Articles

How do you test goodwill for impairment under ASC 350?

Compare the fair value of the reporting unit with its carrying amount, goodwill and deferred taxes included; any excess of carrying amount is the loss, up to the goodwill.

Under ASC 350, as simplified by ASU 2017-04, the goodwill impairment test has one quantitative step: compare the fair value of the reporting unit with its carrying amount, including goodwill. If the carrying amount is higher, the difference is the impairment loss, capped at the goodwill of the unit. Worked on one acquisition: a pass with a thin cushion of $1,692,930 in 2025, then a loss of $13,151,162 in 2026.

Worked in full in The Purchase Price Allocation Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

Free: the purchase price allocation model in Excel, with the earn-out, the four intangible asset valuations, the allocation, the deferred taxes, goodwill and the impairment tests.

The test in four moves

Impairment loss = carrying amount of the reporting unit − fair value of the reporting unit, if positive, and never more than the goodwill of the unit

  1. Test at least once a year, on the same date, and between annual dates when an event makes it more likely than not that the fair value has fallen below the carrying amount.
  2. Test the other assets first: an asset group that includes the unit’s long-lived assets goes through the ASC 360 recoverability test before the goodwill test.
  3. Build the carrying amount of the reporting unit, deferred income taxes included.
  4. Measure the fair value of the unit and compare. There is no second step and no hypothetical purchase price allocation since ASU 2017-04.

Example 1: the first annual test passes, barely

A fictional acquirer bought a precision instruments maker on 1 January 2025 and assigned its final goodwill of $65,777,500 to a single reporting unit. Its first annual test is dated 30 September 2025.

Carrying amount of the reporting unit at each test date.
Component30 September 202530 September 2026
Net working capital$9,900,000$10,300,000
Property, plant and equipment$19,000,000$19,400,000
Intangible assets, net of amortization$39,955,164$34,927,382
Goodwill$65,777,500$65,777,500
Deferred tax liability−$10,809,594−$9,513,720
Carrying amount$123,823,070$120,891,162

The valuation specialist measured the unit with a discounted cash flow at 12.0%: fair value $125,516,000. The cushion is $125,516,000 − $123,823,070 = $1,692,930, 1.4% of the carrying amount. No impairment.

Why so thin: the carrying amount was built from the price paid, which included synergies only this acquirer could reach, while fair value is a market participant’s view that leaves them out. A first test with almost no cushion is normal after a full-price deal, and it is the reason to watch the unit closely.

Example 2: a customer leaves and the test fails

In August 2026 the unit loses its second-largest customer. That is a triggering event, so the acquirer tests on 30 September 2026, the date of the annual test.

First, ASC 360. The asset group (working capital, plant, intangible assets and goodwill, deferred taxes left out) carries $130,404,882. Its undiscounted pre-tax cash flows over the remaining life of the primary asset, the customer relationships, are $136,730,640. They exceed the carrying amount, so plant and intangible assets are recoverable and nothing is written down there.

Then, goodwill. On the revised projection, discounted at 12.5%, the rate the valuation specialist set for the revised projection, the present value of the flows is $63,708,287 and of the terminal value $44,031,903: fair value $107,740,000.

Goodwill impairment at 30 September 2026.
ItemAmount
Carrying amount of the reporting unit$120,891,162
Fair value of the reporting unit$107,740,000
Impairment loss (below the goodwill of $65,777,500, so not capped)$13,151,162

Goodwill falls to $52,626,338. The goodwill was not deductible for tax, so the loss has no tax effect. Had the specialist kept the 12.0% rate, the fair value would have been $113,522,000 and the loss $7,369,162: the rate is the input to defend first.

The trap: leaving the deferred tax liability out of the carrying amount. It reduces the carrying amount by $9,513,720 here; take it out and the loss grows by the same amount, against a fair value that already reflects the taxes a buyer would pay.

Sources

  1. Stout, eliminating Step II: streamlining goodwill impairment testing
  2. Highspring, impairment testing requirements under ASC 350 and ASC 360
  3. Stout, ASC 360 impairment testing of long-lived assets held and used

Rules read on 17 November 2026, paraphrased, not quoted. The companies are the fictional case of the book; rates, royalties and projections are teaching assumptions, not market quotes. Not accounting or valuation advice.

Questions readers ask

Is there still a step two in the goodwill impairment test?

No. Since ASU 2017-04 the loss is the excess of the carrying amount over the fair value of the reporting unit, capped at its goodwill. The hypothetical allocation of step two is gone.

Are deferred taxes in the carrying amount of the reporting unit?

Yes. The carrying amount of a reporting unit includes deferred income taxes, whether or not the fair value is measured as a taxable or nontaxable sale.

Which comes first, ASC 360 or the goodwill test?

When both are triggered together, the long-lived assets of the group are tested for recoverability under ASC 360 first, and any loss there is booked before the goodwill test.

Can a private company skip the annual test?

A private company that elects the goodwill alternative amortizes goodwill, usually over 10 years, and tests it only when a triggering event occurs.

Read the whole book

This article is one calculation from The Purchase Price Allocation Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to acquirer accounting under ASC 805 and ASC 350 with IFRS 3 side by side: consideration and earn-outs, intangible asset valuation, deferred taxes, goodwill, the measurement period and impairment testing, on one acquisition followed for two years.

Also on this site