,542 |
| Incumbent matches at $1.50 | $600,000 | $40,000 | $103,084 |
An incumbent price match to $1.50 is worth $103,084 with no switching cost or risk, more than the $43,655 from moving to the $1.45 bidder. The re-bid is worth running even if the owner does not switch, because it prices the incumbent.
| Bid per sq ft | No failure risk | 25% failure risk | 50% failure risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| $1.40 | 136,168 | 86,941 | 37,714 |
| $1.45 | 84,626 | 43,655 | 2,683 |
| $1.50 | 33,084 | 368 | −32,347 |
| $1.55 | −18,458 | −42,918 | −67,377 |
The model ignores CAM recovery, under which tenants pay most of a janitorial contract, so the owner keeps only part of the saving and may recover part of the one-off cost.
Compare the present value of the saving, less switching cost and the expected cost of a failed vendor, with staying. Here $60,000 a year becomes $43,655 of expected value over 3 years.
About $1.50 a sq ft with a 25% failure risk and $70,000 of switching cost, against the $1.60 incumbent; with no failure risk it is $1.53.
Yes. A match at $1.50 saves $40,000 a year with no switching cost and is worth $103,084, more than the $43,655 from switching to the $1.45 bidder.
The free companion files for The Commercial Property Manager rebuild a fictional office CAM reconciliation, an apartment operating budget, the cost of a move-out and an HVAC replacement, with live formulas. The figures in this article use invented inputs and are not in them. No account and no email address.
Not on Amazon: 24 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on insurance and retirement, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →
Reading guide: real estate investing, finance and fund management → · All 1908 articles →