Articles

How much leakage should a water utility fix before the next cubic metre costs more than it saves?

The right level of leakage is not zero. It is the point where the next cubic metre saved costs more than the water is worth.

Four leakage measures cost between $0.201 and $1.133 a m3 saved. Where a saved m3 is worth only its $0.28 production cost, just 1 measure pays and the utility should fix 1.2 million m3; where it defers a $0.62 source, 3 measures pay and 3.0 million m3 should go; where the water can be sold at $1.33 net, all 3.6 million m3 pay.

The assumptions

Illustrative water utility, invented figures
ItemValue
System input60.0 million m3 a year, of which 22% is physical leakage: 13.2 million m3
Tariff$1.40 a m3, 95% collected, $1.33 net
Variable production cost$0.28 a m3 (energy and chemicals)
Cost of new supply$0.62 a m3 over the long run, if the leakage saved defers a new source
Capital7.0% over 20 years, a capital recovery factor of 0.0944

Capital recovery factor = 0.07 ÷ (1 − 1.07−20) = 0.0944. Four measures can each be bought, each one cheaper per m3 than the one after it:

Leakage measures, ranked by annual cost per m³ saved
MeasureSaved, m m³Capex, $mOpex, $m a yearAnnual cost, $mCost per m³ saved
Pressure management1.21.50.100.242$0.201
Active leak detection1.01.40.300.432$0.432
Mains repairs0.82.80.100.364$0.455
Mains replacement0.67.20.000.680$1.133

Step 1: the annual cost of a cubic metre saved

Annual cost = capex × 0.0944 + opex; cost per m3 = annual cost ÷ volume saved

Pressure management: (1.5 × 0.0944 + 0.10) ÷ 1.2 = 0.242 ÷ 1.2 = $0.201

Mains replacement: 7.2 × 0.0944 ÷ 0.6 = 0.680 ÷ 0.6 = $1.133

Excel, capex in C6, opex in D6, volume in B6: =(C6*0.07/(1-1.07^-20)+D6)/B6

The measures rise in cost from $0.201 to $1.133 a m3, a factor of 5.6. That rising cost is why the right amount of leakage is not zero.

Step 2: what a cubic metre is worth

A saved cubic metre is worth the cost the utility avoids, and that depends on the system. If supply is ample it saves only production cost; if it defers a new source it saves that source’s cost; if the system is short it frees water to sell.

Value of a saved m3 = $0.28 (production cost), $0.62 (deferred supply) or $1.33 (tariff 1.40 × 95%)

Measure pays if its cost per m3 is below that value. At $0.28 only pressure management qualifies

Step 3: how much leakage to fix

Measures that pay, by value of a saved m³
Value of a m³Measures that payVolume saved, m m³Capex, $mNet annual value, $m
$0.28 (production cost only)1 of 41.21.50.094
$0.62 (deferred new supply)3 of 43.05.70.822
$1.33 (water sold in a short system)4 of 43.612.93.070

At $0.28 the utility should fix 1.2 million m3, 9.1% of the 13.2 million m3 of physical leakage, for a net gain of $0.094m a year. At $0.62 it should fix 3.0 million m3, 22.7% of leakage, for $0.822m. At $1.33 it should fix all 3.6 million m3, 27.3% of leakage, for $3.070m.

What if: the cost or the value moves

Measures that pay and net annual value, $m
CaseMeasures that payVolume saved, m m³Net annual value, $m
Costs 20% lower, production cost only1 of 41.20.143
Costs 20% lower, deferred new supply3 of 43.01.030
Costs 20% lower, water sold in a short system4 of 43.63.414
Base costs, production cost only1 of 41.20.094
Base costs, deferred new supply3 of 43.00.822
Base costs, water sold in a short system4 of 43.63.070
Costs 20% higher, production cost only1 of 41.20.046
Costs 20% higher, deferred new supply3 of 43.00.614
Costs 20% higher, water sold in a short system3 of 43.02.744

The cut-off is set by the value of the water, not by the cost of the measures: a 20% cost swing moves the answer by one measure at most. The model has no leakage rebound, no loss of savings over time and no interest during construction.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What is the economic level of leakage?

The level at which the next measure costs more per m3 saved than the water is worth. Here it is 1.2, 3.0 or 3.6 million m3 of the 13.2 million that leaks, depending on the value of water.

Why is the value of a saved cubic metre not the tariff?

Because a saved m3 only earns the tariff if there is demand the system could not otherwise meet. With ample supply it saves $0.28 of production cost, a quarter of the $1.33 net tariff.

Does a water utility want zero leakage?

No. The last measure costs $1.133 a m3, 5.6 times the first, and pays only if water is worth more than that.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Water Infrastructure Investor rebuild a fictional regulated water utility bought at 1.60x rate base and a 150,000 m3 a day desalination plant bid as a build-operate-transfer project, with the capacity charge, sculpted debt and take-or-pay. The figures in this article use invented inputs and are not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 24 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on insurance and retirement, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: infrastructure, data centres and energy → · All 1908 articles →