Articles

How to quote CNC machining jobs without losing the hours

Setup and run hours by machine group times the group's rate, plus material and outside processing: and the overrun that decides whether it pays.

A CNC machining quote is a forecast of setup and run hours by machine group, times each group's hourly rate, plus material and outside processing with their markups. In the worked case, quotes ran 8 percent short of actual hours in 2025 and the blended rate fell $1.90 below the $114.12 the bank covenant needed.

Worked in full in The Machine Shop Owner by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

Free: the machine shop rate calculator in Excel, prefilled with the worked case of the book.

A quote is a forecast of hours

A job shop has no catalog. Every order starts as a quote, and every quote is a forecast: how many setup hours and how many run hours a part will take on which machine group, times that group's hourly rate, plus material and outside processing. The price is fixed before the part reaches a machine. Every hour the estimate misses is an hour the shop pays for and does not bill.

Quote = (setup hours + run hours) × the machine group's rate + material at cost × (1 + markup) + outside processing at cost × 1.10

That is the quote method of Halvercote Precision, the fictional CNC job shop of The Machine Shop Owner. Hours that run beyond the quote, and hours spent remaking scrapped parts, are not billed.

Three numbers to read on every quote

The rate by machine group. One blended rate for the whole floor hides the groups that do not pay their cost. Halvercote quoted its vertical mills at $109.00 an hour in 2025, its lathes at $102.00 and its five-axis machines at $148.00, down from $155.00 the year before to win the first aerospace orders.

The overrun. Actual run hours exceeded quoted hours by 4 percent on average in 2024 and by 8 percent in 2025, with new five-axis parts, tighter tolerances and first-article programs. Overrun hours are paid in payroll, tooling and power, and never invoiced.

The material markup. Material prices paid rose 6 percent in 2025 while blanket orders held part prices, so the markup billed fell from 18 to 15 percent.

Quoting at Halvercote, 2024 and 2025 (fictional case).
Halvercote (fictional case)20242025
Quotes sent420560
Won, share by count34 percent23 percent
Overrun on quoted hours4 percent8 percent
Blended machining rate$107.40$112.22
Rate needed for a DSCR of 1.25$104.08$114.12

The last two lines are the point. In 2024 the blended rate sat $3.32 above the rate the bank covenant needed. In 2025 it sat $1.90 below it, on almost the same billed hours: 30,700 then 30,800.

The quote review

A quote is only as good as the hours it forecast. A quote review closes the loop: on each finished job, compare the actual setup and run hours with the quoted hours by machine group, note the cause of any gap, and feed it into the next quote for that part family. Read the hit rate with it. A quote won at a low rate raises the hit rate and lowers the earnings of every hour it brings.

Terms belong in the review too. The shop's quote and order acknowledgment carry its terms; the customer's purchase order carries others. Under the Uniform Commercial Code's battle of the forms, between merchants an acceptance can form a contract even when it adds terms, and which terms govern is read with counsel, not assumed.

The trap: raising the hit rate by cutting the rate. Count the hours each won quote will consume before counting the orders.

Sources

  1. Uniform Commercial Code, section 2-207, additional terms in acceptance or confirmation

Rules as read in November 2026. The shop in the examples is fictional; nothing here is legal, tax, accounting or investment advice.

Questions readers ask

How do you calculate a CNC machining quote?

Estimate setup and run hours on each machine group the part will visit, multiply by each group's hourly rate, then add material at cost with your markup and outside processing such as heat treating or plating. Read the result against your actual hours on similar parts.

Should setup hours be quoted separately?

Estimate them separately even if you price them in one rate, because setups do not scale with quantity. A short run carries its whole setup.

What is a good quote hit rate for a machine shop?

There is no general figure. Read your own hit rate next to the rate you won at and the hours the work actually took: a higher hit rate bought with a low rate can lower the year.

Do the shop's quote terms govern the order?

Not automatically. When the quote, the purchase order and the acknowledgment carry different terms, which ones govern is a question for counsel.

Read the whole book

This article is one calculation from The Machine Shop Owner, a practitioner’s guide to the numbers of an independent CNC job shop: machine hours and shop rates, quoting, scrap and overruns, payroll, machines, cash, the lease and the bank covenant.

Also on this site