Articles

What does a silver stream earn at different silver prices?

A stream buys silver at a fixed low price, so the streamer owns the whole spread to the market. That makes the IRR a steep function of the metal price.

A streaming company that pays $120.0m up front for 1.0 million ounces of silver a year for 12 years, at a fixed $4.50 an ounce, earns an IRR of 13.2% if silver trades at $25.00 and 7.5% at $20.00. The deposit is only returned over the 12 years at $14.50, and the stream reaches an 8% IRR at $20.42.

The assumptions

Illustrative silver stream, invented terms
ItemValue
Upfront deposit, paid at time 0$120.0m
Payable silver delivered to the streamer1.0 million oz a year
Ongoing payment per ounce (the lesser of this and spot)$4.50
Term, deliveries at the end of each year12 years
Cost to the streamer after the paymentNone: no operating or capital cost

The streamer takes silver that the mine produces and sells it at the spot price, paying the mine $4.50 for each ounce. It carries no mine cost, which is why the mine, not the streamer, bears inflation in operating costs. Taxes, delivery timing and the mine’s own production risk are left out; the delivered ounces are assumed.

Step 1: the annual margin at a silver price

Margin per ounce = spot − $4.50, and not below zero

Annual cash flow = ounces × margin = 1.0 × (25.00 − 4.50) = $20.5m

Excel: =Ounces*MAX(0,Spot-MIN(Fixed,Spot))

Step 2: payback and IRR across silver prices

$120.0m deposit, 12 annual deliveries of 1.0 million oz
Silver priceMarginAnnual cashPayback, yearsIRR
$10.00$5.50$5.5m21.82-8.2%
$15.00$10.50$10.5m11.430.8%
$20.00$15.50$15.5m7.747.5%
$25.00$20.50$20.5m5.8513.2%
$30.00$25.50$25.5m4.7118.5%
$40.00$35.50$35.5m3.3828.1%

The IRR is the discount rate at which twelve equal payments of the annual cash flow have a present value of $120.0m. In Excel it is =IRR on the series of −120.0 followed by twelve annual cash flows. At $25.00 the payback is 5.85 years and the IRR 13.2%; the IRR is lower than the simple yield of 17.1% (annual cash divided by the deposit) because the stream has no value after the twelfth delivery, so the deposit is repaid out of the twelve payments.

Step 3: the silver price that the stream needs

Silver price to return the deposit = 4.50 + 120.0 ÷ (1.0 × 12) = $14.50

Silver price for an 8% IRR = $20.42

Silver price for a 12% IRR = $23.87

Below $14.50 the streamer does not get its deposit back over the life of the stream. The 8% and 12% prices solve for a flat price over twelve years, which is a simplification: the actual price will move, and the early years carry more weight in the IRR than the late ones.

What if: a percentage of spot instead of a fixed payment

Many streams pay a percentage of spot instead. If the ongoing payment is 20% of spot, the margin is 80% of the price at all price levels. The IRR is 12.7% at $25.00 (against 13.2%), 2.9% at $15.00 (against 0.8%) and 24.8% at $40.00 (against 28.1%). The fixed payment gives the streamer more of the upside and more of the downside; the percentage version keeps the return steadier. A 20% fall in silver from $25.00 to $20.00 cuts the fixed-payment IRR from 13.2% to 7.5%.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What is a silver stream?

An upfront payment to a mine in exchange for the right to buy a fixed quantity of its silver at a low fixed price, here $4.50 an ounce, and sell it at the market price.

What silver price does a stream need to return its deposit?

The fixed price plus the deposit divided by the total ounces: $4.50 + $120.0m divided by 12.0 million ounces = $14.50.

How sensitive is a stream's IRR to the silver price?

Very. In this example the IRR is 7.5% at $20.00, 13.2% at $25.00 and 28.1% at $40.00, because the streamer's cost per ounce is fixed.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Mining Finance Professional rebuild a fictional mining finance fund: a silver stream, a gold royalty and a lithium project loan, with all-in sustaining cost, resources and reserves, feasibility economics and a gold collar. The stream in this article uses invented terms and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on energy, infrastructure and land, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: corporate finance, valuation and markets → · All 1908 articles →