Articles

What daily charter rate does a bulk carrier need to cover opex, drydocking and its loan?

A ship loan is repaid out of a daily charter rate. The cash break-even adds the cost of running the vessel, a drydocking reserve and the loan's interest and principal, then divides by the days it earns.

A bulk carrier with a $24.0m loan needs $15,688 a day to cover running costs, drydocking and debt service in cash. At a $14,000 market charter it earns $4.851m a year after commission and covers its debt service only 0.82x; a 1.25x cover needs $17,991 a day.

The assumptions

Illustrative Supramax bulk carrier, invented figures
ItemValue
Loan$24.0m at 4.30% benchmark plus 2.75% = 7.05%, first-year interest on the opening balance
Repayment$1.50m a year (6.25% of the loan), the rest due as a balloon
Operating cost$5,600 a day for crew, repairs, insurance, stores and technical management, over 365 days
Drydocking$1.0m every five years, reserved at $0.2m a year
Commission3.75% of charter hire (address and brokerage)
Off-hire5 days a year, so 360 days earn hire

The rate is the time charter equivalent, hire per day on the days the ship earns. Fuel and port costs are paid by the charterer in a time charter, so they are not in the owner's cost.

Step 1: the annual cash cost

Operating cost: 5,600 × 365 = $2.044m

Drydocking reserve: 1.0 ÷ 5 = $0.200m

Interest, year 1: 24.0 × 7.05% = $1.692m

Principal: $1.500m, so debt service = 1.692 + 1.500 = $3.192m

Total cash cost: 2.044 + 0.200 + 3.192 = $5.436m

Step 2: the break-even rate

Hire kept per day of the rate = (1 − 3.75%) = 0.9625, earned over 360 days = 346.5 net days

Break-even rate = 5.436m ÷ 346.5 = $15,688 a day

By component, per net day: operating cost $5,899, drydocking $577, interest $4,883 and principal $4,329, which add to $15,688

The operating break-even, before any debt service, is (2.044 + 0.200) ÷ 346.5 = $6,476 a day

Excel: =(5600*365/1e6+1/5+24*0.0705+1.5)*1e6/((365-5)*(1-0.0375))

Step 3: cover at different market rates

Annual cash flow by charter rate, $m
Charter rate, $ a dayHire after commissionCash flow before debt serviceDebt service coverCash flow after debt service
12,0004.1581.9140.60-1.278
14,0004.8512.6070.82-0.585
15,688 (break-even)5.4363.1921.000.000
18,0006.2373.9931.250.801
22,0007.6235.3791.692.187

At $14,000 a day the vessel earns $4.851m, covers operating cost and drydocking with $2.607m left, and falls $0.585m short of the $3.192m of debt service. At $18,000 the cover is 1.25x. A 1.25x cover needs $17,991 a day, $2,303 above the cash break-even.

What if: the structure or the costs are different

Break-even rate and cover at $14,000 a day
CaseAnnual cash cost, $mBreak-even, $ a dayCover at $14,000
Base case5.43615,6880.82
Loan of $18.0m, amortisation $1.125m4.63813,3851.09
Operating cost $6,400 a day5.72816,5310.73
20 days off-hire a year5.43616,3700.75
Loan margin 1.00% higher (rate 8.05%)5.67616,3810.76

Leverage and amortisation drive the answer more than operating cost: a loan of $18.0m cuts the break-even by $2,303 a day, while $800 more of daily operating cost adds $843. The balloon is outside this test. After seven years $13.5m is still owed, which the ship's value and the charter market of that year must refinance.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What daily charter rate does a bulk carrier need to cover its loan?

$15,688 a day in this case, once operating cost, a drydocking reserve, interest and principal are covered over 360 days of hire after 3.75% commission.

Why is the break-even so far above the ship's operating cost?

Operating cost is $6,476 a day with drydocking. Interest adds $4,883 and principal $4,329, so debt service is more than half the break-even.

How much does a lower loan reduce the break-even?

An $18.0m loan with proportional repayments cuts it from $15,688 to $13,385 a day, and the cover at $14,000 rises from 0.82x to 1.09x.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Ship Finance Professional rebuild a fictional ship credit fund: a term loan on six bulk carriers and its loan-to-value test, and the fund’s other positions. The vessel in this article is invented and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Paperback on this topic

The Marine Insurance Professional
180 pages, printed on demand and shipped worldwide, direct from the author: $32.99 paperback, $19.99 PDF. Not sold on Amazon. See the book →

The bookshop
151 handbooks and exam guides by Julian R. Sterling that are not on Amazon, sorted by subject. 15% off from 2 books. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: credit, private credit and distressed debt → · All 1908 articles →