Articles · US Corporate Tax

Section 302(b)(2) Substantially Disproportionate Redemption Test: 50% and 80% Formulas Worked

How the shrinking-denominator rule, Section 318 attribution, and Section 1059 control partial corporate stock redemptions.

Section 302(b)(2) is the primary mechanical safe harbor for partial corporate stock redemptions. To secure capital gain exchange treatment under Section 302(a) instead of a gross Section 301 dividend, a shareholder must clear three cumulative mathematical hurdles using Section 318 constructive ownership.

The Three Cumulative Thresholds

  1. Less than 50% voting power immediately after the redemption (strictly below 50.00%; owning exactly 50.00% fails).
  2. Less than 80% of pre-redemption voting stock percentage immediately after the redemption.
  3. Less than 80% of pre-redemption common stock percentage (voting and nonvoting combined, measured by fair market value if multiple classes exist).

The Shrinking Denominator Formula

Because redeemed shares leave the corporation's outstanding share count, redeeming 20% of a shareholder's block never reduces their ownership percentage by 20%. If a shareholder holds s constructive shares out of N total shares and targets ceiling t = min(0.50, 0.80 * s / N), the minimum shares redeemed r must satisfy:

r > (s - t * N) / (1 - t)

Worked Example: Meridian Growth Corp. vs. Claire Hartwell

In Hartwell Industrial Corp. (1,000 voting common shares, $40,000/share, $18,000,000 E&P), unrelated corporate investor Meridian Growth Corp. (MGC) holds 200 shares (20.00%, 80% ceiling = 16.00%). Plugging into the formula gives r > 47.62, meaning MGC must redeem at least 48 shares (24% of its block) to pass.

ScenarioShares RedeemedPre-% (Const.)Post-% (Const.)VerdictTax Paid
2A: MGC ($4,000,000)10020.00%11.11%PASS (Exchange)$315,000
2B: MGC ($1,600,000)4020.00%16.67%FAIL (§ 301 + § 1059)$117,600
2C: Claire ($4,000,000)10070.00%66.67%FAIL (§ 318 Trap)$952,000

Notice the two critical lessons. First, in Scenario 2B, MGC's $117,600 dividend tax looks low because of the 65.0% DRD ($1,040,000), but Section 1059(e)(1)(A)(ii) immediately strips $1,040,000 out of MGC's remaining stock basis (down to $3,960,000). Second, in Scenario 2C, Claire's direct ownership collapses from 14.00% to 4.44%, yet family and partnership attribution holds her at 66.67%, triggering a $238,000 cash tax penalty.

Next: read how Section 318 attribution and Section 302(c)(2) waivers work in family exits, or how Section 304 catches related-party stock sales.

Model this live in Excel

Run your own cap table through the free Section 302 & 304 Redemption Calculator (.xlsx), or get the complete 15-chapter practitioner guide in The Section 302 and 304 Handbook.

See the handbook Free Excel calculator →