Start from tax at the federal statutory rate, add the eight categories of ASC 740-10-50-12A in dollars and in percent, break out any item over the 5 percent threshold, and close to total tax expense.
Under ASU 2023-09, a public business entity reconciles tax at the federal statutory rate to its income tax expense through eight fixed categories, in dollars and in percent, and breaks out by nature any item in four of them that reaches 5 percent of pre-tax income times the statutory rate: 1.05 percent of pre-tax income for a US company. It applies from 2025 for calendar-year public business entities and from 2026, in qualitative form, for other entities. In the example below, 2025 runs from 21.00 percent to an effective tax rate of 23.57 percent, and only tax credits pass the threshold.
Worked in full in The Income Tax Provision Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback
Free: the income tax provision template in Excel, which builds current tax, the deferred tax rollforward and the rate reconciliation in the categories of ASU 2023-09, in dollars and in percent.
The FASB issued ASU 2023-09, Improvements to Income Tax Disclosures, in December 2023. As read in November 2026, it asks for consistent categories and greater disaggregation in the rate reconciliation, for income taxes paid broken down by jurisdiction, and, from all entities, for pre-tax income split between domestic and foreign and income tax expense split between federal, state and foreign. Before the update a company chose its own reconciling lines; now the categories are fixed and the threshold for breaking them out is a formula.
Under ASC 740-10-50-12A, a public business entity reconciles, each year, the tax at the federal statutory rate to its income tax expense, in both percentages and reporting currency amounts, through eight categories:
For the state and local category, ASC 740-10-50-12B adds a qualitative description of the states and local jurisdictions that make up the majority, more than 50 percent, of the category.
Four of the categories (foreign tax effects, effect of cross-border tax laws, tax credits, and nontaxable or nondeductible items) are broken out further by nature, and foreign tax effects also by jurisdiction, when an item is at least 5 percent of the amount computed by multiplying pre-tax income (or loss) from continuing operations by the applicable statutory federal rate. For a US-domiciled company that is 21 percent x 5 percent = 1.05 percent of pre-tax income. The threshold is applied item by item, in dollars, each year.
| Entity | Rate reconciliation | Annual periods beginning after |
|---|---|---|
| Public business entity | The eight categories, in dollars and in percent, with the 5 percent threshold | 15 December 2024 (2025 for a calendar year) |
| Any other entity | A qualitative description of the nature and effect of the categories and of individual jurisdictions with a significant difference; no numerical reconciliation | 15 December 2025 (2026 for a calendar year) |
Application is prospective, with retrospective application allowed. The income taxes paid disclosure applies to all entities: income taxes paid, net of refunds received, split between federal, state and foreign, and by individual jurisdiction where the amount is at least 5 percent of total income taxes paid. The update also removed two older disclosures: the cumulative amount of each type of temporary difference when no deferred tax liability is recognized on investments in subsidiaries, and the positions reasonably possible to change significantly within 12 months.
Brenlow Fluid Systems, the fictional manufacturer of the book, is a public business entity with a calendar year, so 2025 is its first year under the new categories, adopted prospectively. Its pre-tax income is $96,400,000 in the US and $11,600,000 at its European sales subsidiary: $108,000,000 in all. Total income tax expense is $17,167,200 current plus $8,283,400 deferred, $25,450,600, and $25,450,600 / $108,000,000 = 23.57 percent.
