Articles

How does the throwback rule work in state income tax?

Throwback assigns a sale of goods back to the state it was shipped from when the seller is not taxable in the buyer's state, so that the sale is taxed somewhere. Throwout removes such sales from the denominator instead.

Throwback closes a gap in the destination rule: goods shipped into a state that cannot tax the seller would otherwise be taxed nowhere. In the worked case below, throwback adds $50,550,000 to a manufacturer's Illinois numerator and $449,000 to its Illinois tax for 2026, more than twice the Illinois tax on everything else it sells.

Worked in full in The State Corporate Income Tax Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

The rule

Illinois, like many states, sources a sale of tangible goods to the state of delivery, then adds a throwback: a sale is an Illinois sale if the goods are shipped from Illinois and either the buyer is the US government or the seller is not taxable in the buyer's state. "Not taxable" is technical: a seller protected by P.L. 86-272 in a state is generally not taxable there, unless it pays another tax the definition lists, such as a franchise tax for the privilege of doing business, while a seller with nexus in a state that has no income tax may still be taxable there under the jurisdiction test. Pennsylvania and Texas have no throwback; California has one.

The case

Ostrander Flow Controls, a fictional maker of flow meters, ships from its Naperville, Illinois plant and from a distribution center in Dallas. It is taxable in Illinois, California, Texas and Pennsylvania, and protected elsewhere because it only solicits orders there.

Meters in the Illinois numerator, 2026 ($ thousands)
Delivered toAmountShipped fromIllinois numerator
Illinois21,000Naperville21,000
California, Texas, Pennsylvania54,000Naperville or Dallas0
Indiana (protected)7,200Naperville7,200
Other states (protected)43,350Naperville43,350
Other states (protected)14,450Dallas0
Total140,00071,550

With $3,200,000 of services received in Illinois, the Illinois numerator is $74,750,000 and the factor 48.86%. Without throwback, the numerator would be $24,200,000, the factor 15.82%, and the Illinois tax $167,000 instead of $616,000. The meters shipped from Dallas are taxed nowhere: they did not leave Illinois, Texas has no throwback, and Texas courts treat goods handed to a common carrier for delivery out of the state as non-Texas receipts.

Throwback after a nexus finding

A throwback position is a nexus position. In 2024 and 2025, Ostrander threw back its Pennsylvania shipments to Illinois, believing it was protected there. It was not: a service contract had ended its protection. When it came forward in Pennsylvania and paid $142,000 of tax for those years, it could also amend its Illinois returns to remove the Pennsylvania sales from the throwback. The Illinois refunds came to $145,000, almost the same amount, though each side carries its own interest and limitation periods.

The planning lesson is narrow: shipping from another warehouse or creating nexus elsewhere can reduce throwback, but a change made only for tax invites a challenge. The safe gain is getting the facts right, state by state, every year.

Takeaway

Free Excel template: State Apportionment Workbook (sales factors, throwback, services sourcing, state bases and tax by state).

Also on this site: a state apportionment formula example · what P.L. 86-272 protects.

Questions readers ask

What is the difference between throwback and throwout?

Throwback adds a sale into a state where the seller is not taxable to the numerator of the state the goods were shipped from. Throwout removes the sale from the denominator, which raises every state's factor a little instead of the shipping state's a lot.

Does throwback apply to services?

Throwback rules are written for sales of tangible goods shipped from the state. Services are sourced under separate rules, and some states have comparable provisions for receipts that cannot be assigned.

Is a company taxable in a state with no corporate income tax?

For throwback purposes, often yes: under the standard definition a seller is taxable in another state if that state has jurisdiction to impose a net income tax on it, whether or not it does. A seller protected by P.L. 86-272 generally is not, unless it is subject there to another tax the definition lists.

Which states have a throwback rule?

Several states, including Illinois and California, apply throwback; others, including Pennsylvania and Texas, do not. The list changes, so check each state's current statute.

Sources: 15 U.S.C. 381 (P.L. 86-272); Wisconsin Department of Revenue v. William Wrigley, Jr., Co. (1992); MTC revised statement of August 4, 2021; 35 ILCS 5/304; California Franchise Tax Board guidance; Pennsylvania Corporation Tax Bulletin 2019-04 and Department of Revenue rate tables; Texas Comptroller franchise tax tables; NuStar Energy v. Hegar (Texas Supreme Court, March 13, 2026); checked on 18 November 2026. Figures computed by the author's model for a fictional company. Education only, not tax, accounting or legal advice.

Read the whole case

This article is one calculation from The State Corporate Income Tax Handbook. The book follows one manufacturer's state returns in four states through a year, from the nexus review to the memo to the CFO, and every figure it prints is a live formula in the free workbook.

Get the PDF edition, $19.99 Paperback · Free companion files