In a build-operate-transfer contract the buyer pays for availability, not for water taken. The capacity charge has to cover fixed costs, debt service and the equity return, whatever volume the buyer takes.
A desalination plant of 150,000 m3 a day costs $300m, is financed 70% with debt at 6.0% over 20 years, and sells its capacity for 25 years. To give its equity a 12.0% return it needs a capacity charge of $37.91m a year, or $0.692 per m3 of capacity. With a $0.30 variable charge the buyer pays $0.992 per m3 if it takes all the water and $1.166 if it takes 80%.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Capacity | 150,000 m3 a day, 54.75 million m3 a year |
| Capital cost | $300.0m |
| Debt, 70% of cost, level payments over 20 years at 6.0% | $210.0m |
| Equity, 30% of cost | $90.0m |
| Fixed operation and maintenance | $9.0m a year |
| Contract term, after construction | 25 years |
| Target equity return | 12.0% |
| Variable charge (energy, chemicals), passed through | $0.30 per m3 produced |
The buyer, usually a public water authority, pays a capacity charge for the plant being available and a variable charge for the water produced. The capacity charge is due even if the buyer takes less than the contracted volume, which is the take-or-pay feature lenders rely on. The charges here are flat; real contracts index part of both.
Annual debt service = PMT(6.0%, 20, 210.0m) = $18.31m
Excel: =PMT(6%,20,-210)
| Years | Capacity charge | Fixed O&M | Debt service | Equity cash flow |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 to 20 | C | −9.00 | −18.31 | C − 27.31 |
| 21 to 25 | C | −9.00 | 0.00 | C − 9.00 |
Debt is repaid after year 20, so the last five years pay all of the margin to equity. The equity cheque of $90.0m must equal the present value of these flows at 12.0%.
PV factor at 12.0%: 20 years = 7.469, 25 years = 7.843
90.0 = (C − 9.0) × 7.843 − 18.31 × 7.469
C = 9.0 + (90.0 + 18.31 × 7.469) / 7.843 = $37.91m a year
Per m3 of capacity: 37.91m / 54.75m = $0.692
Excel: =Fixed+(Equity+PV(12%,20,-DS))/PV(12%,25,-1)
Equity receives $10.60m a year in years 1 to 20 and $28.91m a year in years 21 to 25. The debt service cover ratio, (C − fixed O&M) / debt service, is 1.58x in the first 20 years, so the equity return, not the lenders' cover test, sets the charge. The last five years are worth $10.8m of the $90.0m cheque.
| Case | Capacity charge, $m | Per m3 | Change vs base | Debt service cover |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base case | 37.91 | $0.692 | – | 1.58x |
| Interest rate 5.0% | 36.52 | $0.667 | −$0.025 | 1.63x |
| Interest rate 7.0% | 39.35 | $0.719 | +$0.026 | 1.53x |
| Debt tenor 25 years | 36.90 | $0.674 | −$0.018 | 1.70x |
| Equity return 10.0% | 36.09 | $0.659 | −$0.033 | 1.48x |
| Equity return 14.0% | 39.74 | $0.726 | +$0.033 | 1.68x |
| Capital cost $360m | 43.69 | $0.798 | +$0.106 | 1.58x |
A point of interest rate moves the charge by about $0.026 per m3, and two points of equity return by about $0.033. A 20% higher capital cost, $360m instead of $300m, adds $0.106, the largest single change here.
| Volume taken | Capacity charge, $m | Variable charge, $m | Total, $m | Per m3 delivered |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 100% | 37.91 | 16.43 | 54.34 | $0.992 |
| 80% | 37.91 | 13.14 | 51.05 | $1.166 |
| 60% | 37.91 | 9.86 | 47.77 | $1.454 |
The capacity charge does not move with volume, so the price per m3 delivered rises from $0.992 to $1.454, 46.5% more, when the buyer takes 60%.
It is the charge that covers fixed operating costs and debt service and still gives equity its target return. Here $9.0m of fixed costs, $18.31m of debt service and a 12.0% return on $90.0m of equity give $37.91m a year.
The capacity charge is fixed and paid whatever volume is taken. Spread over fewer m3, it costs more per m3: $0.992 at full offtake, $1.166 at 80%.
In this example the capital cost: $360m instead of $300m adds $0.106 per m3 of capacity. A one-point rise in the interest rate adds about $0.026.
The free companion files for The Water Infrastructure Investor rebuild a fictional regulated water utility bought at 1.60x rate base and a 150,000 m3 a day desalination plant bid as a build-operate-transfer project, with the capacity charge, sculpted debt and take-or-pay. The plant in this article is simplified and its figures are invented; they are not those of the workbook. No account and no email address.
Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on energy, infrastructure and land, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →
Reading guide: infrastructure, data centres and energy → · All 1908 articles →