Technical Article · Julian R. Sterling
Master Prop. Reg. 1.457-12 noncompete and rolling-vesting tests alongside exact 2026 FICA Section 3121(v)(2) special timing and nonduplication calculations.
In an ineligible Section 457(f) plan, the date on which a substantial risk of forfeiture (SROF) lapses triggers three simultaneous tax events: federal income tax inclusion under IRC 457(f)(1)(A), FICA taxation under the IRC 3121(v)(2) special timing rule, and remuneration recognition for the 21% Section 4960 excise tax.
Under Prop. Reg. 1.457-12(e), a valid SROF requires future performance of substantial services or a bona fide condition tied to the purpose of the compensation. Two high-risk design structures face strict IRS guardrails:
Under the FICA special timing rule (Treas. Reg. 31.3121(v)(2)-1), nonqualified deferred compensation is taxed for FICA at the later of services performed or lapse of SROF. For Alderbrook Health System's four cliff-vesting executives on December 31, 2026, regular wages already exceed the $184,500 OASDI cap, so OASDI on vesting is $0.00, while 1.45% Medicare HI (each side) and 0.90% Additional Medicare Tax (employee only) apply in full:
| Executive | Vested 457(f) | OASDI EE | Med HI EE | Addl Med EE | Total EE FICA | 37% Fed Tax | Net After-Tax |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Elena Vance | $695,563.94 | $0.00 | $10,085.68 | $6,260.08 | $16,345.76 | $257,358.66 | $421,859.52 |
| Dr. Marcus Chen, MD | $162,298.25 | $0.00 | $2,353.32 | $1,460.68 | $3,814.00 | $60,050.35 | $98,433.90 |
| Sarah Jenkins | $463,709.30 | $0.00 | $6,723.78 | $4,173.38 | $10,897.16 | $171,572.44 | $281,239.70 |
| Robert Thorne | $549,959.23 | $0.00 | $7,974.41 | $4,949.63 | $12,924.04 | $203,484.92 | $333,550.27 |
Once FICA is properly assessed at vesting under IRC 3121(v)(2)(B), neither the vested balance nor subsequent reasonable earnings are ever subject to FICA again. When Elena Vance's vested balance earns $41,733.84 during 2027 before distribution, that post-vesting return is taxed as ordinary income under IRC 72 when paid, with $0.00 in additional FICA tax.
Inspect every formula in Section_457_4960_Excise_Tax_Calculator.xlsx or read the full 16-chapter practitioner manual, The Section 457 and 4960 Tax-Exempt Compensation Handbook.
Get the free Excel calculator Explore the handbook