Deferring pay into a nonqualified plan beats taking it and investing after tax, as long as the tax rate at withdrawal is not much higher and the company pays. The second condition is the one enrollment meetings skip.
In the worked case, $100,000 deferred for ten years at 6 percent and paid at a 42 percent rate leaves $103,869. Taken as pay and invested in a taxable account, it leaves $88,126. The edge, $15,743, is lost if the chance that the company does not pay within ten years is above 21.7 percent.
| Route | After tax in year ten | Edge of deferral |
|---|---|---|
| Deferred, paid at 42 percent | $103,869 | - |
| Taxable account, growth taxed yearly at 28.8 percent | $88,126 | $15,743 |
| Buy-and-hold index fund, gain taxed once at sale | $90,659 | $13,210 |
| Bonds or active funds, growth taxed yearly at 45.8 percent | $79,875 | $23,994 |
The edge comes from ten years of growth without tax. It grows with the horizon: over five years, the same comparison gives $6,124. It depends on how you would really invest the money outside the plan, so the honest answer is a range.
Deferral wins unless the rate at withdrawal is much higher than today's: on the ten-year comparison, the edge disappears at a withdrawal rate of 50.8 percent. Many executives pay less in retirement, especially after a move. Paid at 37 percent in a state without income tax, the deferral leaves $112,823, an edge of $24,697. Federal law, 4 U.S.C. 114, bars a former state from taxing nonqualified pay received in substantially equal payments over at least ten years, and certain plans that only restore benefits cut by federal limits; whether a given schedule qualifies is a question for a tax adviser before the move.
Worked in full in The Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback
Free: the NQDC deferral calculator in Excel: the edge of deferring against a taxable account, the break-even tax rate and probability of default, installments and state tax, with its checks.
A deferral is an unsecured loan to your employer. If the company fails before paying you, you stand with the trade creditors; a rabbi trust does not change that. With 30 percent recovered in a default, the ten-year deferral loses on expected value if the probability of default over the period is above 21.7 percent; against a buy-and-hold account, above 18.2 percent; for a five-year deferral, above 11.3 percent.
A rule of thumb: defer what you will not need before the earliest payment date, in an amount whose loss you could absorb, for long enough that the edge is worth the credit risk, with a payout schedule chosen for where you expect to live.
Figures checked on 18 November 2026. The company in the examples is fictional and its figures are teaching assumptions, not market norms, quotes or rules of law. Not legal, tax, accounting or investment advice.
Often, for an executive with a long horizon, a stable employer and a likely lower tax rate in retirement. It is a poor idea for money needed soon, or when the employer's credit is doubtful.
Yes. The balance is an unsecured promise of the employer; in insolvency it is paid only as far as the general creditors are.
On the amount deferred, when it is earned or vests, up to the wage base; not again on the payments or on the growth credited at a reasonable rate.
This article is one step from The Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to designing, funding and running a 409A plan for executives and closely held companies: deferral elections, restoration and SERP credits, rabbi trusts and company-owned life insurance, worked through one company.
DRM-free PDF, $19.99 · Paperback, $32.99, shipped worldwide · Free Excel calculator