Articles

Self-funded or fully insured: how do you compare the cost?

Put the renewal premium beside three numbers for self-funding: the expected cost, the maximum cost under the stop-loss contracts, and the break-even level of claims. A savings estimate alone is not a comparison.

In the worked case, a manufacturer with 400 enrolled employees receives a renewal of $7,174,689 for 2027. Self-funding is projected at $6,579,567 in an ordinary year, a saving of $595,122, but can cost up to $7,996,096, which is $821,407 above the renewal.

The three numbers

Expected cost = expected retained claims + fixed costs.

Maximum cost = aggregate attachment point + fixed costs.

Break-even claims = renewal premium − fixed costs.

Retained claims are the claims the employer keeps after specific stop-loss: every member's claims up to the specific deductible, plus any laser. The aggregate attachment point is a percentage of expected retained claims, often called the corridor.

Step 1: expected retained claims

Start from two years of incurred claims, remove each large claimant's excess above the specific deductible, trend medical claims and drugs separately to the middle of the year being priced, blend the years and weight them against a manual rate. In the example that gives $524.97 per member per month, $5,531,116 for the year, plus $135,000 for one member the stop-loss carrier lasered: $5,666,116.

Step 2: fixed costs

Example: fixed costs per employee per month (PEPM) on 4,800 employee-months. Teaching assumptions, not market quotes.
ItemPEPMAnnual
Administrator (TPA)$38.00$182,400
Network access$16.00$76,800
PBM and care programs$6.00$28,800
Adviser fee$20.00$96,000
Aggregate stop-loss$4.20$20,160
Specific stop-loss at $125,000$105.40$505,920
PCORI fee (estimate)-$3,372
Total$190.30$913,452

Worked in full in The Self-Funded Health Plan Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

Free: the self-funding cost calculator in Excel: fixed costs, stop-loss, expected and maximum cost, break-even and four scenarios, with its checks.

Step 3: the comparison

Expected cost: $5,666,116 + $913,452 = $6,579,567. With a 125 percent attachment, the aggregate ceiling is $7,082,645 of claims, so the maximum cost is $7,996,096. Break-even: $6,261,237 of retained claims, 110.5 percent of expected.

Example: four possible first years against the renewal of $7,174,689.
Year (claims vs expected)Self-funded costAgainst renewal
Favorable year (90%)$6,012,956-$1,161,733
Expected year (100%)$6,579,567-$595,122
Adverse year (115%)$7,429,485+$254,796
Catastrophic year (140%)$7,996,096+$821,407

A level-funded quote sits between the two: in the example it costs $6,953,958 in the expected year and at most $7,238,400, so it beats self-funding only when retained claims pass 111.6 percent of expected.

The trap: trending a bad year's raw claims, which counts the large claims once in the projection and again in the stop-loss premium, and reporting the first year on paid claims, which flatters it by the claims still unpaid (see IBNR).

Sources

  1. CMS, 2027 maximum annual limitation on cost sharing ($12,000 / $24,000), 29 January 2026

Figures checked on 18 November 2026. The employer in the examples is fictional and its figures are teaching assumptions, not market norms or rules of law. Not legal, tax, actuarial or benefits advice.

Questions readers ask

Is self-funding cheaper than fully insured?

In an ordinary year it usually costs less, because the employer stops paying the insurer's margin and risk charge. In a bad year it can cost more, up to the maximum set by the aggregate stop-loss. Compare all three numbers, not the saving alone.

How big does an employer need to be to self-fund?

There is no legal minimum, but small groups lean on stop-loss so heavily that the product looks like insurance; some states also set minimum stop-loss attachment points. Many employers start looking seriously at a few hundred employees.

Does a self-funded plan still have to follow the ACA?

Yes. Market reforms such as the out-of-pocket maximum, preventive care and the employer shared responsibility rules apply whatever the funding; state insurance mandates generally do not, under ERISA preemption, which is a question for counsel in each case.

Read the whole book

This article is one step from The Self-Funded Health Plan Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to leaving fully insured: claims projection, specific and aggregate stop-loss, lasers, funding rates, IBNR and run-out, level funding and the compliance calendar, worked on one employer from the renewal letter to the first year.

Also on this site