Articles

How do you decide whether a deferred tax asset needs a valuation allowance?

Schedule the four sources of taxable income against the asset, weigh negative and positive evidence by how far each can be verified, and reserve what is more likely than not to go unused.

A deferred tax asset needs a valuation allowance when it is more likely than not, a likelihood above 50 percent, that some or all of it will not be realized. Check the four sources of taxable income of ASC 740-10-30-18 in order, weigh the negative and positive evidence by how far each piece can be objectively verified, and reserve the part the sources do not cover. In the example below, a subsidiary’s state losses of $32,300,000 carry a $1,531,020 asset; three years of projections and reversals support a release of $767,880.

Worked in full in The Income Tax Provision Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

Free: the income tax provision template in Excel, which builds current tax, the deferred tax rollforward and the rate reconciliation in the categories of ASU 2023-09, in dollars and in percent.

The test: more likely than not

A deferred tax asset records a future deduction or a carryforward. It lowers tax only if there is taxable income of the right kind, in the right jurisdiction and in time, to absorb it. Under ASC 740-10-25-6, as quoted in dated summaries read in November 2026, more likely than not means a likelihood of more than 50 percent, and a valuation allowance is recorded when it is more likely than not that some portion or all of a deferred tax asset will not be realized.

The question is therefore never whether the group is profitable in general. It is whether the entity that holds the asset will have enough taxable income, where the asset sits, before it expires. The allowance works as a contra account: the asset stays on the tax balance sheet at its full amount, and the allowance brings it down to the part expected to be realized. Changes in the allowance are generally reported as a component of income tax expense from continuing operations (ASC 740-10-45-20), with exceptions this article leaves aside.

The four sources of taxable income

ASC 740-10-30-18 lists four sources of taxable income that may be available to realize a deferred tax asset. It helps to read them from the most verifiable to the least.

ASC 740-10-30-18, as quoted in dated summaries; third column: the book’s fictional case.
SourceWhat it requiresIn the worked example
1. Taxable income in prior carryback yearsA carryback permitted under the tax lawNone: the case allows no carryback in the two states
2. Future reversals of existing taxable temporary differencesTaxable differences that reverse in the same jurisdiction, in time$1,200,000 between 2027 and 2031
3. Tax-planning strategiesActions that are prudent and feasible, that the entity ordinarily might not take but would take to keep a carryforward from expiring unused (ASC 740-10-30-19)None identified
4. Future taxable income exclusive of reversing differences and carryforwardsProjections, weighted by how far they can be verifiedProjections for 2027 to 2031

The first two sources are close to mechanical: they come from the tax law and from the tax balance sheet, and a reviewer can trace them. A tax-planning strategy is an action the company would actually take, with its own costs, not a figure added to close a gap. The fourth source carries the judgment, because it rests on a forecast.

Evidence, weighted by what can be verified

All available evidence counts, negative and positive. ASC 740-10-30-21 gives examples of negative evidence, among them cumulative losses in recent years and a history of operating loss or tax credit carryforwards expiring unused. ASC 740-10-30-22 gives examples of positive evidence, among them existing contracts or a firm sales backlog that will produce enough taxable income to realize the asset.

The decisive sentence is in ASC 740-10-30-23: the weight given to the potential effect of negative and positive evidence is commensurate with the extent to which it can be objectively verified. A loss already reported is a fact. A signed backlog is close to one. A projection of income five years out is an estimate, and it weighs less. The same paragraph calls a cumulative loss in recent years a significant piece of negative evidence that is difficult to overcome.

Three years of cumulative losses: a convention, not a rule

Practice often reads “cumulative losses in recent years” as the current year and the two preceding years, and runs a three-year test. That reading goes back to the basis for conclusions of FASB Statement No. 109, guidance that is superseded and nonauthoritative. The codification sets no three-year rule. A company may adopt the three-year window as its convention, as the company below does, but the result is still one piece of evidence among others: three profitable years do not release an allowance by themselves, and three years of losses are weighed with the rest.

Worked example: a subsidiary’s state loss carryforwards

Brenlow Fluid Systems, Inc. is the fictional US manufacturer of the book’s case. Its subsidiary Brenlow Controls is included in the federal consolidated return but files on its own in two states, where it built up loss carryforwards. The deferred tax asset on those losses is measured at the case rate of 6.00 percent net of the federal benefit: 6.00% x (100% - 21.00%) = 4.74%. The 20-year carryforward and the absence of carryback are case assumptions, not the rules of any real state.

