Articles

How much does module degradation cut a solar project's lifetime revenue?

Panels lose a small share of output every year. The loss looks tiny in year one and adds up to a sizeable, but discounted, number over the contract.

A solar project produces 300,000 MWh in its first year and sells every MWh at $45 for 30 years. If output fell by nothing, its revenue would be worth $167.5m at a 7% discount rate. With 0.50% of degradation a year it is worth $159.7m, which is $7.9m or 4.7% less. By year 30 the plant produces 86.5% of its year-one output.

Learn the whole method: Project Finance Modeling

A course built on one solar project, from P50 and P90 to construction funding, sculpting, reserves, cover ratios and stress tests, with Excel exercises, a 160-question quiz and the Project Finance Model, Pro Edition included ($149 at launch).

Read module 4 and try ten quiz questions, free →

The assumptions

Illustrative solar project, invented figures
ItemValue
Year-one energy300,000 MWh
Contract price, flat$45 a MWh
Term30 years
Discount rate7%
Annual degradation, base case0.50%

Degradation is applied from year two, so year one is the full 300,000 MWh. Availability, curtailment and price escalators are left out to isolate degradation.

Step 1: the output each year

Energy in year t = 300,000 × (1 − 0.5%)t − 1

Year 30 = 300,000 × 0.99529 = 259,412 MWh, 86.5% of year one

Energy over 30 years = 300,000 × (1 − 0.99530) ÷ 0.005 = 8,376,948 MWh, against 9,000,000 MWh with no degradation

Energy and revenue at 0.50% a year
YearEnergy, MWhRevenue, $Present value, $
1300,00013,500,00012,616,822
2298,50013,432,50011,732,466
10286,76712,904,5096,559,998
20272,74712,273,6103,171,734
30259,41211,673,5541,533,521

Step 2: the present value of the revenue

Each year's revenue = energy × $45, discounted at 7%

Closed form: PV = 300,000 × 45 × [1 − (0.995 ÷ 1.07)30] ÷ (0.07 + 0.005) = $159,655,286

Excel: =300000*45*(1-((1-0.5%)/(1+7%))^30)/(7%+0.5%)

Without degradation the same formula with 0% gives $167,522,056; the loss is $7,866,770

Over 30 years the plant sells 6.9% less energy than without degradation, but the present value falls by 4.7%. The lost energy is concentrated in later years, which are discounted more heavily, so the value falls by less than the energy does. Present value is the measure a lender or buyer uses.

What if: a worse panel, a better one

Present value of revenue by degradation rate
Annual degradationPV of revenue, $mLoss against none, $mLoss
0.00%167.50.00.0%
0.30%162.74.82.9%
0.50%159.77.94.7%
0.70%156.710.96.5%

Moving from 0.50% to 0.70% costs a further $3.0m. To keep the same present value at 0.70%, the project would need a price of $45.86 a MWh instead of $45, an increase of 1.91%. To match a plant with no degradation at 0.50% it would need $47.22.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How do you model solar panel degradation?

Multiply year-one energy by (1 minus the annual rate) raised to the power of the year minus one. At 0.50%, output in year 30 is 86.5% of year one.

How much does 0.5% annual degradation cost over 30 years?

In this example $7.9m of present value, 4.7% of the revenue, at a 7% discount rate and a flat $45 a MWh.

What price offsets higher degradation?

Moving from 0.50% to 0.70% a year needs $45.86 a MWh instead of $45 to keep the same present value.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Renewable Energy Development Handbook rebuild a fictional 150 MWac solar project from site control to commercial operation, with energy yield, PPA, tax credits and debt in live formulas. The 300,000 MWh project in this article is invented and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on energy, infrastructure and land, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: infrastructure, data centres and energy → · All 1908 articles →