Article · IFRS vs. US GAAP
Why IAS 36 triggers impairments earlier than ASC 360, how Year 2 reversals work under IAS 36.117-124, and what IAS 36.134(f) requires when headroom is thin.
Dual-reporting groups preparing both IFRS and US GAAP financial statements frequently report sharply different impairment charges on the exact same factories and reporting units. On Vanguard Industrial Holdings plc's CGU Beta, IAS 36 recognizes a €62.00M loss in Year 1 and a €24.84M reversal in Year 2, while US GAAP recognizes only €28.00M in Year 1 and €0.00M in Year 2.
Under US GAAP ASC 360-10, long-lived assets held and used first undergo an undiscounted cash flow recoverability test over the remaining useful life of the primary asset. For CGU Beta's long-lived asset group (€144.00M carrying amount excluding goodwill), 8-year undiscounted cash flows plus residual disposal proceeds total €152.00M, which passes Step 1 with zero long-lived asset impairment. Under ASC 350-20, goodwill is then tested at the Reporting Unit level against Fair Value (€132.00M without deducting costs of disposal), writing off €28.00M of goodwill.
| Metric on CGU Beta (€M) | IFRS (IAS 36) | US GAAP (ASC 350/360) | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 Long-Lived Asset Impairment | 34.00 | 0.00 | +34.00 |
| Year 1 Goodwill Impairment | 28.00 | 28.00 | 0.00 |
| Total Year 1 Impairment in P&L | 62.00 | 28.00 | +34.00 |
| Year 2 Impairment Reversal Recognized | 24.84 | 0.00 | +24.84 |
When CGU Beta rebounds in FY2027 to a recoverable amount of €141.00M (versus €116.16M pre-reversal carrying amount), IAS 36.109 mandates reversing the prior impairment up to €24.84M, subject to two strict boundaries:
For CGU Alpha (€56.19M headroom, or 13.87% of carrying amount), a +89 bp shift in post-tax WACC (from 8.50% to 9.39%, corresponding to an 11.77% implied pre-tax discount rate), a -119 bp drop in terminal growth (to 0.81%), or a -9.56% uniform EBITDA decline reduces headroom to zero. Because each shift is reasonably possible in an industrial cycle, IAS 36.134(f) requires disclosing the exact headroom, base assumption, and break-even delta in the financial statement notes.
Inspect CGU_Beta_Y2_Reversal and IAS36_vs_USGAAP in our free workbook.
Read the companion guides: Value in Use & Pre-Tax Discount Rate Worked Example and CGU Goodwill Allocation & Appendix C NCI Gross-Up, or explore The IAS 36 Impairment of Assets Handbook. Related handbooks: UK Corporate Interest Restriction and Basel III Leverage Ratio.