Brenlow Controls, two separate-filing states; fictional figures.
YearState taxable income (loss)Three-year total
2023-$6,800,000
2024-$3,100,000
2025$1,500,0002023 to 2025: -$8,400,000
2026$4,200,0002024 to 2026: $2,600,000

At 31 December 2025 the three years 2023 to 2025 sum to a cumulative loss of $8,400,000, and the company kept a full valuation allowance of $1,730,100. A year later the picture has moved: 2024 to 2026 sum to cumulative income of $2,600,000, there are two profitable years in a row, a firm order backlog from two industrial customers for 2027 and a cost plan finished in 2025. Against that, one customer accounts for a large share of the backlog, and projections beyond three years cannot be objectively verified.

The scheduling sets the sources against the $32,300,000 of losses left at 31 December 2026. Projections for 2027 to 2029 total $15,000,000; with the $1,200,000 of reversals, three years cover $16,200,000. Adding 2030 and 2031 brings the cover to $28,200,000, which still leaves $4,100,000 of losses uncovered even on five years of projections. The deferred tax asset is $32,300,000 x 4.74% = $1,531,020, fully reserved before the decision.

Three options, priced

Fictional case. Each rate is the result of an option, not a goal.
OptionReleaseAllowance left2026 total tax expense2026 effective rate
(a) Keep the full allowance$0$1,531,020$27,529,55023.51%
(b) Release the part covered by three years of projections and the reversals$767,880$763,140$26,761,67022.85%
(c) Release the whole allowance$1,531,020$0$25,998,53022.20%

Option (b) is $16,200,000 x 4.74% = $767,880. Option (a) ignores positive evidence that is now verifiable for three years and pushes the whole benefit to the years in which the losses are used. Option (c) leans on projections beyond five years for $4,100,000 of losses, the hardest position to support before the external auditors, and any later reversal would hit tax expense. Option (b) releases only what the most verifiable sources cover; its risk is that if income for 2027 to 2029 falls short, part of the release comes back through tax expense later.

The sensitivities test the projections. With every projected year 20 percent lower, three years and the reversals cover $13,200,000, the option (b) release falls to $625,680, and $9,500,000 of losses are left uncovered by five years. With projections 20 percent higher, the cover is $19,200,000 and the release $910,080, and five years with the reversals reach $33,600,000, above the $32,300,000 of losses. Option (b) moves with the projections in both directions; option (c) is supported by five years only in the higher case.

The audit committee approved option (b) on 9 February 2027, on the proposal of the director of tax and the chief accounting officer, for the 2026 accounts. The release of $767,880 is recorded as a discrete item of the fourth quarter of 2026: under ASC 740-270-25-7, a change in judgment about a beginning-of-year valuation allowance is recognized in the interim period in which it occurs, not spread through the estimated annual rate. $763,140 stays reserved, and the decision is revisited each quarter against actual income.

The trap: reading the group’s profit as evidence for this asset. Brenlow is profitable on a consolidated basis, but only Brenlow Controls’ own income in its two separate-filing states can use these losses. The scheduling has to stay in the jurisdiction and the entity that hold the asset, at that jurisdiction’s rate.

What the valuation allowance memo should contain

Sources

  1. FASB Accounting Standards Codification, Topic 740, Income Taxes (paragraphs as quoted in dated summaries, read November 2026)

Rules as read in November 2026: the codification paragraphs are those quoted in dated summaries of the standard, since the codification itself sits behind a login. US rules only, illustrative, and not tax, accounting, audit or legal advice; ask the company’s tax advisers and external auditors about a real case. The company in the examples is fictional, its figures are teaching assumptions, and no effective tax rate shown is a goal.

Questions readers ask

What are the four sources of taxable income?

Under ASC 740-10-30-18: taxable income in prior carryback years if carryback is permitted, future reversals of existing taxable temporary differences, tax-planning strategies, and future taxable income exclusive of reversing temporary differences and carryforwards.

Is three years of cumulative losses an automatic trigger?

No. The three-year window is a common convention that goes back to the superseded basis for conclusions of FASB Statement No. 109. A cumulative loss in recent years is significant negative evidence that is difficult to overcome, but it is weighed with the rest of the evidence.

What counts as a tax-planning strategy?

An action that is prudent and feasible, that the entity ordinarily might not take but would take to prevent a carryforward from expiring unused, and that would result in realization of the asset (ASC 740-10-30-19).

When is a valuation allowance release recorded during the year?

A change in judgment about a beginning-of-year valuation allowance is recognized in the interim period in which it occurs (ASC 740-270-25-7), as a discrete item rather than through the estimated annual effective tax rate.

Read the whole book

This article is one step of The Income Tax Provision Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to ASC 740 seen from the desk of the person who prepares the provision: the current provision, the tax balance sheet and its rollforward, valuation allowances, uncertain tax positions, the rate reconciliation and the income tax note, the quarterly provision, the return-to-provision true-up and a new tax law at enactment.

Also on this site