| Line, in the order of the disclosure | How it is computed | Amount | Percent |
|---|---|---|---|
| Income tax at the federal statutory rate | $108,000,000 x 21.00% | $22,680,000 | 21.00% |
| State and local income tax, net of federal income tax effect | ($96,400,000 + $2,400,000) x 3.95% + $71,100 | $3,973,700 | 3.68% |
| Foreign tax effects | $11,600,000 x (25.00% - 21.00%) | $464,000 | 0.43% |
| Effect of changes in tax laws or rates enacted in the current period | none in 2025 | $0 | 0.00% |
| Effect of cross-border tax laws | set at zero in the case | $0 | 0.00% |
| Tax credits | federal research credit claimed | -$2,400,000 | -2.22% |
| Changes in valuation allowances | release as state losses were used | -$71,100 | -0.07% |
| Nontaxable or nondeductible items | $2,400,000 x 21.00% | $504,000 | 0.47% |
| Changes in unrecognized tax benefits | new position of the year | $300,000 | 0.28% |
| Total: income tax expense | sum of the lines | $25,450,600 | 23.57% |
Read the lines one at a time. State tax uses the case rate of 5.00 percent net of the federal benefit, 5.00% x (100% - 21.00%) = 3.95%, on US income plus the nondeductible items, and adds the $71,100 deferred tax asset that a subsidiary used against its own state losses. The same $71,100 comes back in the valuation allowance line with the opposite sign, because that asset was fully reserved: the two lines are shown gross, not netted away. The foreign line is the rate difference only, $11,600,000 taxed at 25.00 instead of 21.00 percent. The nondeductible line is the fines and penalties and the compensation above the $1,000,000 limit, $2,400,000, at the federal rate. The research credit enters at its full claimed amount, and the part not recognized under the uncertain position analysis, $300,000, sits on its own line.
The threshold for 2025 is $108,000,000 x 21.00% x 5.00% = $1,134,000. Tax credits, at $2,400,000, are above it, so the category is broken out by nature; here the federal research credit is its only item. Foreign tax effects ($464,000) and nontaxable or nondeductible items ($504,000) are below it and stay one line each, as does the zero line for cross-border tax laws. The state and local line carries its qualitative note: two consolidated filing states make up the majority.
| Jurisdiction | Paid, net of refunds |
|---|---|
| Federal | $10,100,000 |
| State 1 | $1,420,000 |
| State 2 | $910,000 |
| Brenlow Europe's jurisdiction | $2,750,000 |
| Other states (largest single payment $310,000) | $820,000 |
| Total | $16,000,000 |
Federal, the two main states and the European jurisdiction each pass $800,000 and are shown separately. The other states paid $820,000 together, but none reaches the threshold on its own, so they stay in one line. Taxes paid are not the current tax expense of the year: in the case, $16,000,000 was paid in 2025 against $17,167,200 of current tax expense, and the disclosure asks for the cash figure.
The trap: building the reconciliation backward from the rate. The lines are computed one by one from the provision, and the total has to equal total income tax expense to the dollar before anyone reads the percentages. Rounded percentages can miss the total by 0.01; the dollar column is the one that must close. The effective tax rate is a result of the year, not a goal to reach.
Rules as read in November 2026: the codification paragraphs are those quoted in dated summaries of the standard, since the codification itself sits behind a login. US rules only, illustrative, and not tax, accounting, audit or legal advice; ask the company’s tax advisers and external auditors about a real case. The company in the examples is fictional, its figures are teaching assumptions, and no effective tax rate shown is a goal.
State and local income tax net of federal effect, foreign tax effects, changes in tax laws or rates enacted in the period, cross-border tax laws, tax credits, changes in valuation allowances, nontaxable or nondeductible items, and changes in unrecognized tax benefits (ASC 740-10-50-12A).
An item in four of the categories is broken out by nature when it is at least 5 percent of pre-tax income times the 21 percent federal rate, which is 1.05 percent of pre-tax income.
For entities other than public business entities, from annual periods beginning after 15 December 2025, with a qualitative description of the reconciliation instead of a numerical one. Early adoption is permitted.
Yes. As read in November 2026, the income taxes paid disclosure applies to all entities: net of refunds, split between federal, state and foreign, and by jurisdiction at 5 percent or more of the total.
This article is one step of The Income Tax Provision Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to ASC 740 seen from the desk of the person who prepares the provision: the current provision, the tax balance sheet and its rollforward, valuation allowances, uncertain tax positions, the rate reconciliation and the income tax note, the quarterly provision, the return-to-provision true-up and a new tax law at enactment.
DRM-free PDF, $19.99 · Paperback, $32.99, shipped worldwide · Free Excel template