Articles

Is it worth extending a wind farm's life by ten years?

At the end of its design life a wind farm can be repowered, extended or decommissioned. An extension is a small capital decision that is judged by the cash it earns on worn equipment, not by the age of the turbines.

A 60 MW wind farm at the end of its design life can run ten more years for $9.0m of refurbishment. At a 30% capacity factor, 1% a year of output decline, $52 per MWh, $4.0m of annual operating cost and an 8% discount rate the extension is worth $17.10m. It breaks even at $35.20 per MWh, 32% below the assumed price.

Learn the whole method: Project Finance Modeling

A course built on one solar project, from P50 and P90 to construction funding, sculpting, reserves, cover ratios and stress tests, with Excel exercises, a 160-question quiz and the Project Finance Model, Pro Edition included ($149 at launch).

Read module 4 and try ten quiz questions, free →

The assumptions

Illustrative wind farm at the end of its design life, invented figures
ItemValue
Installed capacity60 MW
Capacity factor30%
Output in the first extension year157,680 MWh
Output decline a year (blade and gearbox wear)1.0%
Merchant price, flat$52 per MWh
Operating cost a year$4.0m
Refurbishment and lease renewal, paid now$9.0m
Extension10 years
Discount rate8.0%

Output is 60 × 8,760 × 30% = 157,680 MWh in the first extension year and falls by 1.0% a year. Revenue is output × price, and the extension is worth taking if the present value of revenue less operating cost exceeds the $9.0m spent to get it.

Step 1: the cash flows of the extension

Net cash flow and present value, $m except output (MWh)
YearOutputRevenueOpexNetPV at 8%
1157,6808.1994.0004.1993.888
2156,1038.1174.0004.1173.530
3154,5428.0364.0004.0363.204
4152,9977.9564.0003.9562.908
5151,4677.8764.0003.8762.638
6149,9527.7984.0003.7982.393
7148,4537.7204.0003.7202.170
8146,9687.6424.0003.6421.968
9145,4987.5664.0003.5661.784
10144,0437.4904.0003.4901.617
Total26.10

Year 1 revenue is 157,680 × 52 = $8.199m, and year 10 revenue is $7.490m after nine years of wear. Net cash flow falls from $4.199m to $3.490m because the operating cost does not fall with output.

Step 2: the value of extending

NPV = present value of net cash flows − refurbishment = 26.10 − 9.0 = $17.10m

Break-even price = the price at which NPV is zero = $35.20 per MWh, which is 32.3% below the assumed $52

Every $1 per MWh of price is worth about $1.02m of NPV

Excel: =NPV(8%,B2:B11)-9 with net cash flows in B2:B11

The refurbishment is repaid by about year 3, and the extension earns its return mostly in the middle years, when the $4.0m cost base is covered with room to spare. Deferring decommissioning is a further benefit not counted above: a $3.0m cost pushed ten years out is worth $1.61m today if it stays at $3.0m, or $1.31m if it escalates at 2% a year. That would take NPV to $18.41m.

What if: price, cost, output and length

NPV of the extension when one input changes
CaseNPV
Base case$17.10m
Price of $45 per MWh$9.97m
Price of $60 per MWh$25.24m
Refurbishment of $12.0m$14.10m
Operating cost of $4.5m$13.74m
Capacity factor of 27%$11.81m
Discount rate of 10%$14.97m
Seven-year extension$11.73m
Five-year extension$7.17m

Price is the main risk because the farm sells at the merchant price. Even so, a fall to $45 leaves NPV at $9.97m. The value is also sensitive to length: with only five years of life the same refurbishment still earns $7.17m, so the decision is not marginal unless price falls toward $35.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How do you value a wind farm life extension?

Discount the net cash flow of the extra years, with output falling for wear, and deduct the refurbishment. Here that is $26.10m less $9.0m, or $17.10m.

What price makes a life extension break even?

The price at which the present value of net cash flows equals the refurbishment. In this example it is $35.20 per MWh.

Does deferring decommissioning add value?

Yes. A $3.0m cost pushed out ten years is worth $1.61m today without escalation and $1.31m with 2% a year of escalation.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Infrastructure Asset Manager rebuild a fictional infrastructure platform after the deal, from a regulated water utility, a solar portfolio and a schools concession to covenants, a refinancing, the quarterly valuation and the exit. The wind farm in this article is invented and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on energy, infrastructure and land, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: infrastructure, data centre and energy investing → · All 1908 articles →