Since 6 June 2024, a company's duty to redeem a deceased owner's shares does not offset the life insurance it holds to pay for them: the proceeds count in the company's value for estate tax, so an estate can be taxed on more than it is paid.
In the worked case, a founder owns 55 percent of a company worth $20,000,000. If the company holds $11,000,000 of cover on him and redeems his shares for $11,000,000, the shares count at $17,050,000 for estate tax: $6,050,000 of value his heirs never receive, $2,420,000 of tax at 40 percent.
In Connelly v. United States, decided unanimously on 6 June 2024, two brothers owned a building supply company, 77.18 percent and 22.82 percent. The company held $3,500,000 of insurance on each to redeem a deceased brother's shares. After Michael died, the company paid his estate $3,000,000. The estate valued the company at $3,860,000 without the proceeds; the IRS valued it at $6,860,000 with them and assessed $889,914 of additional estate tax. The Court agreed with the IRS: a redemption at fair market value does not change the value of a shareholder's stake, so the redemption obligation is not a liability that cancels the insurance.
The rule in one line: when the company owns the policy, the estate tax value of the deceased owner's shares = his percentage × (company value + insurance proceeds).
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Company value counted for the estate | $31,000,000 |
| Estate tax value of the shares | $17,050,000 |
| Price the estate receives | $11,000,000 |
| Value taxed but not received | $6,050,000 |
| Estate tax, other assets $9,000,000, 2027 exclusion $15,480,000 | $4,228,000 |
Worked in full in The Buy-Sell Agreement Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback
Free: the buy-sell structure calculator in Excel: the estate tax of four structures at a death after Connelly, what the heirs keep and the survivors’ basis, with its checks.
The same company's agreement still uses a 2019 certificate of $9,000,000, so the founder's block would be bought for $4,950,000, with $3,000,000 of company-owned cover. His shares would count at $12,650,000: a gap of $7,700,000, and estate tax of $2,468,000 on an estate that received a fraction of the value. A stale price is also hard to defend under Section 2703, which disregards an agreement price unless the agreement is a bona fide business arrangement, not a device to pass value to family, and comparable to arm's-length terms.
The trap: assuming Connelly matters only to very large estates. With other assets of $4,000,000 instead of $9,000,000, the redemption at the appraised price still owes $2,228,000, because the inflated share value is what pushes the estate over the exclusion; the cross-purchase owes nothing.
Figures checked on 18 November 2026. The company in the examples is fictional and its figures are teaching assumptions, not market norms, quotes or rules of law. Not legal, tax, valuation or insurance advice.
Not in the same way. When the surviving owners own the policies and buy the shares, the proceeds never belong to the company, so they do not raise its value for the deceased owner's estate. The Court itself noted the cross-purchase as an alternative.
The valuation reasoning applies to any entity that owns insurance on an owner and is obliged to redeem the owner's interest. The income tax consequences differ by entity type and should be reviewed with a CPA.
Only if the agreement passes Section 2703 and the older valuation rules, and even then it does not stop the company's value from including insurance proceeds. Counsel decides whether a given price can be relied on.
Measure the gap for each owner, compare the structures, update the price mechanism, and review who owns the policies before changing anything; nothing should lapse before its replacement is in force.
This article is one step from The Buy-Sell Agreement Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to buy-sell agreements for closely held companies: triggers, valuation clauses, life insurance funding and tax after Connelly, entity redemption, cross-purchase and the insurance partnership, worked through one company.
DRM-free PDF, $19.99 · Paperback, $32.99, shipped worldwide · Free Excel calculator