Operating lines, headquarters lines by key, deferred taxes, debt and cash, and the tax effect of a loss on deductible goodwill.
The goodwill test compares two numbers, and most of the attention goes to the fair value. The carrying amount gets less, yet every line put in it or left out of it moves the headroom dollar for dollar. A unit's carrying amount must be built on the same base as its fair value: if the fair value is an enterprise value, the carrying amount excludes debt and cash; if a headquarters asset is part of what a buyer would pay for, its share belongs in the unit. Here is how to build it line by line, and what changes when the loss falls on deductible goodwill.
Worked in full in The Goodwill Impairment Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →
The one-step test, in force since ASU 2017-04, compares the fair value of a reporting unit with its carrying amount and records a loss for the excess, never more than the goodwill of the unit. There is no second measurement to absorb an inconsistency. If the fair value is computed on unlevered cash flows and EV to EBITDA multiples, it is an enterprise value, and the carrying amount must exclude debt and cash too. If the fair value were an equity value, debt would have to come into the carrying amount. Either premise can be argued; mixing them cannot. Choose one, write it down, and apply it to every unit at every date.
As professional summaries of the codification read in November 2026 put it, assets and liabilities that are not directly attributable are assigned to units on a basis that is reasonable and supportable and applied consistently. In practice that means a key per line: revenue, headcount, the net book value of equipment. Write the key next to each line, split each line so that the shares add up to the line exactly, and keep the method from one year to the next.
Debt and cash stay out on an enterprise premise. So do the items that no unit would carry in a sale: a head office building, a closed pension plan kept centrally, its deferred tax asset, a litigation reserve. They are not lost: they reappear in the reconciliation of the units' fair values to the market capitalization, each one listed with its sign. A line that is neither in a unit nor in that bridge is a line the file forgot.
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Receivables and other working capital, net | $31,000,000 |
| Property and equipment | $64,000,000 |
| Customer relationships | $22,000,000 |
| Goodwill | $118,000,000 |
| Deferred tax liability | -$9,000,000 |
| Share of the shared IT platform (revenue key) | $7,000,000 |
| Carrying amount | $233,000,000 |
The unit's fair value is $219,000,000. The excess of the carrying amount over the fair value is $14,000,000. What the loss is depends on one fact the carrying amount table does not show: whether the goodwill is deductible for tax.
Goodwill from an asset purchase can be deductible for tax. A book loss on that goodwill then creates a deferred tax benefit, which raises the carrying amount the loss was meant to bring down to fair value. ASU 2017-04 addressed this: the income tax effect of the loss is considered, and the example given, as professional summaries read in November 2026 describe it, solves it with a simultaneous equation. At a tax rate of 25 percent:
Had the goodwill not been deductible, the loss would simply have been the excess, $14,000,000, with no tax effect. The loss is still capped at the goodwill of the unit: if the grossed-up loss exceeded it, the loss would be the goodwill and the tax effect the rate times that amount.
The case is fictional: Tarrenford Analytical Group, Inc., a listed US provider of laboratory testing and field inspection services with four reporting units (Environmental Testing, Materials and Construction Testing, Food and Product Safety Testing, Asset Integrity Inspection). Every forecast, rate, multiple, share price and test figure below is a teaching assumption of that case, not a market norm, and the facts of your own company govern. Its food testing unit carries goodwill from an asset purchase, deductible for tax. At its interim test of August 31 in year 2, the unit's carrying amount of $517,906,968 exceeded its fair value of $423,154,393 by $94,752,575. The simultaneous equation gave a loss of $126,336,767 and a tax effect of $31,584,192, and the carrying amount after both equals the fair value. Three months later, at the annual test of December 1 in year 2, the carrying amount read as follows.
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Receivables | $43,120,000 |
| Lab supplies | $5,880,000 |
| Prepaid | $2,940,000 |
| Payables | -$17,640,000 |
| Accrued liabilities | -$11,760,000 |
| Lab equipment | $56,840,000 |
| Customer relationships | $56,000,000 |
| Deferred tax of the unit | $15,090,684 |
| Goodwill | $203,663,233 |
| Wethercote trade name | $55,174,033 |
| Shared laboratory information system (share, revenue key) | $4,980,133 |
| Central reference laboratory (share, lab equipment key) | $2,891,818 |
| Headquarters accrued bonuses (share, headcount key) | -$1,598,878 |
| Carrying amount | $415,581,023 |
Three points in that table are worth a second look. The goodwill line is the goodwill after the interim loss, taken from the roll-forward, not the original amount, so the loss enters the annual test once and only once. The trade name is at its reduced amount, because it was tested and written down before the goodwill. And the deferred tax line has turned into an asset of $15,090,684, carrying the tax effect of the interim loss. Against a fair value of $429,092,918, the headroom is $13,511,895, or 3.3 percent of the carrying amount: the unit passes, narrowly.
It depends on the premise, which must match the fair value. If the fair value is an enterprise value, built on unlevered cash flows and EV multiples, debt and cash stay out. Whichever premise is chosen, apply it on both sides of the test and to every unit.
Yes, the deferred taxes of the unit's temporary differences are part of it. When the goodwill is deductible, the tax effect of an impairment loss is computed with the simultaneous equation so that the carrying amount after the loss and its tax effect equals the fair value.
On a basis that is reasonable and supportable and applied consistently, typically one key per line, such as revenue or headcount. Items no unit would carry in a sale stay at headquarters and appear in the market capitalization reconciliation instead.
Since ASU 2017-04 such units are tested like the others, and the goodwill allocated to each of them is disclosed. Whether to change the premise for such a unit is a judgment to agree with the company's auditors.
This article is one step of The Goodwill Impairment Handbook. The book follows one listed company through two years of goodwill tests: four reporting units and a reorganization, a qualitative assessment, the forecast, the rate and the multiples, the market capitalization reconciliation, carrying amounts built line by line, a trade name and an asset group tested first, an interim loss on deductible goodwill solved with the simultaneous equation, the note, the sensitivities and the model.
Paperback PDF edition, $19.99 Book page and free files
Free: the goodwill impairment test model in Excel.
Case figures computed by the book's model; the companies are fictional and every term is a teaching assumption. Figures checked on 18 November 2026.