Each state taxes a share of a multistate corporation's business income: its apportionment factor. Most states now use the sales factor alone: sales sourced to the state divided by sales everywhere.
An apportionment factor is a fraction: the company's receipts in the state over its receipts everywhere, applied to its business income. In the worked case below, a manufacturer with $153,000,000 of receipts has an Illinois factor of 48.86%, although only $21,000,000 of its goods are delivered in Illinois, because of the throwback rule. Under the old three-factor formula its Illinois tax would be $281,000 higher.
Worked in full in The State Corporate Income Tax Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback
Ostrander Flow Controls, a fictional maker of flow meters based in Naperville, Illinois, had $140,000,000 of meter sales and $13,000,000 of fees from FlowWatch, a remote monitoring subscription, in 2026. It files combined returns in Illinois and California. Its Illinois base, federal taxable income of $9,480,000 adjusted for bonus depreciation and the Illinois tax deducted, is $14,292,000.
The denominator is the company's receipts everywhere from its business: $153,000,000, the meters plus the FlowWatch fees, with intercompany items such as the royalty paid to its patent-holding subsidiary eliminated in the combined return. Receipts from selling capital assets or from treasury activity are often excluded by state rules.
A sale of goods is in the state where the goods are delivered to the buyer. Ostrander delivered $21,000,000 of meters in Illinois and $26,000,000 in California. Illinois also has a throwback rule: goods shipped from Illinois to a state where the seller is not taxable are counted as Illinois sales. Ostrander's sales to Indiana, $7,200,000, and its shipments from Naperville to other states where it is protected by P.L. 86-272, $43,350,000, are thrown back.
Illinois sources services to where they are received, California to where the customer receives the benefit. FlowWatch customers in Illinois paid $3,200,000 and in California $4,800,000, so those amounts enter each numerator.
| Item | Illinois | California |
|---|---|---|
| Goods delivered in the state | 21,000 | 26,000 |
| Goods thrown back | 50,550 | 0 |
| Services received in the state | 3,200 | 4,800 |
| Numerator | 74,750 | 30,800 |
| Denominator | 153,000 | 153,000 |
| Factor | 48.86% | 20.13% |
The Illinois base of $14,292,000 times 48.86% gives apportioned income of $6,983,000. After a loss deduction capped at $500,000, Illinois net income is $6,483,000, and the tax at 9.5% (7% income tax plus the 2.5% replacement tax) is $616,000. In California, the base of $14,612,000 times 20.13% gives $2,941,000 and a tax at 8.84% of $260,000.
Illinois has used the sales factor alone for tax years ending on or after December 31, 2000. If it still used three equally weighted factors, Ostrander's Illinois property share of 84.44% and payroll share of 75.47% would raise its factor to 69.59% and its Illinois tax to $897,000. Double weighting the sales factor would give 64.41% and $827,000. For a company that produces in its home state, the single sales factor is a large saving at home.
The factors of different states need not add up to 100%. Ostrander's Illinois, California and Pennsylvania factors sum to 76.90%: throwback pushes Illinois up, and $14,450,000 of meters shipped from its Dallas warehouse to protected states is in no state's numerator.
Free Excel template: State Apportionment Workbook (sales factors, throwback, services sourcing, state bases and tax by state).
Also on this site: what P.L. 86-272 protects · the throwback rule.
An apportionment formula that uses only the sales factor: the company's receipts sourced to the state divided by its receipts everywhere. Most states with a corporate income tax now use it for most taxpayers.
Each state chooses its own formula and sourcing rules. Throwback can count the same sale in the shipping state, and sales into states where the seller is not taxable may be counted nowhere.
Most states now use market-based sourcing, which looks to where the customer receives the service or its benefit. Some still use cost of performance, which looks to where the seller does the work, and Texas sources services where they are performed.
It applies to business income. Nonbusiness income, such as some investment income, is allocated to a single state, usually the commercial domicile, under the rules of each state.
Sources: 15 U.S.C. 381 (P.L. 86-272); Wisconsin Department of Revenue v. William Wrigley, Jr., Co. (1992); MTC revised statement of August 4, 2021; 35 ILCS 5/304; California Franchise Tax Board guidance; Pennsylvania Corporation Tax Bulletin 2019-04 and Department of Revenue rate tables; Texas Comptroller franchise tax tables; NuStar Energy v. Hegar (Texas Supreme Court, March 13, 2026); checked on 18 November 2026. Figures computed by the author's model for a fictional company. Education only, not tax, accounting or legal advice.
This article is one calculation from The State Corporate Income Tax Handbook. The book follows one manufacturer's state returns in four states through a year, from the nexus review to the memo to the CFO, and every figure it prints is a live formula in the free workbook.
Get the PDF edition, $19.99 Paperback · Free companion files