Articles

What does an airline default cost an aircraft lessor for each month of repossession downtime?

The loss on a default is time without rent plus the cost of getting the aircraft back and re-placed. The rent cut on re-lease is only part of it.

A narrowbody with 72 months left on a $210,000-a-month lease, repossessed after a default and re-leased after 12 months at $185,000, costs the lessor $5.86m in present value at 8%, 19.5% of its $30.0m value. Each extra month of downtime between 6 and 18 costs about $0.204m.

The assumptions

Illustrative narrowbody lease, invented figures
ItemValue
AircraftNarrowbody appraised at $30.0m, 72 months left on a lease at $210,000 a month
DefaultThe airline stops paying at month 0 and the lessor repossesses
Recovery costsLegal and export costs of $0.90m at month 0, then $45,000 a month of storage, insurance and maintenance until re-delivery
Re-leaseA new 72-month-horizon lease at $185,000 a month starts after the downtime, after $1.40m of transition and catch-up maintenance
Security deposit$0.42m, two months of rent, kept by the lessor
Discount rate8.0% a year, 0.6434% a month

The comparison is over the 72 months left on the original lease. A performing lease is worth 0.210 × 57.480 = $12.07m in present value, where 57.480 is the sum of 72 monthly discount factors.

Step 1: the present value of the default path with 12 months of downtime

Recovery costs: $0.90m at month 0 plus 45,000 × 11.513 = $0.52m of carrying cost

Transition: 1.40 × 0.9259 = $1.30m at month 12

New rent for months 13 to 72: 0.185 × 45.968 = $8.50m

Net = 8.50 + 0.42 deposit − 0.90 − 0.52 − 1.30 = $6.21m

Excel, monthly rate in B2, downtime in B3: =0.185*(PV(B2,72-B3,-1)/(1+B2)^B3) for the new rent, with PV in months

Step 2: the loss against a performing lease

Loss = performing lease − default path = 12.07 − 6.21 = $5.86m, 19.5% of the aircraft value and 48.6% of the lease

Each month of extra downtime between 6 and 18 months costs about $0.204m

Step 3: downtime against the new rent

Loss against a performing lease, $m
Downtime, monthsNew rent $210,000New rent $185,000New rent $160,000
63.324.615.90
94.025.246.46
124.715.867.01
186.057.068.08
247.338.229.10

At $185,000 a month the loss rises from $4.61m at 6 months to $8.22m at 24 months. A $25,000 cut in the new rent, from $185,000 to $160,000, costs $1.15m at 12 months; six more months of downtime, from 6 to 12, cost $1.25m. The two are of similar size.

What if: the recovery costs are higher

Loss against a performing lease at a $185,000 new rent, $m
Case6 months12 months18 months
Base costs4.615.867.06
Recovery, carrying and transition costs 50% higher5.877.228.52
Recovery, carrying and transition costs doubled7.128.589.97

Doubling every cost adds about $2.71m at 12 months, more than the $2.36m added by stretching the downtime from 12 to 24 months, so the cost assumptions deserve as much scrutiny as the schedule. The model has no tax, no maintenance reserves held, no end-of-lease value and no lessee funding of the repossession.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What does a repossession cost an aircraft lessor?

In this case $5.86m in present value: the rent not received, $0.90m of recovery costs, $0.52m of carrying costs and $1.30m of transition, less the $0.42m deposit.

How much does each month of downtime cost?

About $0.204m a month between 6 and 18 months, from $4.61m at 6 months to $7.06m at 18 months at a $185,000 new rent.

Is the new rent or the downtime more important?

They are close. Six more months of downtime, from 6 to 12, cost $1.25m, and a $25,000 cut in the new monthly rent costs $1.15m at 12 months.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Aircraft Leasing Professional rebuild a fictional lessor’s sale-and-leaseback and its IRRs, a lease return and transition, an airline default, an aircraft ABS and the lessor’s annual results. The figures in this article use invented inputs and are not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 24 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on insurance and retirement, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: credit, private credit and distressed debt → · All 1908 articles →