Setting money aside for a nonqualified plan never makes it cheaper. It buys protection against a change of heart, or a hedge, and the price is the gap between the crediting rate and what the assets earn after tax.
Per $100,000 deferred for ten years at 6 percent, salary paid now costs a company taxed at 25 percent $75,000. Unfunded, the deferral costs $62,213 in today's money at an 8 percent after-tax cost of capital; in a rabbi trust, $90,281; in life insurance surrendered at the end, $94,046.
A company deducts deferred pay when the executive is taxed, at payment. The unfunded route keeps the cash in the business and pays $179,085 in year ten, $134,314 after the deduction. It costs less than salary only if the company's after-tax cost of capital exceeds the crediting rate; at 4.5 percent it would cost $86,488. Because the promise is a debt, the fair comparison is often with the after-tax cost of borrowing, not the hurdle rate.
| Route | In year ten | Cost today at 8 percent |
|---|---|---|
| Paid as salary now | nothing more | $75,000 |
| Unfunded | pays $134,314 after tax | $62,213 |
| Rabbi trust in funds | $20,983 left over | $90,281 |
| Life insurance, surrendered | $12,854 left over | $94,046 |
A rabbi trust is irrevocable but stays available to the company's creditors in insolvency. It protects executives against a future board or a buyer deciding not to pay; it does not protect them against the company's failure. Its income is taxed to the company, so funds that earn 6 percent grow at 4.5 percent after tax. A springing trust, funded only on a change in control, gives the protection when it matters. Funding triggered by a change in the company's financial health is forbidden by Section 409A(b).
Worked in full in The Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback
Free: the NQDC deferral calculator in Excel: the edge of deferring against a taxable account, the break-even tax rate and probability of default, installments and state tax, with its checks.
Company-owned life insurance grows without current tax, and its death benefit is tax-free only if the notice and consent rules of Section 101(j) were met before the policy was issued. A general account policy credits a declared rate, so it does not follow the markets: in the worked case, setting aside $701,920 a year for five years, the policy would cover 98.0 percent of the liability on a 6 percent path and 107.3 percent after a 20 percent market fall, against 97.0 percent and 97.3 percent for a trust in the same funds as the plan.
The trap: funding the plan to make it cheaper. It costs more than paying salary on every funded route; fund it for what it buys.
Figures checked on 18 November 2026. The company in the examples is fictional and its figures are teaching assumptions, not market norms, quotes or rules of law. Not legal, tax, accounting or investment advice.
No. Its assets remain subject to the claims of the employer's general creditors in insolvency; it protects only against a refusal to pay.
Not in the legal sense: a truly funded plan would be taxed at once. Companies may set assets aside informally, which remain theirs.
It can be for a company that will hold the policies until the insured's death and has met the notice and consent rules; its hedge is loose and its costs are hard to read.
This article is one step from The Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to designing, funding and running a 409A plan for executives and closely held companies: deferral elections, restoration and SERP credits, rabbi trusts and company-owned life insurance, worked through one company.
DRM-free PDF, $19.99 · Paperback, $32.99, shipped worldwide · Free Excel calculator