Articles

Section 409A deferral elections and payout rules, and what a mistake costs

Decide when the money goes in before you earn it, decide when it comes out at the same time, and change neither except under strict rules. A plan that departs from that in its document or its operation fails, and the executive pays.

In the worked case, a payment made too early to a finance chief with a vested balance of $455,835 would bring a 20 percent additional tax of $91,167 on top of $168,659 of federal income tax brought forward, plus interest, if it reached both her deferrals and her company credits.

When the money goes in

An election to defer pay must, as a rule, be made by the end of the year before the services (Treas. Reg. 1.409A-2). A newly eligible employee has 30 days, for pay earned afterwards. Performance-based pay over at least 12 months may be elected up to six months before the end of the period. For a plan starting on 1 January 2027, elections for 2027 pay are due by 31 December 2026, and are then irrevocable.

When it comes out

Only six events allow a payment (Treas. Reg. 1.409A-3): separation from service, disability, death, a fixed date or schedule, a change in control event and an unforeseeable emergency, each as the regulations define it. A reduction of work to more than half of the former level is not a separation. Specified employees of public companies wait six months after separation.

Changing a decision

Worked in full in The Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

Free: the NQDC deferral calculator in Excel: the edge of deferring against a taxable account, the break-even tax rate and probability of default, installments and state tax, with its checks.

What a failure costs

Every vested amount deferred under plans of the same type becomes taxable in the failure year, with a 20 percent additional tax and premium interest. Plans are sorted into types: in the example, a payment taken only from the elective account would reach $428,712, an additional tax of $85,742, leaving the company credits outside. The IRS correction programs, Notice 2008-113 for operational errors and Notices 2010-6 and 2010-80 for document errors, reduce the cost when an error is caught early.

The trap: letting payroll act on a change in an executive's status, such as a move to part-time, before someone checks whether it is a payment event.

Sources

  1. Treas. Reg. 1.409A-2, deferral elections
  2. Treas. Reg. 1.409A-3, permissible payments

Figures checked on 18 November 2026. The company in the examples is fictional and its figures are teaching assumptions, not market norms, quotes or rules of law. Not legal, tax, accounting or investment advice.

Questions readers ask

When must a 409A deferral election be made?

As a rule, by the end of the year before the year the services are performed; within 30 days of first eligibility for later pay; up to six months before the end of a performance period of at least 12 months for performance-based pay.

Can I change my deferred compensation payout?

Only by delaying it: the change takes effect after 12 months and pushes the payment at least five years; for a fixed-date payment it must be made 12 months before.

Who pays the 409A penalty?

The employee: income tax on the vested amounts, a 20 percent additional tax and interest. The employer bears the reporting duties and, often, the pressure to make the employee whole.

Read the whole book

This article is one step from The Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to designing, funding and running a 409A plan for executives and closely held companies: deferral elections, restoration and SERP credits, rabbi trusts and company-owned life insurance, worked through one company.

Also on this site