Articles

What does delivery risk add to the price of a forward carbon credit purchase?

A forward price is not a delivered price: a prepayment, a possible shortfall and two years of funding all sit between the contract and the credits.

A buyer that signs a forward for 500,000 carbon credits at $14.00, with 40% paid at signing, has not secured credits at $14.00. If full delivery has an 80% probability, half delivery 15% and none 5%, and any shortfall is replaced at a $16.00 spot price, the expected cost is $14.95 a credit, and $15.88 once the two years of prepayment funding at 8.0% are added. The forward is worth signing only below $14.12.

The assumptions

Illustrative forward purchase, invented probabilities
ItemValue
Contract quantity500,000 credits
Forward price$14.00
Paid at signing (not recovered if the credits are not delivered)40% ($2.80m)
Balance, paid on delivery of each credit60%
Price at which the buyer replaces a shortfall$16.00
Time to delivery and cost of funds2 years, 8.0%

The buyer needs the credits to meet a commitment, so a shortfall is bought on the market at $16.00. The probabilities are the buyer’s own view of the project, not a published statistic: an offset project can fail to issue credits for reasons of verification, weather, permits or counterparty finance.

Step 1: the cost of each outcome

For a delivered share d, the buyer pays the prepayment on everything, the balance on what arrives, and the spot price on what does not.

Cost per contract credit = 40% × 14.00 + 60% × 14.00 × d + (1 − d) × 16.00

Full delivery: 5.60 + 8.40 = $14.00

Half delivered: 5.60 + 4.20 + 8.00 = $17.80

No delivery: 5.60 + 0 + 16.00 = $21.60

Step 2: weight by probability

Cost of covering 500,000 credits
OutcomeProbabilityDeliveredTotal costPer credit
Full delivery80%500k$7.000m$14.00
Half delivered15%250k$8.900m$17.80
No delivery5%0k$10.800m$21.60
Expected100%438k$7.475m$14.95

The expected delivered quantity is 438k credits, 87.5% of the contract. The expected cost of $14.95 a credit is $0.95 above the headline price, 6.8% more.

Expected cost = Σ probability × cost per credit

Excel: =SUMPRODUCT(B2:B4,E2:E4)

Step 3: add the funding of the prepayment

The $2.80m paid today earns nothing for two years. At 8.0% that is $2.80m × (1.082 − 1) = $0.466m, or $0.93 a credit, so the all-in expected cost is $14.95 + $0.93 = $15.88. Against a $16.00 spot price the apparent $2.00 saving shrinks to $0.12.

Step 4: the forward price that breaks even

The expected all-in cost is linear in the forward price: with these inputs it is 0.9916 × the price plus 2.00. Setting it equal to the $16.00 spot gives a forward price of $14.12. Paying more than that is paying for a risk the buyer would not run by waiting for delivery and buying at spot, assuming spot ends at $16.00.

What if: delivery is less likely, or less is prepaid

If the probabilities are 60% full, 25% half and 15% none, the expected all-in cost rises to $17.02, above the $16.00 spot, and the forward is no longer worth signing. If the prepayment is 20% instead of 40%, the all-in expected cost at the original probabilities falls to $15.07: a lower prepayment reduces both the funding cost and the amount lost on non-delivery.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How do you price delivery risk in a forward carbon credit contract?

Weight the cost of each delivery outcome by its probability. With 80% full, 15% half and 5% no delivery on a $14.00 forward with 40% prepaid and a $16.00 replacement price, the expected cost is $14.95 a credit.

Why does the prepayment matter so much?

It is lost if nothing is delivered and it carries a funding cost. At 8.0% for two years the $2.80m prepayment costs $0.93 a credit before any delivery risk.

At what forward price is the forward worth signing?

When the expected all-in cost equals the spot price the buyer expects to pay at delivery. Here that is $14.12 against a $16.00 spot.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Carbon Markets Professional rebuild a fictional carbon desk’s year: a cement producer’s compliance position and hedge programme, an EUA trading book, its stress fortnight, an option quote, a carbon credit forward purchase and a CORSIA resale. The delivery probabilities in this article are invented and are not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on energy, infrastructure and land, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: infrastructure, data centres and energy → · All 1908 articles →