Articles

What does one year of construction delay cost a new nuclear reactor in NPV and IRR?

A late reactor costs more than its extended-duration bills. Every dollar of operating cash flow arrives a year later, and at a 7% discount rate that deferral is the larger part of the loss.

One year of delay cuts the NPV of this reactor by $606m, from $208m to −$398m, and its IRR from 7.25% to 6.54%. The deferred revenue costs $388m of that and the $350m of extended-duration costs $218m; restoring the NPV needs a price of $108.41/MWh instead of $100.

The assumptions

Illustrative single reactor, invented figures
ItemValue
Capacity1,100 MW at a 90% capacity factor, so 8,672,400 MWh a year
Overnight cost$7,200m spent evenly over six years, $1,200m a year
Price$100/MWh under a long-term contract
Operating cost$200m a year, fuel and operations
Operating life40 years from commissioning
DelayOne year at the end of construction, with $350m of extended-duration costs for staff, site and testing
Discount rate7% nominal, project cash flows before tax and financing

The delay is one extra year after year 6, with no new capital works, so the capital cost is the same and the extra cost is the one-year bill. Cash flows are taken at year-ends from the start of construction.

Step 1: the base case

Revenue: 8,672,400 MWh × $100 = $867.2m a year; less operating cost of $200.0m is $667.2m

PV of 40 years of $667.2m at 7% = 667.2 × 13.3317 = $8,895m at the start of year 7, or $5,927m today

PV of construction: 1,200 × 4.7665 = $5,720m

NPV = 5,927 − 5,720 = $208m; IRR 7.25%

Excel: =NPV(0.07,B2:B47) and =IRR(B2:B47) with the yearly cash flows for years 1 to 46 in B2:B47

Step 2: the cost of one year of delay

All operating cash flows move back one year, so their present value falls by a factor of 1.07: 5,927 × (1 − 1 ÷ 1.07) = $388m

The extended-duration costs are spent in year 7: 350 ÷ 1.077 = $218m

Total cost of the delay: 388 + 218 = $606m, so the NPV moves from 208 to −398

The IRR falls by 0.71 points, from 7.25% to 6.54%

Interest during construction tells the same story from the lender's side. At 7%, the $7,200m of spend has grown to $8,584m by the end of year 6 and to $9,535m by the end of year 7 once the delay year's $350m is added, a rise of $951m in the capitalised cost.

Step 3: the price needed to make up for the delay

Price that restores the NPV of $208m: $108.41/MWh, 8.4% above $100

Each $1/MWh adds 8.672m a year, worth 72.0m in NPV after a one-year delay

Excel: Goal Seek on the price cell to set the NPV to the base case value

Delay length, NPV at 7% and the price that restores the base NPV
Delay, yearsNPV, $mIRRBreak-even price, $/MWhPrice rise
02087.25%100.00n/a
1−3986.54%108.418.4%
2−9645.95%117.4117.4%

The second year costs $566m on top of the first $606m, a little less because later cash flows are discounted more. Two years of delay takes the IRR below 6% and the break-even price to $117.41.

What if: the cost of delay or the discount rate is different

NPV with and without one year of delay, $m
CaseNPV, on timeNPV, one year lateCost of the delayIRR, one year late
Base case208−3986066.54%
Extended-duration cost $700m208−6168246.30%
Discount rate 6%1,1775436336.54%
Discount rate 8%−533−1,1095766.54%
Strike price $110/MWh9783226567.36%

The cost of the delay is $633m at 6% and $576m at 8%, so it is not very sensitive to the rate, while doubling the extended-duration bill to $700m adds $218m. The model has no inflation escalation of the price, no financing, no tax and no liquidated damages from the supplier, which would offset part of the loss.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What does one year of construction delay cost a new nuclear reactor?

$606m of NPV in this case: $388m from the deferred revenue and $218m from $350m of extended-duration costs, at a 7% discount rate.

How much does the IRR fall?

From 7.25% to 6.54% after one year and to 5.95% after two, against a 7% discount rate.

What price makes up for a one-year delay?

$108.41/MWh, 8.4% above the $100 base price, restores the NPV of $208m.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Nuclear Energy Investor value a fictional two-unit nuclear station under four cases (licence renewal, a hyperscaler power contract, an uprate), with fuel, contracts, debt, decommissioning, new build and SMR models. The new unit in this article is invented and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on energy, infrastructure and land, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: infrastructure, data centres and energy → · All 1908 articles →