Article · IAS 36 Valuation

IAS 36 Value in Use and Pre-Tax Discount Rate: Worked Example vs. Naive WACC/(1-t)

Why IAS 36.55 requires a pre-tax discount rate, why grossing up post-tax WACC by (1 - t) creates a €36.69M valuation error, and how to iterate to the exact rate.

IAS 36.55 mandates that Value in Use (VIU) be calculated by discounting pre-tax cash flows at a pre-tax discount rate. Yet market-observable discount rates derived via CAPM and corporate bond yields are inherently post-tax. When preparers take the shortcut of dividing post-tax WACC by (1 - t), they systematically distort recoverable amount whenever capital allowances, growth, or finite explicit forecasts exist.

1. The IAS 36.30-55 Cash Flow and Discount Rate Rules

Under IAS 36.33 and IAS 36.44, VIU projections must reflect management's approved budgets over a maximum of five years (unless a longer period is justified), use a steady or declining terminal growth rate, exclude cash flows from uncommitted restructurings and asset enhancements, and exclude financing and income tax cash flows (IAS 36.50). As explained in IAS 36.BCZ85, because post-tax cash flows discounted at a post-tax WACC capture the exact timing of tax depreciation shields, standard valuation practice computes VIU on a post-tax basis first and then iteratively solves for the single pre-tax discount rate r_pre that equates the present value of pre-tax cash flows to that post-tax VIU.

2. Worked Example: CGU Alpha (Precision Automation)

Consider CGU Alpha of Vanguard Industrial Holdings plc (VIH), carrying €405.00M of net assets (€140.00M goodwill, €135.00M plant, €70.00M building, €40.00M customer relationships, and €20.00M net working capital). With a 25.00% statutory tax rate, CAPM cost of equity of 9.875% (Rf 3.00% + Beta 1.25 x ERP 5.50%), post-tax cost of debt of 3.00% (4.00% pre-tax), and an 80/20 target equity/debt structure, post-tax WACC equals exactly 8.50%. Terminal growth is 2.00%.

Line Item (€M)Year 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5Term. Y6
EBITDA (Pre-Tax)46.0048.5051.0053.5056.0057.12
Less: Maintenance Capex9.009.5010.0010.5011.0011.22
Less: Change in NWC2.001.501.501.001.001.02
Pre-Tax Free Cash Flow35.0037.5039.5042.0044.0044.88
Memo: Tax Depreciation18.0016.0014.5013.0011.5011.22
Less: Cash Tax (25.00%)7.008.139.1310.1311.1311.48
Post-Tax Free Cash Flow28.0029.3830.3831.8832.8833.41

Note: Individual line items are rounded independently to two decimal places (ROUND_HALF_UP); subtotals may differ by ±€0.01M from the sum of displayed figures (exact Y6 cash tax is €11.475M, rounded to €11.48M).

3. Iterative Pre-Tax Rate vs. Naive Gross-Up Error

Discounting the post-tax cash flows at 8.50% produces a present value of explicit cash flows of €119.40M plus a discounted terminal value of €341.78M, for a true Value in Use of €461.19M (headroom of €56.19M over carrying amount).

Solving iteratively for the pre-tax rate that discounts the pre-tax cash flow stream to €461.19M yields 10.61% (10.6056%). By contrast, the naive shortcut r_post / (1 - t) = 8.50% / 0.75 = 11.33% (11.3333%) overshoots the true pre-tax rate by 73 basis points. Plugging 11.33% into the pre-tax cash flows produces a distorted VIU of €424.49M, understating recoverable amount by €36.69M (-7.96%).

Why the error occurs: Dividing by (1 - t) assumes zero growth and assumes cash taxes always equal 25.00% of pre-tax free cash flow. With 2.00% terminal growth and front-loaded tax depreciation shields exceeding maintenance capex in Years 1-5, effective cash tax is lower than 25.00% of pre-tax FCF, and growth amplifies the denominator effect (r - g).

Download the live IAS 36 VIU & Pre-Tax Calculator

Inspect every formula in the CGU_Alpha_VIU_Sens tab of our free 8-tab Excel workbook.

Get the free Excel calculator →

Next in this series: IAS 36 CGU Goodwill Allocation, Individual Asset Floors, and Appendix C NCI Gross-Up, or explore the full IAS 36 Impairment of Assets Handbook. Related IFRS title: The IFRS 17 Insurance Contracts Handbook.