Articles · US Corporate Tax

Section 304 Brother-Sister and Parent-Subsidiary Redemptions: E&P Waterfalls and Basis Traps

Complete worked comparison of Section 304(a)(1) carryover basis traps versus Section 304(a)(2) cost basis preservation.

Selling stock of one controlled C-corporation to a brother-sister affiliate or to a controlled subsidiary does not bypass Section 302. Section 304 recharacterizes the cash sale as a deemed redemption, slashes the corporate attribution threshold from 50% to 5% (§ 304(c)(3)(B)), and pulls combined E&P from both corporations (§ 304(b)(2)).

Brother-Sister (§ 304(a)(1)) vs. Parent-Subsidiary (§ 304(a)(2))

When both branches overlap, Section 304(a)(2) controls (Treas. Reg. 1.304-2(c)). That priority rule creates a massive difference in corporate stock basis:

Worked E&P Waterfalls on the Hartwell Group

MetricScenario 7: § 304(a)(1) HLC Buys 200 HICScenario 8: § 304(a)(2) HFS Buys 100 HIC
Cash Purchase Price / Seller Basis$8,000,000 / $1,000,000$4,000,000 / $500,000
Post-Sale Constructive HIC Ownership75.00% (FAIL)77.78% (FAIL)
Tier 1 Acquiring Corp E&P Drawn / Ending$6,000,000 / $0 (HLC)$4,000,000 / $3,500,000 (HFS)
Tier 2 Issuing Corp (HIC) E&P Drawn / Ending$2,000,000 / $16,000,000$0 / $18,000,000
Arthur Tax Paid vs. Exchange Tax$1,904,000 (+$238,000 penalty)$952,000 (+$119,000 penalty)
Acquiring Corp Basis in HIC Shares$1,000,000 (§ 362(a) Carryover)$4,000,000 (§ 1012 Cost)

In Scenario 7, Arthur not only pays a $238,000 immediate tax penalty, HLC also loses $7,000,000 of tax basis in the HIC shares because of the deemed Section 351 step. Always screen affiliated sales under Section 304(c) before closing, and check the Section 304(b)(3)(B) acquisition debt carve-out whenever holding-company debt is assumed.

Related guides: Section 302(b)(2) redemption tests and Section 318 attribution & family waivers.

Model this live in Excel

Run your own cap table through the free Section 302 & 304 Redemption Calculator (.xlsx), or get the complete 15-chapter practitioner guide in The Section 302 and 304 Handbook.

See the handbook Free Excel calculator →