What return must a portfolio earn to justify borrowing against it to invest more?
A securities-based loan turns a portfolio into a larger one at a known cost. The break-even is the loan rate, and the expected gain is small next to the risk it adds.
A client who borrows $2.0m at 5.80% against a $5.0m portfolio and reinvests it breaks even if the portfolio returns 5.80%. At an expected 7.0% the loan adds $24,000 a year but $300,000 of one-year standard deviation, and it pays in only 53.2% of years.
$5.0m, diversified, expected return 7.0% a year with a standard deviation of 15.0%
Loan
$2.0m, interest only, at 4.30% benchmark plus 1.50% = 5.80%
Use of the loan
Reinvested in the same portfolio, so $7.0m is invested in total
Tax and fees
None, to keep the comparison to the loan rate and the return
Horizon
One year, returns normally distributed
The loan is 40% of the original portfolio and 28.6% of the enlarged one (2.0 ÷ 7.0). The question here is not how far the portfolio can fall before a margin call but whether the extra return justifies the extra risk.
Step 1: the break-even return
The extra $2.0m earns the portfolio return r and costs 5.80%, so the loan adds 2.0 × (r − 5.80%)
At r = 7.0%: 2.0 × (7.0% − 5.80%) = $0.024m, or $24,000
The loan adds nothing at r = 5.80%, the loan rate, whatever the size of the loan
Excel: =2*(0.07-0.058)
Step 2: the risk the loan adds
The extra $2.0m moves with the portfolio: one standard deviation is 2.0 × 15.0% = $300,000 a year
Expected gain against that risk: 24,000 ÷ 300,000 = 0.08 of expected gain per unit of risk, against 0.18 for the portfolio over cash at 4.30%
Chance the portfolio returns more than 5.80%: Φ((7.0% − 5.80%) ÷ 15.0%) = Φ(0.08) = 53.2%
In a bad year, the 5th percentile, the portfolio returns 7.0% − 1.645 × 15.0% = -17.7% and the loan adds 2.0 × (-17.7% − 5.80%) = −$469,500
Client outcome by portfolio return
Portfolio return
Return on $5.0m with no loan
Return on $5.0m with the loan
Loan adds, $
-20.0%
-20.0%
-30.32%
-516,000
-10.0%
-10.0%
-16.32%
-316,000
0.0%
0.0%
-2.32%
-116,000
5.8%
5.8%
5.80%
0
7.0%
7.0%
7.48%
24,000
15.0%
15.0%
18.68%
184,000
25.0%
25.0%
32.68%
384,000
The levered return on the client's own $5.0m is (7.0 × r − 2.0 × 5.80%) ÷ 5.0. At a 7.0% portfolio return it is 7.48% against 7.00%, a gain of 0.48 points. At −20.0% it is -30.32% against −20.00%.
What if: the loan rate is different
Loan rate and the odds, $2.0m loan, expected return 7.0%
Loan rate
Expected gain, $
Chance the loan adds value
Loan result in a 5th percentile year, $
4.8%
44,000
55.8%
-449,500
5.8%
24,000
53.2%
-469,500
6.8%
4,000
50.5%
-489,500
7.8%
-16,000
47.9%
-509,500
Each point on the loan rate costs $20,000 a year in expected gain, and the loan stops paying in expectation above 7.0%. The chance that it adds value in any one year stays close to a coin toss, between 47.9% and 55.8%, because the 15.0% standard deviation swamps a spread of 1 to 2 points. The model uses one year and a normal return, so it understates what a sequence of bad years does to a loan that has to be rolled.
The common mistakes
Comparing the loan rate with the portfolio's long-run return. The loan has to be serviced in every year, including the ones where the portfolio returns less than 5.80%.
Treating a 1.2 point spread as a free gain. It is worth $24,000 a year in expectation and comes with $300,000 of standard deviation.
Looking only at the expected case. In a 5th percentile year the loan turns a -17.7% portfolio return into a further loss of $469,500.
Forgetting that the loan is reinvested in the collateral. The loan grows the portfolio that secures it, so a fall hits both the equity and the lending value.
Takeaway
The loan adds 2.0 × (r − 5.80%): nothing at 5.80%, $24,000 at an expected 7.0%.
It adds $300,000 of one-year standard deviation and pays in 53.2% of years.
Each point on the rate costs $20,000 a year, and at 7.8% the expected gain is negative.
Questions readers ask
What return must a portfolio earn to justify borrowing against it to invest more?
More than the loan rate. At 5.80% the loan adds nothing if the portfolio returns 5.80%, and it adds $24,000 a year at an expected 7.0% on $2.0m.
Why is the expected gain small next to the risk?
The extra $2.0m carries the portfolio's 15.0% standard deviation, $300,000 a year, while the expected spread over the loan rate is only 1.2 points.
How often does borrowing to invest actually pay in a single year?
In 53.2% of years here, because a 15.0% standard deviation dwarfs the 1.2 point spread between expected return and loan rate.
The workbooks behind this article
The free companion files for The Private Banker rebuild a fictional founder's portfolio, a securities-based loan and a banker's book, with allocation, fees, drawdown, lending value, margin calls and revenue. The loan in this article is simplified and its figures are invented. No account and no email address.
Buy, borrow, die: is borrowing against stock cheaper than selling?Borrowing against appreciated stock instead of selling it wins when the shares out-earn the loan and are held until the basis steps up at death. On an illustrative $20.0m portfolio with a $2.0m basis funding $1.0m a year for 10 years at 7% growth, a 6.0% securities-based loan leaves $25.37m against $20.40m from selling; the break-even loan rate is 11.4%, but a 40% fall in year 5 cuts the gain to $0.46m and lifts the LTV to 59.2%.
How much does leverage add to a private credit fund's return?On illustrative loans yielding 11.00 per cent, with leverage at 6.50 per cent, a 1.25 per cent fee on assets, 1.00 per cent annual losses and 15 per cent carry over a 7 per cent hurdle, one turn of fund leverage raises the net return from 7.10 to 9.01 per cent and two turns to 10.92. The annual loss rate that wipes out the pre-carry return falls from 9.35 to 6.30 and 5.28 per cent, and leverage stops helping once losses pass 3.25 per cent.
How much does 70% LTV amplify real estate equity returns?Equity change = property change / (1 - LTV). At 70% LTV a 10% value move is a 33.3% equity move either way; amplification is 2.00x at 50% LTV and 6.67x at 85%. Cash yield on equity is (cap - LTV x rate)/(1 - LTV): 8.33% at a 6.00% cap and 5.00% debt, 3.67% at 7.00% debt.
How do you rebalance a 60/40 portfolio? A worked exampleTo rebalance, multiply each target weight by the portfolio total and trade the difference. A 100,000 60/40 portfolio after stocks +20 per cent and bonds +2 per cent is worth 112,800 at 63.83 per cent stocks: sell 4,320 of stocks and buy 4,320 of bonds, or add 7,200 of new money to bonds. Rebalancing after a 30 per cent fall and a full recovery left the portfolio 3,157 ahead in the illustration.