Asset cover is loan-to-value turned upside down. The covenant bites at a higher LTV than the one the loan starts at, and the room it leaves depends on the date of the test.
A ship loan of $120.0m on six bulk carriers valued at $200.0m starts at 60.0% loan-to-value, an asset cover of 166.7%. With a 125% asset cover covenant, values can fall 25.0%, $50.0m, before the covenant is breached at closing; after two years of amortisation at $12.0m a year and 5% a year of ageing, the room has grown to 33.5%. A 30% fall at closing leaves the cover at 116.7% and costs a prepayment of $8.0m to cure.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Loan at closing | $120.0m |
| Market value of the six vessels (broker valuations) | $200.0m |
| Minimum asset cover (value ÷ loan) | 125% |
| Scheduled amortisation | $12.0m a year |
| Fall in value from ageing, at constant market conditions | 5% a year |
Asset cover is the inverse of loan-to-value: 200.0 ÷ 120.0 = 166.7%, 60.0% LTV. A 125% minimum is an 80.0% maximum LTV. The covenant is tested on the market value of the vessels, which owners and lenders take from independent brokers, not on book value.
Breach value = minimum asset cover × loan = 1.25 × 120.0 = $150.0m
Fall to breach = 1 − breach value ÷ current value = 1 − 150.0 ÷ 200.0 = 25.0%
Excel: =1-Cover*Loan/Value
The fleet can lose $50.0m of value, 25.0%, before the loan is out of covenant. The loan itself is repaid in full as long as the vessels fetch more than $120.0m, a fall of 40.0%; the covenant gives the lender a 15-point cushion above that.
Each year the loan falls by $12.0m while the vessels lose 5% of their value from ageing. The ageing is slower than the repayment, so the cover improves even if the market does not.
| Year | Loan | Value at constant market | Asset cover | LTV | Fall to breach |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 120.0 | 200.0 | 166.7% | 60.0% | 25.0% |
| 1 | 108.0 | 190.0 | 175.9% | 56.8% | 28.9% |
| 2 | 96.0 | 180.5 | 188.0% | 53.2% | 33.5% |
| 3 | 84.0 | 171.5 | 204.1% | 49.0% | 38.8% |
| 4 | 72.0 | 162.9 | 226.3% | 44.2% | 44.8% |
After two years the loan is $96.0m against a value of $180.5m: 188.0% cover, and a fall of 33.5% is needed to breach. A 30% market fall in year two leaves the cover at 131.6%, still above 125%; the same fall at closing does not.
If values fall 30% at closing, the fleet is worth $140.0m and the cover is 140.0 ÷ 120.0 = 116.7%, below 125%. Two ways to cure it:
Prepay: (120.0 − P) × 1.25 = 140.0, so P = 120.0 − 112.0 = $8.0m
Add security: 140.0 + S = 1.25 × 120.0, so S = 150.0 − 140.0 = $10.0m
Prepayment is cheaper by $2.0m because it cuts the debt that has to be covered as well as the shortfall: each dollar repaid removes $1.25 of required value. Additional security, in cash or a further vessel, only adds the dollar.
At a 140% minimum the breach value is $168.0m and the room at closing falls from 25.0% to 16.0%. A 30% fall then needs a prepayment of $20.0m rather than $8.0m. A tighter covenant brings forward the lender’s right to act, and it brings forward the borrower’s cash call in the same proportion.
A minimum ratio of the market value of the vessels to the outstanding loan. With a 125% minimum on a $120.0m loan the vessels must be worth at least $150.0m.
At closing, 25.0% on a $200.0m fleet and a $120.0m loan. The room grows as the loan amortises: 33.5% after two years in this example.
A prepayment of $8.0m after a 30% fall at closing, or $10.0m of additional security. Prepaying is cheaper because it reduces the debt the cover is measured against.
The free companion files for The Ship Finance Professional rebuild a fictional ship credit fund: a term loan on six bulk carriers and its loan-to-value test, and the fund’s other positions. The vessel values in this article are invented and are not in them. No account and no email address.
Not on Amazon: 24 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on insurance and retirement, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →
Reading guide: credit, private credit and distressed debt → · All 1908 articles →