Articles

How does the quarterly tax provision work under the annual effective tax rate method?

Apply the estimated annual effective tax rate to ordinary income for the year to date, subtract what earlier quarters recorded, then add the discrete items of the quarter.

Under ASC 740-270, each quarter applies an estimated annual effective tax rate to ordinary income for the year to date, subtracts the tax already recorded in earlier quarters, and adds the discrete items of the quarter, such as a valuation allowance release or interest on a prior-year position. In the example below, rates of 23.70%, 23.60% and 23.55% and three discrete items give four quarters that add up to $26,761,670, total tax expense for 2026.

Worked in full in The Income Tax Provision Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

Free: the income tax provision template in Excel, which builds current tax, the deferred tax rollforward and the rate reconciliation in the categories of ASU 2023-09, in dollars and in percent.

The rule: one rate for ordinary income, the rest as it happens

ASC 740-270 governs income taxes in interim periods. Under ASC 740-270-25-2, as quoted in dated summaries read in November 2026, the tax related to ordinary income is computed at an estimated annual effective tax rate, and the tax related to all other items is individually computed and recognized when the items occur. Under ASC 740-270-30-5, the estimated rate is applied to the year-to-date ordinary income at each interim period.

Ordinary income is income from continuing operations before income taxes, excluding significant unusual or infrequently occurring items, discontinued operations and the cumulative effects of changes in accounting. ASC 740-270-30-8 keeps unusual or infrequent items out of the rate. Two kinds of items matter in almost every provision: a change in judgment about a beginning-of-year valuation allowance is recognized in the interim period in which it occurs (ASC 740-270-25-7), and changes on prior-year uncertain tax positions, including their interest and penalties, are treated as discrete items.

The cumulative mechanics

Each quarter does the same four steps. Estimate the rate for the full year: expected tax on the year’s ordinary income over the year’s expected ordinary income. Apply it to ordinary income for the year to date. Subtract the tax on ordinary income already recorded in earlier quarters; the difference is this quarter’s tax on ordinary income. Then add the discrete items of the quarter.

The rate is revised at every quarter end, and the year-to-date tax is recomputed at the new rate, less the amounts provided in prior quarters, as the example in ASC 740-270-55 shows. A change in the estimate therefore lands in the quarter in which it is made, through the catch-up on the year to date. When a reliable estimate cannot be made, ASC 740-270-30-18 allows the actual effective tax rate for the year to date to be the best estimate.

New legislation follows its own rule. Under ASC 740-270-25-5, its effects are not recognized before enactment; effects on current-year taxes enter the estimated rate from the first interim period that includes the enactment date, and effects on deferred balances are discrete items of that period. Public Law 119-21, enacted on 4 July 2025, therefore entered the provision of the quarter ending 30 September 2025 for a calendar-year company.

Worked example: the four quarters of 2026

Brenlow Fluid Systems, the fictional company of the book, reports ordinary income of $26,500,000, $29,800,000, $30,100,000, $30,700,000 in the four quarters of 2026, $117,100,000 for the year. Its estimated annual rate is 23.70% at the end of the first quarter, 23.60% at the second and 23.55% at the third, case estimates revised as the year’s figures firm up. At year end the actual figures replace the estimate.

Fictional company, 2026; the rates are case estimates.
QuarterOrdinary income, year to dateAnnual rateTax on ordinary income, year to dateLess prior quartersTax on ordinary income of the quarter
Q1$26,500,00023.70%$6,280,500$0$6,280,500
Q2$56,300,00023.60%$13,286,800$6,280,500$7,006,300
Q3$86,400,00023.55%$20,347,200$13,286,800$7,060,400
Q4$117,100,00023.52% (final)$27,546,400$20,347,200$7,199,200

The second quarter shows the catch-up at work: $56,300,000 x 23.60% = $13,286,800 for the half year, less the $6,280,500 already booked, gives $7,006,300 for the quarter. The small cut in the rate from 23.70% to 23.60% also corrects the first quarter, inside the same subtraction.

Three items stay out of the rate. Interest on the 2025 unrecognized tax benefit, $5,250 a quarter from the second quarter at the case rate of 7.00 percent, belongs to a prior-year position and is classified in income tax expense under the case policy. The 2025 return-to-provision true-up, a benefit of $32,600 booked when the 2025 return was filed on 14 September 2026, is a prior-year item that the case records in the third quarter. The release of $767,880 of valuation allowance on a subsidiary’s state losses, approved by the audit committee on the evidence at 31 December 2026, is a change in judgment about a beginning-of-year allowance and lands in the fourth quarter.

Fictional company, 2026. The four quarters add up to the year.
QuarterTax on ordinary incomeDiscrete itemsTax expense of the quarterRate of the quarter
Q1$6,280,500none$6,280,50023.70%
Q2$7,006,300interest on the 2025 position $5,250$7,011,55023.53%
Q3$7,060,4002025 true-up -$32,600; interest $5,250$7,033,05023.37%
Q4$7,199,200allowance release -$767,880; interest $5,250$6,436,57020.97%
Year$27,546,400-$784,730$26,761,67022.85%

At year end, tax on ordinary income for the year is $26,761,670 - (-$784,730) = $27,546,400, a final annual rate on ordinary income of $27,546,400 / $117,100,000 = 23.52%. The fourth quarter takes that final amount less the $20,347,200 recorded through September. The four quarters, $6,280,500, $7,011,550, $7,033,050, $6,436,570, add up to $26,761,670, total income tax expense for the year, an effective tax rate of 22.85%.

The trap: reading the quarter’s rate as a signal. The fourth quarter shows 20.97% against 23.70% in the first, yet the estimate of the annual rate on ordinary income barely moved. The swing is the discrete release. Folding that release into the annual rate would have turned a fourth-quarter decision into a change of estimate for the whole year, which is what ASC 740-270-25-7 rules out. No rate here is a target; each is a result of the year’s figures.

What the quarterly file should hold

Sources

  1. FASB Accounting Standards Codification, Topic 740, Income Taxes (paragraphs as quoted in dated summaries, read November 2026)

Rules as read in November 2026: the codification paragraphs are those quoted in dated summaries of the standard, since the codification itself sits behind a login. US rules only, illustrative, and not tax, accounting, audit or legal advice; ask the company’s tax advisers and external auditors about a real case. The company in the examples is fictional, its figures are teaching assumptions, and no effective tax rate shown is a goal.

Questions readers ask

What is the estimated annual effective tax rate?

The expected tax on the year's ordinary income divided by the year's expected ordinary income. Under ASC 740-270-25-2 it is applied to ordinary income; other items are computed and recognized when they occur.

What is a discrete item?

An item whose tax is recognized in the quarter in which it occurs instead of through the annual rate: for example, unusual or infrequent items, a change in judgment about a beginning-of-year valuation allowance, or changes on prior-year uncertain tax positions, including their interest.

What if the annual rate cannot be estimated reliably?

ASC 740-270-30-18 allows the actual effective tax rate for the year to date to be the best estimate when a reliable estimate cannot be made.

When does a new tax law enter the quarterly provision?

Not before enactment. Effects on current-year taxes enter the estimated rate from the first interim period that includes the enactment date; effects on deferred balances are discrete items of that period (ASC 740-270-25-5).

Read the whole book

This article is one step of The Income Tax Provision Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to ASC 740 seen from the desk of the person who prepares the provision: the current provision, the tax balance sheet and its rollforward, valuation allowances, uncertain tax positions, the rate reconciliation and the income tax note, the quarterly provision, the return-to-provision true-up and a new tax law at enactment.

Also on this site