Articles

What scrap, rework and overruns really cost a machine shop

Overruns and remade parts are hours nobody pays for. Counting them in hours shows what they really cost.

Scrap, rework and overruns cost a machine shop the hours it runs and never bills, the running costs of those hours and the material thrown away. In the worked case, unbilled hours rose from 1,965 to 3,727 in 2025 and scrapped material from $22,049 to $41,474, while billed hours stayed almost flat.

Worked in full in The Machine Shop Owner by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

Free: the machine shop rate calculator in Excel, prefilled with the worked case of the book.

Two kinds of unpaid hours

A machine shop pays for two kinds of hours it never invoices. Overruns are run hours beyond the quoted hours. Rework is the hours spent remaking scrapped or nonconforming parts. Add both to billed hours and you get hours run: every hour a spindle turned on customer work, paid or not.

Hours run = billed hours × (1 + overrun) + rework hours

Halvercote Precision, the fictional CNC job shop of The Machine Shop Owner, ran 34,527 hours in 2025 to bill 30,800: 3,727 unbilled hours, against 1,965 in 2024.

Unpaid hours at Halvercote, 2024 and 2025 (fictional case).
Halvercote (fictional case)20242025
Billed hours30,70030,800
Overrun on quoted hours4 percent8 percent
Scrap and rework, share of billed hours2.4 percent4.1 percent
Rework hours7371,263
Unbilled hours (overruns and rework)1,9653,727
Scrapped material$22,049$41,474

What an unpaid hour costs

Three costs come with every unpaid hour. The machine running costs are paid on hours run, billed or not: tooling and inserts at $7.60 an hour run in 2025, coolant and consumables at $2.60, spindle power at $3.40. A scrapped part also throws away its material, $41,474 in 2025. And the payroll: machinists on two shifts are paid whether the machines run or not, so a remake uses hours the shop had already paid for and that earned nothing.

That is how a year can look steady and still slip. Halvercote's billed hours barely moved and its revenue rose, but its unbilled hours nearly doubled, and its EBITDA fell from $637,564 to $563,175.

The scrap log

Scrap and rework are counted in hours, as a share of billed hours, by machine group and part family, next to the overrun figure. The production manager reads the log at the morning meeting, names a cause for each remake, and takes repeated causes back to the quote, the program or the setup. A doubtful part is never shipped to protect a number, and a nonconformance is never hidden from the customer.

In its December 2025 plan, the shop projected scrap and rework at 3.2 percent of billed hours in 2026 and 2.8 percent after, with overruns at 6 then 5 percent. Those are projections, not results.

The trap: counting scrap in dollars of material only. The material is the smallest part of a remake; the hours are the rest.

Rules as read in November 2026. The shop in the examples is fictional; nothing here is legal, tax, accounting or investment advice.

Questions readers ask

How do you calculate the cost of scrap in a machine shop?

Count the hours spent remaking parts and add the running costs of those hours, the scrapped material and the paid machine time they used. Report it as a share of billed hours by machine group.

Is rework the same as an overrun?

No. An overrun is time beyond the quote on a good part; rework is time spent remaking a scrapped or nonconforming part. Both are unbilled.

Why measure scrap in hours instead of dollars?

Because the hours carry the payroll, the tooling and the power, and they take capacity from billed work. Material is only part of the cost.

What scrap rate should a job shop aim for?

There is no general figure. Set your own target from your own log and track it month by month against the cause of each remake.

Read the whole book

This article is one calculation from The Machine Shop Owner, a practitioner’s guide to the numbers of an independent CNC job shop: machine hours and shop rates, quoting, scrap and overruns, payroll, machines, cash, the lease and the bank covenant.

Also on this site