Articles

What does a mine closure liability cost today, and what does funding it in advance add?

Closure is paid after the mine stops earning, so it looks small in a discounted model. Escalation, the discount rate and the funding method move the answer.

A $90.0m closure estimate, escalated at 2.5% a year and paid in years 11 to 13, becomes $120.5m of cash and is worth $48.6m at an 8% discount rate. That cuts a $216.0m mine to $167.4m. Funding it with a cash trust over 10 years raises the cost to $66.8m of present value.

The assumptions

Illustrative mine, invented figures
ItemValue
ProjectInitial capex $200.0m, then $62.0m of cash flow a year for 10 years
Cost of capital8.0% a year
Closure cost$90.0m in today’s money, rising 2.5% a year
Closure spendingYears 11 to 13 after the start: 40%, 40% and 20%
Trust fund return3.0% a year if cash is set aside
Surety bond fee2.5% a year on a face amount equal to the escalated closure cost

Before closure the project is worth -200.0 + 62.0 × 6.7101 = $216.0m at 8%, where 6.7101 is the 10-year annuity factor.

Step 1: the closure cost in the years it is paid

Year 11: 90.0 × 1.02511 × 40% = $47.2m

Year 12: 90.0 × 1.02512 × 40% = $48.4m

Year 13: 90.0 × 1.02513 × 20% = $24.8m

Total paid = $120.5m, 33.8% more than the $90.0m estimate in today’s money

Step 2: the present value and the effect on the mine

PV at 8% = 47.2 ÷ 1.0811 + 48.4 ÷ 1.0812 + 24.8 ÷ 1.0813 = $48.6m

Project value after closure = 216.0 − 48.6 = $167.4m, a cut of 22.5%

Excel, yearly cash flows in B6:N6 (years 1 to 13): =NPV(0.08,B6:N6)

Closure is paid after the mine stops earning, so its present value is 40.4% of the amount paid, and the mine still carries a value of $167.4m.

Step 3: how the discount rate changes the liability

Present value of the closure cost by discount rate
Discount ratePV of closure, $mMine value after closure, $m
8.0%48.6167.4
5.0%67.7148.3
3.0%85.0131.0

At 3% the liability is $85.0m, 1.7 times its value at 8%. The project discount rate prices risky mine cash flows; the closure cost is close to a fixed obligation, which is why accounting and regulators discount it at a much lower rate.

Step 4: three ways to fund it

Cash trust: the fund must hold 114.2 at year 10, so annual deposits at 3% are 114.2 ÷ 11.4639 = $9.96m, a present value at 8% of $66.8m

Surety bond: fees of 2.5% a year on a face of $92.2m in year 1 rising to $115.2m in year 10 have a present value of $17.1m, on top of the closure cost itself

Cost of closure by funding method, present value at 8%, $m
MethodPresent value, $mMine value after closure, $m
Unfunded, paid in years 11 to 1348.6167.4
Surety bond, closure paid later65.7150.3
Cash trust built over 10 years66.8149.2

The trust costs $18.2m more than the unfunded case, because cash earning 3% sits in a fund while the mine’s own money is worth 8%. The bond costs $17.1m more and keeps the cash in the business. What the regulator accepts decides which is available.

What if: the closure cost is higher

Closure estimate raised, present value at 8%
Estimate, today’s moneyPaid in years 11 to 13, $mPV at 8%, $mMine value after closure, $m
$90.0m120.548.6167.4
$135.0m180.772.9143.1
$180.0m240.997.2118.8

Doubling the estimate to $180.0m cuts the mine to $118.8m. The model has no salvage value, no post-closure monitoring and no tax relief on the spending.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How do you value a mine closure liability?

Escalate the estimate to the years it is paid and discount it. Here $90.0m becomes $120.5m paid in years 11 to 13, worth $48.6m at 8% and $85.0m at 3%.

Does closure cost change a mine’s NPV a lot?

In this case it takes 22.5% of the value, from $216.0m to $167.4m, even though it is paid after production ends.

Is a surety bond cheaper than a cash trust for closure?

Here yes: the bond fees cost $17.1m of present value against $18.2m of extra cost for the trust, because trust cash earns 3% while the mine’s capital costs 8%.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Mining Finance Professional rebuild a fictional mining finance fund: a silver stream, a gold royalty and a lithium project loan, with all-in sustaining cost, resources and reserves, feasibility economics and a gold collar. The figures in this article use invented inputs and are not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on markets, funds and compliance, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: corporate finance, valuation and markets → · All 1908 articles →