Articles

Entity redemption or cross-purchase: which buy-sell structure?

In an entity redemption the company buys a departing owner's shares; in a cross-purchase the other owners do. After Connelly, the cross-purchase usually wins on estate tax and on the survivors' basis, and loses on the number of policies and the premium burden.

For a founder with 55 percent of a $20,000,000 company, a redemption at $11,000,000 with company-owned cover leaves estate tax of $4,228,000; a cross-purchase at the same price leaves $1,808,000. The survivors' basis is $1,500,000 after a redemption and $12,500,000 after a cross-purchase.

The two structures

Entity redemption: the company owns one policy per owner, receives the proceeds and buys the shares. The remaining owners' percentages rise without any of them paying.

Cross-purchase: each owner owns cover on the others, receives the proceeds and buys the shares personally, usually in proportion to his or her holding.

Example 1: the founder's death in 2027

Price $11,000,000 in both cases; other assets $9,000,000; 2027 exclusion $15,480,000; teaching assumptions.
ItemRedemptionCross-purchase
Estate tax value of the shares$17,050,000$11,000,000
Estate tax$4,228,000$1,808,000
Heirs keep$15,772,000$18,192,000
Survivors' basis$1,500,000$12,500,000
Tax on a later sale at $20,000,000$4,403,000$1,785,000

Worked in full in The Buy-Sell Agreement Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

Free: the buy-sell structure calculator in Excel: the estate tax of four structures at a death after Connelly, what the heirs keep and the survivors’ basis, with its checks.

Example 2: what the cross-purchase costs

Three owners need six policies in a direct cross-purchase (90 for ten owners), and the youngest owners carry the oldest lives. With all premiums of $107,000 a year spread over the buyers, the 55 percent founder carries $17,591, the 30 percent owner $57,490 and the 15 percent owner $31,919. If the company funds the premiums with bonuses grossed up at 40 percent, they cost it $133,750 after its deduction: $26,750 a year more than paying the premiums itself, $267,500 over ten years.

The insurance partnership

An LLC taxed as a partnership can own one policy per owner and pass the proceeds to the survivors. Transfers of a policy to a partner of the insured or to a partnership in which the insured is a partner are exceptions to the transfer-for-value rule of Section 101(a)(2); a transfer to a fellow shareholder is not. Whether a given arrangement qualifies is a question for tax counsel.

The trap: comparing only premiums. The estate tax and basis advantages of a cross-purchase arise only if an owner dies while still an owner; a retirement or disability is usually bought by the company in either design. Put the condition in the board memo.

Sources

  1. Connelly v. United States, No. 23-146, decided 6 June 2024
  2. 26 U.S. Code 101(a)(2) and 101(j), Cornell Legal Information Institute

Figures checked on 18 November 2026. The company in the examples is fictional and its figures are teaching assumptions, not market norms, quotes or rules of law. Not legal, tax, valuation or insurance advice.

Questions readers ask

Which is simpler, entity redemption or cross-purchase?

Entity redemption: one policy per owner, premiums from one checkbook, no risk that an owner lets a policy lapse. The cross-purchase needs more policies or a separate entity to hold them.

Can a company move its existing policies to the owners?

Not without care. A transfer to a fellow shareholder for value can make most of the death benefit taxable; transfers to a partnership in which the insured is a partner are an exception. The company should also be paid the policy's value.

What is a wait-and-see buy-sell agreement?

One that leaves the choice of buyer, company or owners, open until the event, with policies owned so that either route can be funded.

Do S corporations change the answer?

Partly: insurance proceeds received by an S corporation raise every shareholder's basis, which narrows the basis gap of a redemption. The estate tax point of Connelly still applies.

Read the whole book

This article is one step from The Buy-Sell Agreement Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to buy-sell agreements for closely held companies: triggers, valuation clauses, life insurance funding and tax after Connelly, entity redemption, cross-purchase and the insurance partnership, worked through one company.

Also on this site