Articles

What does a revenue floor cost a battery owner, and how much extra debt does it support?

A floor is priced by what it gives up in good years and valued by the debt it releases in bad ones. The lender sizes on the downside, so that is where the contract pays.

A $100 a kW-year revenue floor, with 50% of revenue above $120 given to the floor provider, costs a 100 MW battery $0.35m a year in expected revenue but raises debt capacity from $42.04m to $56.05m at a 1.30x low-case cover. Expected equity IRR rises from 13.7% to 15.5% and the low-price case from −6.7% to 1.9%.

The assumptions

Illustrative merchant battery, invented figures
ItemValue
Battery100 MW / 400 MWh, capex $80.0m ($800 a kW)
Merchant revenue$80, $130 or $190 a kW-year in a low, base or high price case, with probabilities of 30%, 50% and 20%
Operating cost$20 a kW-year, $2.0m a year
Floor contractFloor of $100 a kW-year; above $120 the owner keeps 50% of the extra revenue
Debt15-year annuity at 7.0%, sized so the low-case cash flow covers debt service 1.30 times
Equity return15 years of flat cash flows, no residual value, no degradation

The annuity factor for 15 years at 7.0% is (1 − 1.07−15) ÷ 0.07 = 9.108. The lender gives no credit to revenue above the low case, which is why a floor changes the loan.

Step 1: what the owner actually receives

Owner revenue = R if R is between the floor and $120, the floor if R is below it, and 120 + 50% × (R − 120) above $120

Low case: merchant $80 is lifted to $100. Base case: 120 + 0.5 × (130 − 120) = $125. High case: 120 + 0.5 × (190 − 120) = $155

Excel, price in B6, floor in B2, threshold in B3, owner share in B4: =IF(B6<$B$2,$B$2,IF(B6<=$B$3,B6,$B$3+(1-$B$4)*(B6-$B$3)))

Revenue and expected value, $ a kW-year
CaseProbabilityMerchantWith floor
Low price30%80100
Base price50%130125
High price20%190155
Expected revenue127.0123.5

The floor costs 3.5 a kW-year in expected revenue, 0.35m a year across 100 MW, or 2.8% of expected merchant revenue. In exchange the low case rises by $20 a kW-year and the high case falls by $35.

Step 2: what the floor does to debt capacity

Merchant: low-case cash flow (80 − 20) × 100,000 kW = $6.0m; debt service = 6.0 ÷ 1.30 = $4.615m; debt = 4.615 × 9.108 = $42.04m

With floor: (100 − 20) × 100,000 kW = $8.0m; debt service = 8.0 ÷ 1.30 = $6.154m; debt = 6.154 × 9.108 = $56.05m

Extra debt: 56.05 − 42.04 = $14.01m, which cuts the equity cheque from $37.96m to $23.95m

Excel, annuity debt from the low-case cash flow in B10: =B10/1.3*(1-1.07^-15)/0.07

Debt rises from 52.5% to 70.1% of capex. The extra $14.01m of debt costs $1.538m a year more in debt service, against a floor that costs $0.35m a year in expected revenue.

Step 3: equity returns

Equity IRR over 15 years by price case; equity cheque $37.96m merchant, $23.95m with floor
CaseMerchant equity IRRWith floor equity IRR
Low price−6.7%1.9%
Base price14.7%16.2%
High price32.1%30.1%
Probability-weighted cash flow13.7%15.5%

The floor lifts the low-case IRR from −6.7% to 1.9% and the expected IRR from 13.7% to 15.5%. The high case falls from 32.1% to 30.1%. Most of the gain in expected IRR comes from the smaller equity cheque, not from the revenue protection itself.

What if: the floor level or the sharing changes

Floor terms and results
CaseExpected revenue, $/kW-yrCost vs merchant, $m a yearDebt, $mExpected equity IRRLow-case IRR
No floor, merchant127.00.0042.0413.7%−6.7%
Floor $100, 50% above $120 (base)123.50.3556.0515.5%1.9%
Floor $90, 50% above $120120.50.6549.0412.5%−2.9%
Floor $110, 50% above $120126.50.0563.0520.7%8.8%
Floor $100, 40% above $120125.40.1656.0516.4%1.9%
Floor $100, 60% above $120121.60.5456.0514.5%1.9%

A $90 floor costs $0.65m a year and adds $7.01m of debt; a $110 floor costs $0.05m and adds $21.02m. Each extra $10 of floor adds $7.01m of debt, and a higher floor costs less here because only the low case ever falls below it. The sharing percentage does not change the debt, only the cost of the contract: 40% costs $0.16m a year and 60% costs $0.54m. A $90 floor is the one case that lowers expected equity IRR, to 12.5%. The model ignores the provider’s credit, any fee for the floor and degradation.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What does a revenue floor cost a battery owner?

In expected value, 3.5 a kW-year here, $0.35m a year on 100 MW. The owner gains $20 in the low case and gives up $35 in the high case.

Why does a revenue floor increase debt capacity?

Because lenders size on the low case. Raising low-case revenue from $80 to $100 a kW-year lifts low-case cash flow from $6.0m to $8.0m and debt from $42.04m to $56.05m at 1.30x.

Does a revenue floor always raise equity returns?

No. Expected IRR rises from 13.7% to 15.5% mainly because the equity cheque falls, but the high-price case drops from 32.1% to 30.1%.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Battery Storage Development Handbook value a fictional 200 MW / 800 MWh battery under merchant, toll and floor cases, with degradation, augmentation, the investment credit, the foreign entity test and debt. The figures in this article use invented inputs and are not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on energy, infrastructure and land, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: infrastructure, data centres and energy → · All 1908 articles →