Articles · US Corporate Tax
Why unwaivable partnership attribution blows up family buyouts and how proper sequencing saves six figures in federal tax.
Direct share certificates rarely decide whether a closely held corporate redemption qualifies for capital gain exchange treatment. Under Section 302(c)(1), the constructive ownership rules of Section 318(a) pull family members, partnerships, estates, trusts, corporations, and options into the shareholder's ownership total.
Section 302(c)(2) allows a completely redeemed shareholder under Section 302(b)(3) to waive only Section 318(a)(1) family attribution, subject to a 10-year prohibition on officer/director/employee/consulting roles, creditor-only debt rules (Treas. Reg. 1.302-4(d)), and a 10-year look-back test (§ 302(c)(2)(B)). It never waives partnership, estate, trust, or option attribution.
| Arthur Hartwell 360-Share Exit ($14,400,000) | 3A: Stays in HFP (FAIL) | 3B: Exits HFP + Waiver (PASS) | Savings / Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unwaivable HFP Attribution (§ 318(a)(2)(A)) | 50 sh (7.81%) | 0 sh (0.00%) | Eliminated |
| Tax Characterization | § 301 Dividend | § 302(a) Exchange | Exchange Won |
| Federal Tax at 23.8% | $3,427,200 | $2,998,800 | $428,400 Saved |
| HIC Ending E&P (Beginning $18,000,000) | $3,600,000 | $11,520,000 | $7,920,000 Preserved |
In Scenario 3A, Arthur's unrecovered $1,800,000 basis shifts to spouse Beatrice's shares under Treas. Reg. 1.302-2(c) (lifting her basis from $960,000 to $2,760,000). Simply liquidating Arthur's HFP partnership interest before closing Scenario 3B unlocks $428,400 in immediate federal tax savings.
Also read: Section 302(b)(2) 50% and 80% tests and Section 304 related-party stock sales.
Run your own cap table through the free Section 302 & 304 Redemption Calculator (.xlsx), or get the complete 15-chapter practitioner guide in The Section 302 and 304 Handbook.