Articles

At what power price does a nuclear licence renewal pay for itself?

A renewal is a decision to spend capital now for margin later, so the test is the price at which the margin repays the spend. A small change in that price moves the value a long way.

A 1,000 MW nuclear station with five years left on its licence can spend $480m to run for another 20. At a flat power price of $55.00 a MWh the renewal is worth $425.3m at an 8.0% discount rate. It breaks even at $47.10 a MWh, $7.90 below the base price, and every $1.00 a MWh moves the value by $53.9m.

The assumptions

Illustrative station, invented figures, flat prices, before tax
ItemValue
Net capacity1,000 MW
Capacity factor92.0%
Output (1,000 MW × 8,760 hours × 92.0%)8,059,200 MWh a year
Fuel and operating cost$32.00 a MWh
Sustaining capital spending after renewal$60.0m a year
Licence extension capital spending$480.0m, $160.0m in each of years 1 to 3
Current licence endsEnd of year 5
Renewed licence20 years, years 6 to 25
Discount rate8.0%

Without the renewal the station closes at the end of year 5. Decommissioning is paid either way, only 20 years later with the renewal, so it is left out; counting it would make the renewal look better, not worse. Tax, inflation and any capacity or clean-energy payments are also left out so that the price stands alone.

Step 1: the margin in one year of the extended life

Margin = MWh × (price − operating cost) − sustaining capital spending

At $55.00: 8,059,200 × (55.00 − 32.00) − 60.0m = $125.4m

Excel: =Output*(Price-Cost)-Sustaining

Revenue is $443.3m and operating cost $257.9m, so the station keeps $185.4m before the $60.0m of sustaining spending. The renewal is worth that margin for 20 years, but only from year 6, so each year is discounted five or more years.

Step 2: the present value of the margin and of the spend

Annuity factor, years 6 to 25 at 8.0% = 6.682

PV of margin = 125.4m × 6.682 = $837.7m

PV of the extension spend = 160.0m × (1.08−1 + 1.08−2 + 1.08−3) = $412.3m

Value of the renewal = 837.7 − 412.3 = $425.3m

Excel: =(Margin*(PV(8%,20,-1)/1.08^5))-NPV(8%,160,160,160)

Step 3: the break-even price

Value = 0 when price = cost + (sustaining × factor + PV of spend) / (MWh × factor)

= 32.00 + (60.0m × 6.682 + 412.3m) / (8,059,200 × 6.682) = $47.10 a MWh

The renewal at six flat power prices, $m
Power priceAnnual marginPV of marginValue of renewal
$40.004.529.9-382.4
$45.0044.8299.2-113.2
$50.0085.1568.4156.1
$55.00125.4837.7425.3
$60.00165.71,106.9694.6
$65.00206.01,376.2963.9

The value is a straight line in the price. It is negative at $40.00 and $45.00, turns positive between $45.00 and $50.00 and then rises by $269.3m for every $5.00. A renewal that looks safe at $55.00 has a cushion of only 14.4% before the value reaches zero, because most of the price is operating cost that does not go away.

What if: a dearer extension, a higher discount rate, lower output

Break-even power price when one input changes
CaseBreak-even priceChange vs base
Base case$47.10–
Extension capex $720m instead of $480m$50.93+$3.83
Discount rate 10.0%$48.78+$1.68
Capacity factor 90.0%$47.44+$0.34
Operating cost $36.00 a MWh$51.10+$4.00

A 50% overrun on the extension spend raises the break-even by $3.83, against $1.68 for a two-point rise in the discount rate. The price still matters more than either: a $5.00 move in the power price changes the value of the renewal by $269.3m.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How do you decide whether a nuclear licence renewal is worth it?

Compare the present value of the extra years of margin, after fuel, operating cost and sustaining spending, with the present value of the extension spend. Here $125.4m a year for 20 years from year 6 is worth $837.7m against $412.3m of spend.

What power price makes a licence renewal break even?

$47.10 a MWh for a 1,000 MW station at a 92.0% capacity factor, $32.00 of operating cost, $60.0m of sustaining spending and $480m of extension spend at 8.0%.

Why is the renewal so sensitive to the power price?

Operating cost is fixed in dollars per MWh, so a change in price drops straight into the margin. Each $1.00 a MWh moves the value of the renewal by $53.9m.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Nuclear Energy Investor value a fictional two-unit nuclear station under four cases (licence renewal, a hyperscaler power contract, an uprate), with fuel, contracts, debt, decommissioning, new build and SMR models. The station in this article is invented and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on energy, infrastructure and land, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: infrastructure, data centres and energy → · All 1908 articles →