When is it cheaper to repair a failing rooftop HVAC unit than to replace it?
A repair is cheap this year and dear every year after. The comparison that works is a cost per year of use, with the running cost of the old unit included.
A rooftop unit has failed and the contractor quotes $4,800 to repair it against $22,000 to replace it. At an 8.0% cost of capital the new unit costs $7,620 a year over 15 years, running costs included. The repaired unit costs $7,963 a year if it lasts three more years and $7,302 if it lasts five. The break-even is 3.8 years of life after the repair.
The assumptions
Illustrative rooftop unit, invented figures
Item
Repair the old unit
Replace with a new unit
Up-front cost
$4,800
$22,000
Maintenance a year
$900
$400
Energy a year
$5,200
$4,650
Running cost a year
$6,100
$5,050
Life
Unknown, tested from 2 to 5 years
15 years
Cost of capital
8.0%
8.0%
The old unit is less efficient and needs more maintenance, so it costs $1,450 a year more to run than the new one before the repair is counted. After the repair life ends the unit would be replaced, so the comparison is of an annual cost for each path rather than total cost.
Step 1: the annual cost of the new unit
Capital recovery factor, 8.0% over 15 years = 0.11683
4,800 × factor = 1,520, so the factor must be 0.31672
L = 3.8 years
The old unit would have to last about four more years for the repair to cost less. The extra $1,450 a year of running cost is what makes the repair dear: over three years it adds $3,737 in present value, 78% of the $4,800 repair itself.
What if: a rebate, a dearer repair
Break-even life of the repair when one input changes
Case
Annual cost of the new unit, $
Repair that must last, years
Base case
7,620
3.8
$3,000 utility rebate on the new unit (net cost $19,000)
7,270
5.2
Repair quoted at $7,000
7,620
6.0
A $3,000 rebate raises the life the repair needs to 5.2 years, while a $7,000 repair needs 6.0. Below these lives replacement is cheaper.
The common mistakes
Comparing $4,800 with $22,000. The repair costs 21.8% of the replacement but buys a few years against 15, and the old unit costs $1,450 a year more to run, so the cost a year is not in that proportion.
Comparing only the capital charges. $1,863 a year for a three-year repair against $2,570 for the new unit makes the repair look $708 a year cheaper; with running costs it is $342 dearer.
Ignoring who pays. Depending on the lease, a replacement and a repair may be recovered from tenants differently, so the owner's answer and the building's answer can differ. Check the lease before using either figure.
Trusting a guessed life. The contractor's estimate of the years left is the single input that decides the answer; between three and five years the repair goes from $342 dearer to $318 cheaper.
Takeaway
Equivalent annual cost = cost × capital recovery factor + running cost; compare the repaired unit with the new one.
Here the new unit costs $7,620 a year and a $4,800 repair costs less only if the unit lasts 3.8 years or more.
A rebate or a dearer repair moves the break-even life to 5.2 or 6.0 years.
Questions readers ask
How do you compare repairing and replacing an HVAC unit?
Convert each option to an equivalent annual cost: up-front cost times the capital recovery factor for its life, plus maintenance and energy. Here $7,620 a year for the new unit against $7,963 for a repair that lasts three years.
How long must a repaired unit last to be worth it?
In this example 3.8 years. At that life the annual cost of the repaired unit, $7,620, equals that of a new one. A longer life favours the repair; a shorter one favours replacement.
Why does the running cost of the old unit matter?
It is $1,450 a year higher than that of the new unit. Over three years that is $3,737 in present value, comparable to the repair itself.
The workbooks behind this article
The free companion files for The Commercial Property Manager rebuild a fictional office CAM reconciliation, an apartment operating budget, the cost of a move-out and an HVAC replacement, with live formulas. The unit in this article is invented and is not in them. No account and no email address.