Articles

How much life insurance does a buy-sell agreement need?

Enough cover on each owner to pay that owner's price under the agreement, reviewed every year with the value, less any part the agreement deliberately funds with a note the company can afford.

In the worked case, appraised prices are $11,000,000, $6,000,000 and $3,000,000 for three owners aged 61, 54 and 44, against policies in force of $3,000,000, $3,000,000 and $1,000,000. New layers cost $94,200 a year, all premiums $107,000.

The rule of thumb, and why it is only a start

Cover needed = the owner's price under the agreement − any part funded by a note on purpose.

Insurers apply financial underwriting: they cap cover for a buy-sell purpose at a figure supported by the value of the owner's interest, so the request needs a valuation behind it. Value moves, so the cover needed today will be wrong in a few years; review it with the price every year.

Example 1: three owners, one appraisal

Price = percentage × equity of $20,000,000; new 20-year term at teaching rates, not quotes.
OwnerCover neededIn forceNew layer premium
Harlan (61, 55 percent)$11,000,000$3,000,000$76,000
Mireille (54, 30 percent)$6,000,000$3,000,000$14,400
Calum (44, 15 percent)$3,000,000$1,000,000$3,800

Keeping the older, cheaper policies ($12,800 a year) and adding layers brings all premiums to $107,000 a year. Note the end dates: policies bought in 2014 for 20 years end in 2034, which builds a gap into the agreement unless it is planned for.

Worked in full in The Buy-Sell Agreement Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

Free: the buy-sell structure calculator in Excel: the estate tax of four structures at a death after Connelly, what the heirs keep and the survivors’ basis, with its checks.

Example 2: the part insurance does not fund

Disability and retirement are more likely than death and no life policy pays for them. A disability buyout of the founder at $11,000,000, with a $3,000,000 disability policy and a note for $8,000,000 at 6.0 percent, costs $1,433,080 a year over seven years, covered 1.35 times by cash available of $1,937,500, or $1,086,944 over ten years, covered 1.78 times. A retirement buyout of the whole $11,000,000 over ten years costs $1,494,548 a year, covered 1.30 times.

Paperwork that decides whether the proceeds are tax-free

For a company-owned policy issued after 17 August 2006, Section 101(j) requires a written notice to the employee and a written consent before the policy is issued; otherwise the tax-free benefit can be limited to the premiums paid. In the example, a 2014 policy of $3,000,000 without a signed consent could leave $2,898,600 taxable and $608,706 of federal tax.

The trap: insuring the price of the year the agreement was signed. The example's policies were sized for a company worth $9,000,000 in 2019; the appraisal now says $20,000,000.

Sources

  1. 26 U.S. Code 101(j), employer-owned life insurance: notice and consent, Cornell Legal Information Institute

Figures checked on 18 November 2026. The company in the examples is fictional and its figures are teaching assumptions, not market norms, quotes or rules of law. Not legal, tax, valuation or insurance advice.

Questions readers ask

Term or permanent insurance for a buy-sell agreement?

Term is the usual choice when the owners expect to sell or retire before the term ends; permanent cover costs more but lasts for life and builds cash value that can help fund a retirement buyout.

Who should own the policies?

The company in an entity redemption, the other owners in a cross-purchase, or an insurance partnership or trustee. After Connelly, company ownership can raise the estate tax value of the deceased owner's shares.

Are buy-sell life insurance premiums deductible?

Generally no, whether paid by the company or by the owners. Bonuses paid to owners to fund premiums are deductible by the company as compensation, if reasonable, and taxable to the owners.

How often should the cover be reviewed?

Every year, with the agreed value or the latest financial statements, and whenever an owner's holding, health or plans change.

Read the whole book

This article is one step from The Buy-Sell Agreement Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to buy-sell agreements for closely held companies: triggers, valuation clauses, life insurance funding and tax after Connelly, entity redemption, cross-purchase and the insurance partnership, worked through one company.

Also on this site