Articles

What lease rate factor does an aircraft lessor need to earn an 8% IRR?

The lease rate factor is the rent that returns the price and a target IRR after the aircraft is sold. It is set by the term and the residual, not by the target alone.

A lessor that pays $60.0m for an aircraft, leases it for 12 years at a flat monthly rent and expects to sell it for 40% of the price at the end needs a lease rate factor of 0.898%, $539k a month, to earn an 8.0% unlevered IRR. At a 0.800% factor the same aircraft earns 6.41%; if the residual proves to be 30% rather than 40%, it earns 5.60%.

The assumptions

Illustrative aircraft purchase and lease, no downtime, maintenance, tax or leverage
ItemValue
Purchase price$60.0m
Lease term, flat rent paid monthly in arrears12 years (144 payments)
Residual value at lease end, share of the price40% ($24.0m)
Target unlevered IRR8.0% a year

The lease rate factor is the monthly rent as a percentage of the purchase price. It is the number lessors and lessees quote to each other, because it can be compared across aircraft of different prices. Everything below is on a monthly cash flow basis.

Step 1: the monthly rate and the discount factors

An annual 8.0% is a monthly rate of 1.081/12 − 1 = 0.6434%. Over 144 months the present value of one dollar a month is 93.703, and the present value of one dollar received at the end is 0.3971.

Monthly rate = (1 + IRR)1/12 − 1

Annuity factor = (1 − (1 + m)−n) ÷ m = 93.703

Residual discount factor = (1 + m)−n = 0.3971

Step 2: the rent that returns the price

The price must equal the present value of the rents plus the present value of the residual. The residual is worth $24.0m × 0.3971 = $9.531m today, 15.9% of the price, so the rents have to carry the other $50.469m.

Rent = (Price − Residual × discount factor) ÷ annuity factor

= ($60.000m − $9.531m) ÷ 93.703 = $538.6k a month

Lease rate factor = 538.6 ÷ 60,000 = 0.898%

Excel: =PMT((1+8%)^(1/12)-1,144,-60,24) gives the rent in $m; divide by 60 for the factor

Over a year that is $6.463m, a 10.77% cash yield on the price. The yield is above the 8.0% IRR because part of the price comes back as depreciation: the aircraft is sold for $36.0m less than it cost.

Step 3: how the factor moves with the residual and the target

Monthly lease rate factor needed, 12-year flat lease
Residual7.0% IRR8.0% IRR9.0% IRR
30% ($18.0m)0.881%0.940%0.999%
40% ($24.0m)0.836%0.898%0.959%
50% ($30.0m)0.791%0.855%0.920%

Ten points of residual are worth 4.24 basis points of factor, $25.4k a month. One point of IRR is worth about 6.1 basis points of factor at a 40% residual. Over twelve years the residual weighs little, because $24.0m received in year twelve is worth only 15.9% of the price today.

What if: the lessee wants 0.800% and the residual is 30%

At a factor of 0.800% the rent is $480k a month. Solving for the IRR that makes the price equal the present value of those rents and the residual gives 6.41% at a 40% residual and 5.60% at 30%. To earn 8.0% on a 30% residual the factor has to be 0.940%, $564.0k a month, not 0.898%.

The term matters more. Holding the 40% residual and the 8.0% IRR, the factor is 0.898% on twelve years, 0.977% on ten and 1.097% on eight: a shorter lease has to repay the same depreciation faster.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What is a lease rate factor?

The monthly rent divided by the purchase price of the aircraft. For $60.0m and $539k a month it is 0.898%.

How does the residual value change the lease rate factor?

Through its present value. On a 12-year lease at 8.0%, moving the residual from 40% to 30% lifts the factor from 0.898% to 0.940%, about 4.2 basis points.

What IRR does a 0.800% lease rate factor earn?

On a 12-year flat lease it earns 6.41% at a 40% residual and 5.60% at a 30% residual, both below an 8.0% target.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Aircraft Leasing Professional rebuild a fictional lessor’s sale-and-leaseback and its IRRs, a lease return and transition, an airline default, an aircraft ABS and the lessor’s annual results. The lease rate factors in this article use invented inputs and are not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 10 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on tax and incentives, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: credit, private credit and distressed debt → · All 1908 articles →