Articles

What is IBNR in a self-funded health plan?

IBNR, incurred but not reported, is the cost of care already given but not yet paid. In a plan's first year it makes the bank balance look like a saving; on the balance sheet it is a liability.

In the worked case, expected claims of $472,176 a month are paid on a lag. By 31 December only $4,922,438 of the year's $5,666,116 has been paid, so $743,678 is still owed: the first year's cash surplus of $941,058 is mostly that debt.

The lag

IBNR at a date = claims incurred up to that date − claims paid on them by that date.

Of each month's claims, the example pays 22 percent in the month of service, 48 percent the month after, 14 percent the month after that, and the rest over the next year. Applied to a new plan with no inherited claims, paid claims start low: $103,879 in January, $330,523 in February, $467,455 in December.

The first year end

Paid claims for the year are $4,922,438, 86.9 percent of incurred. IBNR is $743,678, or 1.575 months of claims. A reserve target of IBNR plus 10 percent is $818,045.

Worked in full in The Self-Funded Health Plan Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

Free: the self-funding cost calculator in Excel: fixed costs, stop-loss, expected and maximum cost, break-even and four scenarios, with its checks.

Why it matters

A report that compares paid claims with the renewal premium overstates the first year's saving by the whole IBNR. In the second year the paid figure jumps by about the same amount, because the plan pays the tail of the first year while leaving its own tail unpaid. The liability is settled only when the plan ends, through the run-out, and a stop-loss contract on a 12/12 basis does not cover the claims paid after the year end. Measure the plan on an incurred basis and book the IBNR at every balance sheet date.

Estimating IBNR in practice: once the plan has months of its own data, the administrator builds lag triangles (paid claims by month of service and month of payment) and completion factors. Large claims are estimated case by case, and a change in processing speed can look like a change in cost.

Figures checked on 18 November 2026. The employer in the examples is fictional and its figures are teaching assumptions, not market norms or rules of law. Not legal, tax, actuarial or benefits advice.

Questions readers ask

What does IBNR stand for?

Incurred but not reported: claims for care already given that have not been paid at a given date. In practice it also covers claims received but not yet processed.

How is IBNR estimated for a new self-funded plan?

From expected claims and a lag pattern from the administrator's book of business, until the plan has a few months of its own lag reports.

Who pays the IBNR if the plan returns to fully insured?

The employer: the new insurer covers care from its start date, while claims for earlier care stay with the self-funded plan and are paid as run-out, with stop-loss only within the contract's paid window or a terminal liability option.

Read the whole book

This article is one step from The Self-Funded Health Plan Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to leaving fully insured: claims projection, specific and aggregate stop-loss, lasers, funding rates, IBNR and run-out, level funding and the compliance calendar, worked on one employer from the renewal letter to the first year.

Also on this site