Articles

How far can a pledged portfolio fall before the bank issues a margin call?

The bank does not lend against market value. It lends against lending value, a different percentage for each holding, and a margin call comes when the loan exceeds it.

A founder borrows $2.8m against a $5.0m portfolio: a loan-to-value of 56.0%, which suggests a 44.0% cushion. The bank, however, counts only $3.5m of lending value, so the loan uses 80.0% of its limit. The call comes when equities fall 26.9%, which is a 21.5% fall in the portfolio, because the bonds do not move. If the equities fall 30%, the shortfall is $80,000.

The assumptions

Illustrative portfolio and loan, invented figures
HoldingMarket valueLending value rateLending value
Diversified equity fund$3,000,00070%$2,100,000
One single stock$1,000,00050%$500,000
Investment-grade bonds$1,000,00090%$900,000
Portfolio$5,000,00070.0%$3,500,000

The loan is $2,800,000. A margin call is triggered when the loan is greater than the lending value of the portfolio. The single stock has a lower rate because it is concentrated. For this example the bonds are assumed not to move; equities and the single stock fall by the same percentage.

Step 1: the utilisation of the credit line

Lending value = 3.0m × 70% + 1.0m × 50% + 1.0m × 90% = $3.5m

Utilisation = loan / lending value = 2.8 / 3.5 = 80.0%

Loan-to-value = 2.8 / 5.0 = 56.0%

Excel: =SUMPRODUCT(Value,Rate)

Step 2: the fall that triggers the call

Lending value after a fall x in equities = (2.6m) × (1 − x) + 0.9m

Call when it equals the loan: 2.6 × (1 − x) + 0.9 = 2.8

x = 1 − (2.8 − 0.9) / 2.6 = 26.9%

Portfolio fall = 4.0m × 26.9% / 5.0m = 21.5%

Excel: =1-(Loan-BondLV)/EquityLV

Lending value as equities fall
Equity fallPortfolio value, $Lending value, $Utilisation
0.0%5,000,0003,500,00080.0%
10.0%4,600,0003,240,00086.4%
20.0%4,200,0002,980,00094.0%
26.9%3,923,0772,800,000100.0%
30.0%3,800,0002,720,000102.9%

At a 26.9% equity fall the portfolio is worth $3,923,077 against a loan of $2,800,000, a loan-to-value of 71.4%. The loan-to-value figure on the offer letter would have suggested much more room.

Step 3: what the client must do after a 30% fall

Lending value at a 30% equity fall = 2.6m × 0.70 + 0.9m = $2,720,000

Shortfall = 2,800,000 − 2,720,000 = $80,000

Cure by repaying the loan: $80,000

Cure by selling equity at a 70% rate: shortfall / (1 − 70%) = $266,667 of equity sold and used to repay the loan

Selling equity to repay the loan is dearer than repaying with cash: each dollar sold repays a dollar of loan but removes only 70 cents of lending value, so 30 cents of shortfall is closed per dollar sold.

What if: a different draw, a different holding falls

Fall that triggers a call at different loan sizes
LoanLoan-to-valueUtilisationEquity fall to a callPortfolio fall to a call
$2,100,00042.0%60.0%53.8%43.1%
$2,450,00049.0%70.0%40.4%32.3%
$2,800,00056.0%80.0%26.9%21.5%
$3,150,00063.0%90.0%13.5%10.8%
$3,500,00070.0%100.0%0.0%0.0%
Which holding falls, loan of $2.8m
Holding that fallsFall that triggers a call
Equities and the single stock together26.9%
Diversified equity fund alone33.3%
Single stock aloneNo call: even at a zero price the lending value is $3,000,000, above the loan

A loan of $3.5m, 70% of the portfolio value, would be called on the day it is drawn: its lending value is $3,500,000, equal to the loan, so a loan of 70% of market value leaves no room at all.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What is lending value on a securities-based loan?

The amount the bank is willing to lend against each holding: its market value times a lending rate, such as 70% for a diversified equity fund and 90% for investment-grade bonds. Here $5.0m of portfolio has $3.5m of lending value.

How much can a portfolio fall before a margin call?

In this example the equities and the single stock can fall 26.9%, a 21.5% fall in the portfolio, before the $2.8m loan exceeds the lending value. The loan-to-value of 56.0% understates how close the call is.

How is a margin call cured?

By repaying cash equal to the shortfall, or by selling assets and repaying the loan. After a 30% equity fall the shortfall is $80,000; selling equity at a 70% lending rate means selling $266,667.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Private Banker rebuild a fictional founder's portfolio, a securities-based loan and a banker's book, with allocation, fees, drawdown, lending value, margin calls and revenue. The loan in this article is simplified and its figures are invented. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 36 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on how to read the documents, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: credit, private credit and distressed debt → · All 1908 articles →