Articles

How far can vessel values fall before a ship loan breaches its asset cover covenant?

Asset cover is loan-to-value turned upside down. The covenant bites at a higher LTV than the one the loan starts at, and the room it leaves depends on the date of the test.

A ship loan of $120.0m on six bulk carriers valued at $200.0m starts at 60.0% loan-to-value, an asset cover of 166.7%. With a 125% asset cover covenant, values can fall 25.0%, $50.0m, before the covenant is breached at closing; after two years of amortisation at $12.0m a year and 5% a year of ageing, the room has grown to 33.5%. A 30% fall at closing leaves the cover at 116.7% and costs a prepayment of $8.0m to cure.

The assumptions

Illustrative ship loan secured on six bulk carriers
ItemValue
Loan at closing$120.0m
Market value of the six vessels (broker valuations)$200.0m
Minimum asset cover (value ÷ loan)125%
Scheduled amortisation$12.0m a year
Fall in value from ageing, at constant market conditions5% a year

Asset cover is the inverse of loan-to-value: 200.0 ÷ 120.0 = 166.7%, 60.0% LTV. A 125% minimum is an 80.0% maximum LTV. The covenant is tested on the market value of the vessels, which owners and lenders take from independent brokers, not on book value.

Step 1: the value at which the covenant breaches

Breach value = minimum asset cover × loan = 1.25 × 120.0 = $150.0m

Fall to breach = 1 − breach value ÷ current value = 1 − 150.0 ÷ 200.0 = 25.0%

Excel: =1-Cover*Loan/Value

The fleet can lose $50.0m of value, 25.0%, before the loan is out of covenant. The loan itself is repaid in full as long as the vessels fetch more than $120.0m, a fall of 40.0%; the covenant gives the lender a 15-point cushion above that.

Step 2: the room grows with amortisation

Each year the loan falls by $12.0m while the vessels lose 5% of their value from ageing. The ageing is slower than the repayment, so the cover improves even if the market does not.

Loan, value, cover and room to the covenant, $m
YearLoanValue at constant marketAsset coverLTVFall to breach
0120.0200.0166.7%60.0%25.0%
1108.0190.0175.9%56.8%28.9%
296.0180.5188.0%53.2%33.5%
384.0171.5204.1%49.0%38.8%
472.0162.9226.3%44.2%44.8%

After two years the loan is $96.0m against a value of $180.5m: 188.0% cover, and a fall of 33.5% is needed to breach. A 30% market fall in year two leaves the cover at 131.6%, still above 125%; the same fall at closing does not.

Step 3: curing a breach

If values fall 30% at closing, the fleet is worth $140.0m and the cover is 140.0 ÷ 120.0 = 116.7%, below 125%. Two ways to cure it:

Prepay: (120.0 − P) × 1.25 = 140.0, so P = 120.0 − 112.0 = $8.0m

Add security: 140.0 + S = 1.25 × 120.0, so S = 150.0 − 140.0 = $10.0m

Prepayment is cheaper by $2.0m because it cuts the debt that has to be covered as well as the shortfall: each dollar repaid removes $1.25 of required value. Additional security, in cash or a further vessel, only adds the dollar.

What if: a tighter covenant

At a 140% minimum the breach value is $168.0m and the room at closing falls from 25.0% to 16.0%. A 30% fall then needs a prepayment of $20.0m rather than $8.0m. A tighter covenant brings forward the lender’s right to act, and it brings forward the borrower’s cash call in the same proportion.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What is an asset cover covenant on a ship loan?

A minimum ratio of the market value of the vessels to the outstanding loan. With a 125% minimum on a $120.0m loan the vessels must be worth at least $150.0m.

How far can vessel values fall before the covenant breaches?

At closing, 25.0% on a $200.0m fleet and a $120.0m loan. The room grows as the loan amortises: 33.5% after two years in this example.

What does it cost to cure a breach?

A prepayment of $8.0m after a 30% fall at closing, or $10.0m of additional security. Prepaying is cheaper because it reduces the debt the cover is measured against.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Ship Finance Professional rebuild a fictional ship credit fund: a term loan on six bulk carriers and its loan-to-value test, and the fund’s other positions. The vessel values in this article are invented and are not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 24 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on insurance and retirement, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: credit, private credit and distressed debt → · All 1908 articles →