Articles

What capacity charge does a desalination plant need to earn a 12% equity return?

In a build-operate-transfer contract the buyer pays for availability, not for water taken. The capacity charge has to cover fixed costs, debt service and the equity return, whatever volume the buyer takes.

A desalination plant of 150,000 m3 a day costs $300m, is financed 70% with debt at 6.0% over 20 years, and sells its capacity for 25 years. To give its equity a 12.0% return it needs a capacity charge of $37.91m a year, or $0.692 per m3 of capacity. With a $0.30 variable charge the buyer pays $0.992 per m3 if it takes all the water and $1.166 if it takes 80%.

The assumptions

Illustrative plant, invented figures, flat nominal charges, before tax
ItemValue
Capacity150,000 m3 a day, 54.75 million m3 a year
Capital cost$300.0m
Debt, 70% of cost, level payments over 20 years at 6.0%$210.0m
Equity, 30% of cost$90.0m
Fixed operation and maintenance$9.0m a year
Contract term, after construction25 years
Target equity return12.0%
Variable charge (energy, chemicals), passed through$0.30 per m3 produced

The buyer, usually a public water authority, pays a capacity charge for the plant being available and a variable charge for the water produced. The capacity charge is due even if the buyer takes less than the contracted volume, which is the take-or-pay feature lenders rely on. The charges here are flat; real contracts index part of both.

Step 1: the debt service

Annual debt service = PMT(6.0%, 20, 210.0m) = $18.31m

Excel: =PMT(6%,20,-210)

Step 2: the equity cash flow in terms of the capacity charge C

Equity cash flow, $m
YearsCapacity chargeFixed O&MDebt serviceEquity cash flow
1 to 20C−9.00−18.31C − 27.31
21 to 25C−9.000.00C − 9.00

Debt is repaid after year 20, so the last five years pay all of the margin to equity. The equity cheque of $90.0m must equal the present value of these flows at 12.0%.

Step 3: solve for the capacity charge

PV factor at 12.0%: 20 years = 7.469, 25 years = 7.843

90.0 = (C − 9.0) × 7.843 − 18.31 × 7.469

C = 9.0 + (90.0 + 18.31 × 7.469) / 7.843 = $37.91m a year

Per m3 of capacity: 37.91m / 54.75m = $0.692

Excel: =Fixed+(Equity+PV(12%,20,-DS))/PV(12%,25,-1)

Equity receives $10.60m a year in years 1 to 20 and $28.91m a year in years 21 to 25. The debt service cover ratio, (C − fixed O&M) / debt service, is 1.58x in the first 20 years, so the equity return, not the lenders' cover test, sets the charge. The last five years are worth $10.8m of the $90.0m cheque.

What if: financing, return and cost

Capacity charge when one input changes
CaseCapacity charge, $mPer m3Change vs baseDebt service cover
Base case37.91$0.692–1.58x
Interest rate 5.0%36.52$0.667−$0.0251.63x
Interest rate 7.0%39.35$0.719+$0.0261.53x
Debt tenor 25 years36.90$0.674−$0.0181.70x
Equity return 10.0%36.09$0.659−$0.0331.48x
Equity return 14.0%39.74$0.726+$0.0331.68x
Capital cost $360m43.69$0.798+$0.1061.58x

A point of interest rate moves the charge by about $0.026 per m3, and two points of equity return by about $0.033. A 20% higher capital cost, $360m instead of $300m, adds $0.106, the largest single change here.

What the buyer pays when it takes less water

Total charge per m3 delivered, $
Volume takenCapacity charge, $mVariable charge, $mTotal, $mPer m3 delivered
100%37.9116.4354.34$0.992
80%37.9113.1451.05$1.166
60%37.919.8647.77$1.454

The capacity charge does not move with volume, so the price per m3 delivered rises from $0.992 to $1.454, 46.5% more, when the buyer takes 60%.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How is the capacity charge of a desalination plant calculated?

It is the charge that covers fixed operating costs and debt service and still gives equity its target return. Here $9.0m of fixed costs, $18.31m of debt service and a 12.0% return on $90.0m of equity give $37.91m a year.

Why does the price per cubic metre rise when the buyer takes less water?

The capacity charge is fixed and paid whatever volume is taken. Spread over fewer m3, it costs more per m3: $0.992 at full offtake, $1.166 at 80%.

What moves the capacity charge most?

In this example the capital cost: $360m instead of $300m adds $0.106 per m3 of capacity. A one-point rise in the interest rate adds about $0.026.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Water Infrastructure Investor rebuild a fictional regulated water utility bought at 1.60x rate base and a 150,000 m3 a day desalination plant bid as a build-operate-transfer project, with the capacity charge, sculpted debt and take-or-pay. The plant in this article is simplified and its figures are invented; they are not those of the workbook. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on energy, infrastructure and land, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: infrastructure, data centres and energy → · All 1908 articles →