Articles

What activities lose P.L. 86-272 protection?

P.L. 86-272 bars a state net income tax on a company whose only activity in the state is soliciting orders for tangible goods, approved and shipped from outside. One regular unprotected activity ends it for all income in the state.

Public Law 86-272, enacted in 1959, protects sellers of goods from state net income taxes when all they do in a state is solicit orders. It does not protect services, gross receipts taxes or margin taxes, and it is lost by a single regular activity beyond solicitation. In the worked case below, a calibration contract ended a manufacturer's protection in Pennsylvania, and losing it in Indiana would actually have lowered its total state tax by $30,000.

Worked in full in The State Corporate Income Tax Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

What the statute protects

The protection has four limits. It covers only net income taxes, not a gross receipts tax, a margin tax or a capital-based franchise tax. It covers only sales of tangible personal property: selling a service or licensing software is outside it. The activity in the state must be the solicitation of orders, or entirely ancillary to it. And orders must be approved and filled from outside the state.

Solicitation and the de minimis test

In Wisconsin Department of Revenue v. William Wrigley, Jr., Co. (1992), the Supreme Court held that solicitation covers requests for purchases and activities entirely ancillary to them, those with no independent business purpose. Activities beyond that are tolerated only if they are de minimis, judged by whether they are regular and systematic. Typical unprotected activities: installation, repair, calibration or replacement of products after the sale, collecting delinquent accounts, approving orders in the state, keeping inventory there, and any service sold for a separate charge.

Internet activities

On August 4, 2021, the Multistate Tax Commission adopted a revised statement treating some website activity as business activity in the customer's state, such as post-sale support by chat or email. It applies only where a state adopts it, and adoption is litigated: a San Francisco court held California's guidance void on procedural grounds, New York's rule was upheld by a trial court on April 28, 2025 and by the Appellate Division on May 7, 2026, and New Jersey's amended rule of May 19, 2025 is challenged in its Tax Court.

Case 1: protection lost in Pennsylvania

Ostrander Flow Controls, a fictional Illinois maker of flow meters, sold meters into Pennsylvania through representatives for years, protected by the statute. In 2024 it launched FlowWatch, a monitoring subscription with an annual calibration visit by a contractor. Selling a service and sending a contractor to repair and calibrate products both ended the protection. Its Pennsylvania receipts were $9,100,000 in 2024 and $10,800,000 in 2025, far above the state's $500,000 economic nexus threshold. The tax for those two years came to $142,000, before interest.

Case 2: protection kept in Indiana

Ostrander's Indiana sales representative swapped faulty sensors at customers' sites, a post-sale repair. If regular, that ends protection in Indiana. The cost is not just Indiana's tax:

Losing protection in Indiana, 2026 ($ thousands)
ItemProtectedTaxable in Indiana
Indiana tax at 4.9%034
Illinois numerator74,75067,550
Illinois tax616552
Total state tax1,020990

Because Illinois throws back sales into states where the seller is not taxable, the $7,200,000 of Indiana sales are taxed by Illinois at 9.5% while Ostrander is protected. Taxable in Indiana, they move to Indiana's 4.9%. The company kept the protection anyway, routing replacements through its service desk, to avoid exposure for earlier years and a new filing that saves money only as long as two legislatures keep their current rules.

Takeaway

Free Excel template: State Apportionment Workbook (sales factors, throwback, services sourcing, state bases and tax by state).

Also on this site: a state apportionment formula example · the throwback rule.

Questions readers ask

Does P.L. 86-272 apply to services?

No. It protects only the solicitation of orders for sales of tangible personal property. A company that sells services into a state where it has nexus is not protected there, for any of its income.

Does P.L. 86-272 apply to the Texas franchise tax?

Texas does not treat its margin tax as a net income tax, and the Comptroller does not apply P.L. 86-272 to it. Gross receipts taxes such as Ohio's commercial activity tax are also outside the statute.

What is the de minimis exception?

Under the Wrigley decision of 1992, an activity beyond solicitation does not end protection if it is trivial. Courts look at whether it is regular and systematic, not only at its dollar value.

Does a protected company still have to file?

Sometimes. Pennsylvania, for example, requires a return from a protected corporation with $500,000 or more of Pennsylvania receipts, even though it owes no corporate net income tax.

Sources: 15 U.S.C. 381 (P.L. 86-272); Wisconsin Department of Revenue v. William Wrigley, Jr., Co. (1992); MTC revised statement of August 4, 2021; 35 ILCS 5/304; California Franchise Tax Board guidance; Pennsylvania Corporation Tax Bulletin 2019-04 and Department of Revenue rate tables; Texas Comptroller franchise tax tables; NuStar Energy v. Hegar (Texas Supreme Court, March 13, 2026); checked on 18 November 2026. Figures computed by the author's model for a fictional company. Education only, not tax, accounting or legal advice.

Read the whole case

This article is one calculation from The State Corporate Income Tax Handbook. The book follows one manufacturer's state returns in four states through a year, from the nexus review to the memo to the CFO, and every figure it prints is a live formula in the free workbook.

Get the PDF edition, $19.99 Paperback · Free companion files