Book · Julian R. Sterling
Deferred Compensation and Executive Excise Taxes for Nonprofits and Public Employers Under US Tax Law: Eligible Section 457(b) Plans, Ineligible Section 457(f) Vesting, Section 4960 21% Excise Tax on Form 4720, Excess Parachutes, and FICA Timing
Executive compensation in 501(c)(3) health systems, universities, foundations, and public employers operates under a specialized tax architecture that bears almost no resemblance to corporate IRC Section 162(m) planning. Starting in tax year 2026 under Public Law 119-21 (OBBBA, July 2025) and IRS Notice 2026-36, the 21% Section 4960 excise tax expanded beyond the historical Top 5 executives to sweep in every current or former employee of an Applicable Tax-Exempt Organization (ATEO) whose remuneration exceeds $1,000,000 or who triggers an excess parachute payment.
One complete, reconciled five-year case study carries every computation from payroll deferral to Form 4720 Schedule N. Across Alderbrook Health System (AHS, 501(c)(3) parent), Alderbrook Medical Foundation (AMF, 501(c)(3) supporting organization), and Alderbrook Health Ventures, Inc. (AHV, a 100%-owned taxable C corporation), six named executives illustrate 2026 Notice 2025-67 457(b) limits ($24,500 basic, $49,000 special 3-year catch-up), December 31, 2026 Section 457(f) cliff vesting, IRC Section 3121(v)(2) FICA special timing, Dr. Marcus Chen's 60% medical services carve-out ($870,000.00 excluded, preventing $128,582.63 of audit-failure tax), David Ross's $218,400.00 excess parachute cliff and $86,100.21 net cutback math, and Robert Thorne's post-OBBBA inclusion ($23,091.44).
| Tax Year | Regime | 4960(a)(1) Tax | 4960(a)(2) Tax | System Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Pre-OBBBA (Top 5) | $18,900.00 | $0.00 | $18,900.00 |
| 2024 | Pre-OBBBA (Top 5) | $37,800.00 | $0.00 | $37,800.00 |
| 2025 | Pre-OBBBA (Top 5) | $56,700.00 | $0.00 | $56,700.00 |
| 2026 | Post-OBBBA (All-Employee) | $308,538.82 | $218,400.00 | $526,938.82 |
| 2027 | Post-OBBBA (All-Employee) | $52,500.00 | $0.00 | $52,500.00 |
| 5-Year Consolidated Total (AHS $596,118.59 / AMF $49,808.62 / AHV $46,911.61) | $692,838.82 | |||
Download Section_457_4960_Excise_Tax_Calculator.xlsx (6 linked tabs: Controls, 457b_Limits, 457f_SERP_FICA, 4960_Excise_5Yr, Parachute_Cutback, Form_4720_SchN) with live toggles for graded 457(f) vesting, parachute cutbacks, and medical carve-out audit stress testing.
Download free Excel workbookAvailable directly from julianrsterling.com as an instant-download A5 PDF edition and a print-on-demand 6x9 paperback shipped to the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, and the European Union.