Estimated versus audited payroll, the overtime exclusion, mixed duties and uninsured subcontractors, worked on one employer's audit, with the records that win it.
A workers' compensation premium is provisional until the audit. The policy is priced on estimated payroll by class, the insurer collects a deposit on that estimate, and after the policy expires an auditor measures the payroll that actually counts, in the classes where it actually belongs. The difference becomes a return or an additional premium. This guide works a full audit on Brannock Supply Co., a fictional distributor whose 2026 audit produced $35,163 of additional premium, and shows which adjustments the employer could have influenced, what records win an audit and how to dispute one.
Worked in full in The Workers' Compensation Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in live Excel workbooks.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →
Workers' compensation is priced on exposure, and the exposure base is remuneration by class. Payroll is not known in advance: headcount moves, overtime follows demand and work shifts between departments. Three consequences follow for the finance function. The deposit is a cash payment against an estimate, not the cost of the year, so the audited premium should be accrued as payroll is incurred. The additional premium falls due months after expiry, often when the next deposit is also being paid. And an error found at audit is rarely isolated: it usually reflects a daily practice that also affects the current policy.
Insurers choose the form of audit by account size and complexity, and rules on which policies must be audited vary by state. In principle the forms are a physical audit, on site or by screen sharing, the norm for an account of Brannock's size; a shorter telephone or virtual audit; a voluntary self-audit for small accounts; and interim audits during the year where payroll is volatile.
Brannock's 2026 policy was written at a 1.12 mod on 2026 rates. The estimated (deposit) annual premium was $809,030. On full-year payroll the audited premium is $844,193, so $35,163 of additional premium is due.
| Class | Estimated payroll | Gross at audit | Audited payroll |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8810 Clerical | $5,900,000 | $6,050,000 | $5,740,000 |
| 8742 Outside sales | $3,000,000 | $2,950,000 | $2,950,000 |
| 8018 Wholesale store | $10,900,000 | $11,380,000 | $11,510,000 |
| 7219 Trucking | $5,500,000 | $5,760,000 | $5,770,000 |
| 3632 Machine shop | $4,100,000 | $4,240,000 | $4,170,000 |
Read the table in two moves. From estimated to gross is growth and estimation error: Brannock paid more than it expected in four of its five classes. From gross to audited is the work of the audit rules, three adjustments that change what counts as payroll and where it is rated. One worked in Brannock's favor, two against it.
In most NCCI states the premium portion of overtime pay is excluded from payroll, with local exceptions. The logic is that the extra half of time-and-a-half does not add exposure: the employee works the same hour at a higher price. For time-and-a-half, the premium portion is one third of total overtime pay.
Brannock's overtime pay was $540,000 in the branches and warehouse, $690,000 in trucking and $210,000 in the machine shop. One third of each, $180,000, $230,000 and $70,000, comes out of payroll, and the exclusion saved $21,123 of premium. It is not automatic. It needs payroll records that show overtime separately, by employee and by class. A system that reports only gross wages forces the auditor to include the full amount.
The auditor moved $310,000 of payroll from class 8810, clerical office employees, to class 8018, wholesale store. The employees concerned split their time between the office and the warehouse floor, and Brannock kept no separate records of the two activities.
In principle the clerical classification is available only to employees whose duties are confined to clerical work, away from the operational hazards. An employee who also works on the floor does not qualify, and the payroll of an employee who works in more than one class generally cannot be divided without verifiable records of the time and pay in each. Without them, the payroll goes to the highest-rated class involved. On Brannock's 2026 rates, 8810 is rated at 0.17 per $100 and 8018 at 2.86: every dollar moved is priced many times higher, before the mod. The fix is either to change the work or, where the split is real, to keep time records that support it in states whose rules permit a division.
The audit added $240,000 to trucking, the cost of owner-operators Brannock engaged during 2026 without certificates of insurance. In principle an employer that hires an uninsured subcontractor may be responsible for injuries to the subcontractor's workers, and the insurer charges for that exposure by treating the amount paid, or part of it, as payroll in the class of the work. Rules on the portion included and on owner-operators vary by state. Whether an owner-operator is in fact an employee is a separate question of status.
This adjustment was entirely avoidable. A certificate collected before the work starts, and renewed before it expires, keeps the cost off the audit, and keeps an injured owner-operator's claim out of the class that already drives Brannock's losses.
An auditor who receives this file has little reason to make assumptions. One who receives a raw general ledger has to, and the rules generally resolve doubt in favor of the higher-rated class.
Read the audit worksheet the day it arrives and compare it with your own reconstruction. Errors of fact, such as a missed overtime breakdown or a certificate that existed but was not supplied, are usually corrected on request with documents. Disagreements of classification follow the insurer's dispute process and, beyond it, the procedures of the rating bureau or the state, which differ. Pay the undisputed part, document the rest in writing, and keep the deadline in view.
Audited payroll is the payroll the rating bureau uses for expected losses. When 2026 enters Brannock's experience period, its audited payroll raises expected losses: the January 1, 2028 projection carries E of $984,656, and the mod falls to 1.0628, rounded 1.06. Most of the fall comes from 2023 and the rollover leaving the period, but every dollar of audited payroll also raises the expected losses your claims are measured against. The mechanics are worked in the guide on how to calculate an experience mod, and you can test them with the free Experience Mod Calculator. Audited payroll also sets the standard premium on which any loss-sensitive plan is built; see how a retrospective rating plan is priced.
Finally, set the next estimate from the audit, not from last year's estimate. Brannock's 2027 policy carries estimated payroll of $30,800,000; if the mixed duties and the owner-operators continue, the 2027 audit will find them again. The full audit chapter, the payroll rules behind each class and the cash timing of deposit and audit premium are in The Workers' Compensation Handbook.
In principle, the payroll that counts as remuneration, the class each employee belongs in, excluded items such as the premium portion of overtime, and payments to subcontractors without proof of their own coverage. Brannock's audit moved its premium from $809,030 estimated to $844,193 audited.
In most NCCI states only the straight-time part counts; the premium portion, one third of time-and-a-half pay, is excluded if records show it separately. Rules vary by state. The exclusion saved Brannock $21,123 of premium.
Because they did not provide certificates of insurance. The insurer may then treat the amount paid to them, or part of it, as payroll in the class of the work. Brannock's audit added $240,000 to trucking for this reason.
Accrue the expected audited premium as payroll is incurred, not the deposit, and rebuild the audit yourself before the auditor arrives. Brannock's $35,163 of additional premium was predictable from its own payroll records.
This guide is one arc of The Workers' Compensation Handbook. The book follows one employer through class codes and payroll, the premium algorithm, the experience mod claim by claim, the premium audit, claims and return to work, the loss development triangle and the choice between guaranteed cost, a retrospective rating plan, a large deductible and self-insurance.
Paperback PDF edition, $19.99 Book page and companion workbooks
Free download: Experience Mod Calculator (Excel).
Illustrative figures computed by the book's model; the company, its claims and the case state's rating values are fictional. Rules described in principle as read in November 2026; states differ. Education only, not insurance or legal advice.